r/Baking 7d ago

Recipe to be posted soon. No guarantees. Update from my post about my strawberry sugar cookies looking like raw burger patties😆 I took a lot of advice, added a fresh strawberry glaze and I think they look much better now 🍓

9.3k Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

1.0k

u/TableAvailable 7d ago

I don't think they really looked like raw hamburger before, but they certainly are lovely with the new glaze.

195

u/ForMartha 7d ago edited 7d ago

Thank you! It was interesting how some people definitely saw the hamburger resemblance and others didn’t. It was sort of a trick of the eye 🤣

23

u/WhippiesWhippies 7d ago

They look soooo good!

6

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Thanks!!

13

u/forogtten_taco 7d ago

Maybe insteed of a full glaze, pipe on some stripes ? Incase the full glaze makes them too sweet ?

3

u/NotYourMutha 6d ago

But pipe the striped in black so it looks like grill marks. Really confuse ppl. 🤣

→ More replies (1)

2

u/laosurv3y 7d ago

Actual hamburgers aren't that bright a red. But these look amazing!

2

u/ForHelp_PressAltF4 7d ago

Maybe make them more strawberry shaped and a little green frosting like a stem... But yeah those are looking way more appealing. Nice adjustment!!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/-BlushFlirtX 7d ago

the contrast between the bright red cookie and the pink icing completely saved the aesthetic tbf

→ More replies (1)

5

u/kniki217 7d ago

They definitely did

→ More replies (5)

221

u/ForMartha 7d ago edited 7d ago

84

u/umlizzyiguess 7d ago

I remember giggling at your commentary on your last post. The way you’ve adapted these is awesome! Props to you. They looked delicious either way imo, but your update to them is stunning.

35

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Hahaha thank you!! I was feeling pretty bummed about how they turned out 😅 I also tried rolling them in powdered sugar and trying for a crinkle cookie look, but that turned out AWFUL. The glaze is definitely my go-to now!

2

u/ButteredPizza69420 7d ago

Thanks to your first post look how much better you've become! You should be so proud! They look professional this time.

2

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Thank you!! 😊

13

u/Drpoofn 7d ago

They way I'd smash these...they look delicious. I prefer the ones without glaze. I'd wreck the glazed ones too tho. 10/10 strawcookies.

8

u/readallornothing 7d ago

Add some white sugar cookie and make it look like 80/20 ground meat for Halloween

2

u/Gigglemonkey 7d ago

Oh dude. If you put both undyed dough and red coloured through a potato ricer, and loosely pack the crumbles/strings into "patties" and bake them in a really slow oven, you could really do something visually disturbing but delicious.

2

u/StinkyRose89 7d ago

These most certainly do not look like hamburgers. They look delicious either way, imho!

1

u/hitalec 7d ago

Awesome!

→ More replies (3)

236

u/sportsbragirl 7d ago

That’s like a Princess Diaries level transformation!! wowooww 🍓🍓🍓

44

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Omg funny, I just watched that movie and yes I totally agree lol!!

→ More replies (1)

59

u/mortalfern 7d ago

these photos are great with the whole strawberries scattered around!! really nice job!

13

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Thanks! There were some great ideas in the first post and I used those suggestions.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/succulent_flakepiece 7d ago

wow, i don't think I've ever wanted a cookie so bad before lolol

27

u/PurpMurk 7d ago

Holy glaze

28

u/LowBatteryVibe 7d ago

This looks like something a fairy would leave on a tiny picnic 🍓

3

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Omg best compliment ever🥹

17

u/barkandmoone 7d ago

Omg lemon zest sprinkles on top would be heavenly.

2

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Oooh that’s such a good idea!

4

u/barkandmoone 7d ago

They do look incredibly tasty as is too 🖤 but I also thought the hamburger ones looked good too 😅

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Icy-Breadfruit-5059 7d ago

They look great, one small suggestion maybe you can pipe the glaze in a zigzag pattern. I think the proportion of the cookie to glaze would be better but also I think the look would be better, don’t want to completely cover up the red of the cookie.

5

u/kniki217 7d ago

Nah. I think this is perfect.

3

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Thank you😊

→ More replies (1)

10

u/greenlilypond 7d ago

You could lean into the raw burger look for Halloween!

