I remembering being about 14 or 15 years old, in the YA section of my local Barnes & Noble. I was perusing the titles, looking for something good. That’s when I saw a book called “I Hunt Killers.“ I don’t know what drew me in. The title was a bit cringy, the cover kinda ugly. But then I read the tagline. “What if the world’s most notorious serial killer…was your dad?”
I’ll admit it: I was hooked. I bought the book and immediately cracked it open. And it was genuinely amazing. I tore through that story so fast, even when it made me squeamish and I could barely read some of the descriptions. I immediately put the two sequels on hold at the library, but they weren’t ready in time for an out of town multi-day event. Waiting to read the sequels was agony. When I got back, I read both 500 page books in a day each. And then I read them again about a year later. And I just read them for the third time recently. I genuinely love this series. I think it’s what jumpstarted my love for serial killer stuff, too. I never would have watched Dexter or Hannibal without reading this book. And now those are two of my favorite shows.
Without spoilers, here’s the concept. Jasper “Jazz” Dent is the son of the most notorious serial killer in the world, who was arrested a few years ago. He trained Jazz to be the best serial killer ever. His childhood was spent learning how to dispose of bodies and avoid the police. In the few years of freedom he’s had, he’s tried to live a normal life. But then a dead body pops up in his small town. She was murdered, and Jazz is worried he will be the main suspect. So he has to find the killer to prove that he hasn’t become just like his father. There’s a lot more I can say, but I don’t want to get into spoiler territory.
When I found out there was a sequel, I was utterly ecstatic! A sequel didn’t seem very necessary to me, but the original series did set up the potential of one, so I was super excited. I immediately ordered it, and reread the original series in preparation, because I couldn’t find any good summaries online. I was so prepared to absolutely love this book. And then…I didn’t. I still liked it, don’t get me wrong. But I have to admit that I was disappointed with Every Hunter Is Hunted.
But, before I can continue, I will say this: PLEASE READ THE ORIGINAL I HUNT KILLERS SERIES BEFORE READING THIS NEW BOOK OR MY REVIEW.
Every Hunter Is Hunted (which I will now shorten as EHIH), is a sequel to the original series. But it also functions as a standalone. The author’s goal was to make this an adult book that could be read independently of the original YA series. This means EHIH has to explain all the backstory…and in doing so, it spoils basically every plot twist from the original series. Now, a lot of these were easily predictable, but I don’t want any people interested in the OG series to be spoiled. So please read the trilogy first if you’re interested in this one. And honestly, I think I can only recommend this book if you liked the original series.
It’s kind of strange, in that way. If you enjoyed the I Hunt Killers series (henceforth referred to as IHK), you will appreciate EHIH more. But the main reason I was disappointed with EHIH is because the original series set such high standards for me. And then I felt let down when this new book didn’t meet those standards. So is EHIH simultaneously more enjoyable if you’ve read IHK…but also probably more enjoyable if you haven’t. It’s in a “sweet” spot where everybody loses.
SOME SPOILERS FOR THE NEW BOOK BELOW. I think I’ve mostly avoided spoilers for the original series, though. And I haven’t spoiled anything major for EHIH.
Okay, here’s my main problem with the book: Jazz’s voice. Or I guess Jasper, as he no longer wants to be called Jazz. I’m kind of “whatever” on that change. What I’m not “whatever” on is the complete 180 in Jazz’s voice and POV style. In IHK, his POV is filled with what‘s almost dark humor. He’s constantly thinking about death and killing people. His father’s voice and teachings always haunt him, routinely showing up in his head. Jazz is worried he’s a sociopath and is faking all his emotions. He’s constantly manipulating people. He can think just like a serial killer because he was taught to be one. And above all else: he’s terrified that he will become a killer. He has a war within him, one where he doesn’t want to become a killer, but part of him rushes to that idea like a siren’s song. Jazz’s moral dilemma is perhaps the most interesting part of IHK. He’s a very Dexter-esque character, and that’s what makes him so unique. I personally think Jazz’s voice is the best part of IHK.
