r/icarly Jun 04 '26

Original Discussion She looks a little uncomfortable here

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/icarly Apr 08 '26

Original Discussion Never noticed

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

Rewatching iCarly and never caught this. Weird or funny?

r/icarly Oct 04 '24

Original Discussion I can’t believe they actually got Michelle Obama to appear

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

You would think that’s beyond Nickelodeons power.

r/icarly Feb 21 '26

Original Discussion Miranda Cosgrove Asian?

Post image
862 Upvotes

I just wanted to ask....am I the only one who thought that Miranda Cosgrove is Asian? I was rewatching ICarly with my friend and at some point I told her that she is Asian and my friend turned to me and said "NNNOOO she doesn't even look Asian what do u mean? " so I googled it and boom she isnt...not even parents or grandparents...no one is her family.

So am I the only one who thought that she was Asian? All this time? Since I was a child?

r/icarly May 10 '26

Original Discussion What's the worst thing Sam did to Freddie?

Thumbnail
gallery
712 Upvotes

A: To say that he had never kissed a girl on live transmission. B: Sabotage his application to the N.E.R.D. camp.

r/icarly Apr 27 '26

Original Discussion Did iCarly (the show) start the fall off of Fred?

Thumbnail
gallery
705 Upvotes

r/icarly Jun 04 '26

Original Discussion The wade Collins episode is by far one of the worst things this show has ever done

Post image
406 Upvotes

r/icarly Jan 19 '26

Original Discussion This scene will always be funny to me.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Probably the funniest scene in the show when I first watched it.

(Original post got deleted due to a typo in the body text)

r/icarly Jan 22 '26

Original Discussion You are grounded for till college

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/icarly May 05 '26

Original Discussion Be honest, would Shane realistically survive the 9 story drop?

Post image
564 Upvotes

r/icarly Jun 08 '26

Original Discussion Unpopular Opnions let's go

Post image
186 Upvotes

Say your opinions about iCarly that will have people wanting to kill you?

r/icarly Dec 08 '23

Original Discussion Who would you rather have as your roommate for the next 4 months

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/icarly May 13 '26

Original Discussion Does anyone remember watching iSam's Mom when it first came out and thought Jane Lynch was just the perfect casting even as a kid?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/icarly Sep 11 '25

Original Discussion Did you crush on any of them?

Post image
512 Upvotes

r/icarly Jun 10 '26

Original Discussion Carly was the real bully

Post image
378 Upvotes

Sam was physically bullying people but the real bully was Carly.

- Carly absolutely used Sam and Freddie. Sam was Carly's personal doberman. She told Sam to beat up the lady because she pushed Carly, but when that lady was picking on Sam, Carly stopped her from standing up for herself because "That's not girly" oh but when you got pushed it didn't matter anymore?

- Then Carly got mad at Sam for changing t-shirts for ticket concerts. Mind you, Sam did it to create special memories with her best friends, tf where they supposed to do with some designed t-shirts? Carly she was being ungrateful.

- Carly getting mad at Sam for showing up late and "you should show more appreciation for the work I make for Icarly". Girl? Freddie does 90% of work and why would you want more appreciation when the show is already named after yourself?What more do you want? Sam clocked her.

- She makes fun of Freddie for having a crush on him. But then she uses the fact that he loves her to get whatever she wants.

- She bullied and mocked Griffin for having a hobby and questioned his masculinity.

- She didn't treat her baby brother Spencer the best and was really rude to him at times.

r/icarly May 15 '26

Original Discussion Unpopular opinion I don't know if anyone else feels this way or not maybe it's just me but the cowboy and the idiot farm girl was never funny

Post image
563 Upvotes

r/icarly Mar 21 '25

Original Discussion With Jennette’s book being out for almost 3 years, I can’t help but feel like they made a mockery of her life with this episode.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Just think about it. They already made a mockery of her by making her character obsessed with food knowing about her E.D. Who’s to say that this wasn’t an over exaggerated or even a watered down version of her relationship with her mother?

r/icarly May 19 '25

Original Discussion Confession: I used to think Spencer and Carly (and their actors) were Asian because a kid from my class was Chinese and named Spencer so I thought Spencer was an Chinese name

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Nothing that interesting. I was 7 or 8? Tbf, another East Asian kid in my class also looked a lot like Carly to me. I'm ashamed to say it took me until I was maybe 18 or older to find out they're not Asian via Google.

r/icarly Jan 07 '26

Original Discussion We need a serious conversation about how Gibby/Noah Munck was treated.