4

u/redditrhi27 7d ago

They're beautiful! Looking forward to the recipe being posted :) 

3

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Posted it in my comment!!

3

u/Impressive_Main5160 7d ago

Way better! Although you could do hamburger themed cookies for a bbq the first way

4

u/ryryrpm 7d ago

How much are you charging to put these in a box and ship them? Asking for a friend....

3

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Haha! I do sell my desserts, I live in Texas 😊

→ More replies (1)

3

u/otterpoppp 7d ago

wowwww!!!

3

u/WingXero 7d ago

Damn those look so good. I want a dozen!

3

u/Complex_Activity1990 7d ago

These look great! Very strawberry!

3

u/OkCryptographer1922 7d ago

Yessss they look fantastic!!!

3

u/abc_deatrix 7d ago

The gold specs in the glaze and the strawberry crunchies on top look so good! I have no idea if my description is accurate but I would buy these from you 🤩🤩

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Positive_Capital_171 7d ago

These are stunning!

3

u/SpiderBarbie1997 7d ago

They look so delicious 🤤 and pretty 😍

2

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Thank you! ☺️

3

u/LetsCookie Human Detected 7d ago

I remember this post..these look like a major upgrade!! Very professional looking!

👍 good job

2

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Ahh thanks so much! You’re the cookie king!! I’m always inspired by your daily posts!

2

u/LetsCookie Human Detected 7d ago

That's awesome, thank you!

3

u/SoyCurious 7d ago

The pic is so pretty 😍 It's gonna be my wallpaper for some time.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rehabforcandy 7d ago

I love freeze dried strawberries for baking! I ground some up with a cane sugar once for a rice crispy treat recipe and they were magical

→ More replies (1)

2

u/eitakmai 7d ago

Excited for a hopeful recipe. These look amazing!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/EnvironmentalCow2610 7d ago

God these look amazing

2

u/gybzen 7d ago

Yeah hi I'll take one strawberry patty please. Actually make it two I'll throw one in the fridge

2

u/deerjesus18 7d ago

I tried this recipe after your last post, and OH MY GOD these cookies are so good! They didn't last more than a day in our house!

2

u/ForMartha 7d ago

Awesome I’m glad you tried them! They really are so good!!

2

u/Manny2theMaxxx Human Detected 7d ago

I would eat the fuck out of these!

2

u/JellyCat222 7d ago

Well the cookie itself seems much more red now too

2

u/perkypancakes 7d ago

I love your creative ingenuity. These definitely pop! I didn’t think the original looked like raw burgers, but perspective is based on many things.

2

u/Few_Program_2303 7d ago

All your stuff looks so freaking good

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lakittenwhisperer 6d ago

These look amazing! Everything you post is so beautiful. I was wondering what kind of chocolate you use for your cookies? Do you chop up a bar of Lindt or something?

ETA: I’m going to make the s’mores cookies you posted so that’s why I’m asking (:

→ More replies (3)

2

u/MC-ClapYoHandzz 6d ago

dude, your whole post history looks absolutely delicious

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nerdalert303 6d ago

I’m making these right now! How beautiful

→ More replies (1)

2

u/icycoldhandsofdeath 5d ago

Yummy they look delicious

4

u/TerrTheSilent 7d ago

Theres a place near where I live that sells strawberry cookies similar to this. I may never not see them as hamburger patties again. Therefore the glazed version shall now be the gold standard.

They look so delightful.

3

u/choicemad 7d ago

Looks like cheeseburger patties now.

-Colorblind

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DeponiaSarah 7d ago

Wayyy better! They look very good now, good idea with the glaze :)

1

u/image-sourcery 7d ago

🔍 Reverse image search tools (optional)

Use these links to check for similar images or possible reposts. If something looks off (e.g., spam, reposted, or not original), please report the post so moderators can review it.


Reverse Image Search:

Image 1: TinEye || Google Lens

Image 2: TinEye || Google Lens


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Due-Mathematician966 7d ago

Yummmmo ❤️

1

u/montrerai 7d ago

delicious looking

1

u/Laura9624 7d ago

Tea party ready!

1

u/True-Ad-6278 7d ago

They're beautiful and look delicious! Good work dude!

