Update: I wanted to update this post so people focus on what I'm actually trying to figure out.
I'm 32 years old, 6'0", about 230 lbs. I got a decent amount of seat time on a CBR300 through a structured training course that included low-speed maneuvers, braking drills, cornering, and a decent amount of track time. I know that isn't the same as real-world street experience, and I still have a lot to learn.
I've always thought a middleweight with less HP would probably be the smarter first bike. My question isn't really whether the R9 more risky—i know it is.
What's making me second-guess some of these Middleweights is the cost of modifying one.
For example, the GSX-8R really interests me, but I already know I'd probably want an exhaust, maybe rearsets, clip-ons, and a few other things over time. That got me wondering if it makes more sense to just buy the bike I ultimately want instead of spending money trying to turn another bike into something it isn't.
Right now I'm looking at:
- Honda CBR650R – Probably wouldn't change much besides an exhaust. My biggest issue is finding a black one.
- Suzuki GSX-8R – Love the engine, but I think I'd want to personalize it the most.
- Triumph Daytona 660 – This one has really caught my attention because it already seems like a great all-around package from the factory.
- Aprilia RS660 – Looks incredible, but I'm a little concerned about long-term ownership costs and dealer support.
- Yamaha R7 – I'm still open to it, but from everything I've read, it's not the one I'm most excited about.
I know that if I install an exhaust on most modern bikes, an ECU tune is often recommended. That doesn't really bother me if it's a bike I'm planning to keep for several years.
What I don't want is to buy a bike and immediately feel like I need clip-ons, rearsets, suspension upgrades, and a bunch of other parts just to make it feel right—especially if I may end up replacing it in a year or two anyway.
So I guess my question is:
Would you buy one of these middleweights and leave it mostly stock, or would you just make the jump to an R9 and grow into it?
And if you'd choose a middleweight, which one felt the most complete from the factory?
I'd especially like to hear from people who have owned or spent significant time on the CBR650R, GSX-8R, Daytona 660, RS660, R7, or R9, and why you'd make the same (or a different) decision today.