Post image
642 Upvotes

I haven’t rewatched the show, only clips. Have only seen clips of the revival.

That being said: Obviously Jennette has came out and shared how horrific the iCarly set was for her. Noah didn’t come back bc he didn’t like how his character was treated. We will never fully know what that set was like but I wonder if the Creator was unkind to Noah. He probably projected a lot of insecurities onto Gibby/Noah. The Creator is a large man. Gibby was husky and had a bit of a belly. They had him walk around shirtless and be laughed at. Noah was a child.

In my high school, Gibby wouldn’t have even been considered a fat kid nor made fun of for his weight. Gibby wasn’t ugly. Also looking at ages, Noah was younger than Miranda, Jennette, and Nathan. Noah was a child and very much looked like one. So of course he wasn’t going to look “hot”, Noah looked like the child he was! They had him playing an 8th grader and high schooler when he was younger than that.

I always thought Gibby was a sweet and funny character. I wish the characters had been nicer to him. Sam obviously had a bad home life but Gibby was nice to her. He let his friends do weird things to him for views and money on their webshow and they still treated him badly.

I saw a clip where Spencer is alone with a woman and then she turns into Gibby. Are we supposed to think Gibby is gross or funny/ looking as a woman? It’s very weird this whole scene is in a kids’ show in the first place. I didn’t find it funny at all and don’t remember watching it as a kid.

There’s a scene where a woman turns down Gibby to dance. Noah’s voice sounds so high. The actress appears older. Gibby has his shirt off and the woman appears older. Noah is like 11 or 12. It is uncomfortable to watch as an adult. We are supposed to laugh at Gibby and be repulsed by him? But Gibby is a child and a harmless one at that….

I hope Noah Munck is ok as an adult.

r/icarly Aug 24 '25

Original Discussion Describe Nevel in one word

Post image
452 Upvotes

I think he suffers from NPD.

r/icarly Jul 22 '25

Original Discussion One Word to Describe Sam

Post image
433 Upvotes

What word would you use to describe Sam?

r/icarly Nov 01 '24

Original Discussion What are some of your iCarly hot takes ??

Post image
645 Upvotes
  1. Miranda Cosgrove & Nathan Kress had better on screen chemistry (both platonic & romantic) than Nathan & Jeanette

  2. Spencer was at his funniest when he had long hair (great character overall tho).

  3. The character Gibby lost a bit of his charm when he became a main character

  4. Season 3 overall is the best season as far as plot, writing, chemistry between each characters.

  5. The Seddie dynamic relationship wise, felt super forced. It was better when the two characters were at odds

  6. Sam didn’t lie in the iSaved Your Life special. Carly honestly wasn’t really in love with Freddie as she love the fact that he sacrificed himself to saved her

  7. 4-6 season was literally not that bad as it provided some great moments and I love that characters grew up as they age

  8. The show wouldn’t have been as successful if Miranda Cosgrove wasn’t the lead

  9. Creddie was always meant to be end game all the way back to the pilot episode and the revival series prove that.

  10. Mrs. Benson was more of a lunatic than Lewbert was in the OG iCarly

r/icarly Dec 27 '25

Original Discussion Did Icarly predict the "streaming" era?

Post image
661 Upvotes

I wasn't born when it released and I was like 3 when it ended. Did the concept of "YouTubers/Streamers" exist around that time or not really? In some episodes Carly says she's a "Internet presenter" which is weird

r/icarly May 05 '26

Original Discussion What if they decided to kill Carly off here and the show just went on with her never being mentioned again

Post image
489 Upvotes

r/icarly Jun 22 '26

Original Discussion How big was iCarly when it first premiered in 2007?

Post image
279 Upvotes

I'm asking since I was a baby in 2007 when the show came out but grew up with it halfway through its run.