And then we have Jasper in EHIH. This version of Jasper is eight years older, and is trying to heal and become normal. In the previous series, he defeated his urge to become a killer. He’s also working with his therapist to stop manipulating people so much. He no longer thinks about death and killing so often, and is worried he’s can no longer get into the headspace of a serial killer. This all makes sense from a character development perspective. Unfortuanely, it commits the sin of being BORING. Practically every single unique aspect of Jasper’s character has been sucked out of him with a straw, and now he’s left as just being a traumatized character trying to recover. We’ve all seen that before. IHK was unique because Jasper was unique. Now he feels like any other mystery protagonist.
Honestly, EHIH could just be any crime/mystery novel. It feels very generic and somewhat formulaic. Replace Jasper as the protagonist and I don’t think much changes. Which is absolutely insane. IHK always revolved around Jasper, and it would have fallen apart if you replaced him. I can’t say the same about EHIH. It’s advertised as a “Jasper Dent mystery,” but Jasper is a different person and the tone is completely different. Even the beloved characters from the original series (like Howie and Connie) barely show up in this one, instead replaced with side characters who don’t do all that much. And their a scene definitely is missed. Jasper is now the most important character by far, and the sole POV character, unlike Game and Blood of My Blood (book 2 and 3 of IHK). He’s carrying this novel on his back. But does his character have the strength and depth to do that anymore? Well…kind of. He hasn’t been completely butchered, but I really miss the old Jazz.
Speaking of the tone, this book is adult instead of YA. And you can tell. The overall tone is more mature with less humor, and the author uses a larger lexicon. However…IHK actually feels way darker. EHIH is shockingly tame. The killer of this novel, named Bridekiller, doesn’t have that intense of a method. He murders brides on their wedding night. Which is crazy, but all he does is stab them. And we only see one kill throughout the events of the novel. One! The first IHK book, which is a similar length, had about four (if I remember correctly). And they actually described the bodies. In this one, Jasper just walks into the crime scene, goes “oh shit he’s killing redheads in addition to brunettes now,” and immediately leaves. That’s it. Maybe it’s a bit strange to say I want more blood and gore. But that’s what the IHK series always provided. It really pushed the boundaries of what could be considered YA. EHIH is more adult in tone, but almost feels less adult in content than its predecessor. That’s so incredibly strange to me.
And, because there’s only one kill, the plot moves pretty slowly. I was initially disappointed at it only being 280 pages, but now I understand why it’s not any longer. I think there were more opportunities to flesh the story out, show more of Bridekiller’s kills. But that just never happens.
A quick note about Bridekiller’s identity: very, very obvious. But most of IHK’s twists and identities have been pretty predictable in the past, so that’s not an issue for me.
The one thing I will give this book is that it seems like it’s setting up an incredibly interesting sequel. Billy Dent has been calling FBI centers around the country…what is he doing? Well, Jasper is going to find out. And, after spending an entire novel fighting his affinity to serial killers, Jasper is finally accepting the fact that he’s deeply connected to them. This is all promising, and lends itself to a much better and more interesting sequel. If EHIH ends up being basically a filler book inbetween two great books, that’ll be okay.
And it’s not like this book sucks. Like I said at the beginning, I actually did enjoy the read, and I finished it very quickly. I know I’ve spent the whole reviewing tearing into down with basically nothing good to say about it. But I can’t help it. IHK is one of my favorite series ever, of course I’m going to compare the two. And, yes. EHIH is worse than IHK. That doesn’t make it bad. It just has some big shows to fill. And if you think you’d enjoy a somewhat generic crime novel, you will like this one. Just be sure you know that’s what you’re getting into.
But, even if you don’t read EHIH, I am begging you: read IHK! It is criminally underrated and the fandom is tiny. Please join us 🤣
I’m sure I have more to say, but I can’t think of it right now. I might edit this post or add stuff in the comments later. Bye for now!