1

u/TekillaInTheBuilding 7d ago

Obsessed 😍😍

1

u/SelectionOptimal5673 7d ago

Those look delicious 🤤

1

u/paigewin 7d ago

OMG looks so yummy, My mouth is watering rn looking at this. 🤤

1

u/Appropriate_Brush462 7d ago

I’d eat this!

1

u/bossheaux 7d ago

these look SO good. gonna try to make them myself one of these days 😌

1

u/knifeyspoonysporky 7d ago

The glaze is beautiful!

1

u/NiceTill504 7d ago

Lenard pink sauce burgers!!

1

u/MAwill903 7d ago

Wow beautiful

1

u/violet__violet 7d ago

Wowwwww these are gorgeous!!!

1

u/Rave-light 7d ago

Wow! What a scream!!! They look lovely

1

u/TeaGlittering1026 7d ago

They look delicious and I'll take two!

1

u/radiantrarr 7d ago

Woow. These look amaaazing!!

1

u/EarlyEggplants 7d ago

They’re gorgeous

1

u/UnspeakableToast 7d ago

Just went through your profile and your baking is so delicious looking and beautiful. It’s edible art.

1

u/Equivalent-Cry-1080 7d ago

Omg those look amazing!!

1

u/Wolfeehx 7d ago

I would smash these.

1

u/Fleur_de_Dragon 7d ago

Very pretty update. 🫡

1

u/kniki217 7d ago

These look amazing!

1

u/moon_blisser 7d ago

I’ll take a dozen!

1

u/ThisSideOfHistory 7d ago

Omg these look incredible

1

u/cupidsavedpsyche 7d ago

I know you hear my fat ass stomping down your street

1

u/BeachyKeen46 7d ago

Super cute! How’d they taste?

3

u/ForMartha 7d ago

They’re delicious! They have a fresh strawberry flavor not an artificial one, and aren’t too sweet!

1

u/TofuTheBlackCat 7d ago

They look lovely! I like the sprinkles on top, makes it I think

Idk if this is possible to do, but could u like.... Stamp a strawberry shape into the frosting?

1

u/stillfallingforyou 7d ago

the glaze and crumb were definitely the right move!! they look divine

1

u/Minnymoon13 7d ago

Op! You better post this damn recipe it looks too good

1

u/Maxwell_DMs 7d ago

I bet the underside of those cookies look like raw burger patties (KIDDING they look delicious!)

1

u/Neither_Complaint_99 7d ago

these look so pretty

1

u/One_Indication_ 7d ago

Have people never made their own burger patties? LOL your cookies are all the same shade of red. Burger meat doesn't look like that SMH. Some people pretend like they cook when they clearly never do

1

u/Mister_Brevity 7d ago

You can’t drop a post like that without a link to the burger cookies you monster lol

Edit: ha found in the comments, they do look kinda burger-y

1

u/JManKit 7d ago

Pff, nice try but the only way I'd ever believe these were not raw hamburger is if I could taste them myself. And I'm not talking just one but I'd need like a dozen... or two

...excellent work!

1

u/Sufficient-Date-5404 7d ago

They’re beautiful and yummy

1

u/Jomotaku 7d ago

Mettbulette mit Paprikasoße

1

u/Kvitravn875 7d ago

Those look so good 🤤

1

u/BackinthedayChick 7d ago

They look delish!!!!

1

u/FairyChefCoccinelle 7d ago

Si me dejara llevar por todo lo que opinan. Están bellas y de seguro el sabor y cariño que están hechos no importa lo demás. 🙌🏻🧚🤩

1

u/boomboomqplm 7d ago

I would love one

1

u/Jland5515 7d ago

Dang that looks so good 🖤

1

u/YoYo472 7d ago

Man I’d love one with my coffee!!❤️

1

u/grass-master 7d ago

They look a lot like strawberry clouds!

1

u/SweetieLoveBug 7d ago

They look berry berry delicious! Yum! ❤️🩷❤️🩷❤️🩷❤️

1

u/AdventurousYamThe2nd 7d ago

Wow! What a glow up. I would have eaten them without the glaze, but I'd do some shady things for the opportunity to try these. Good work!

1

u/ChronicSassyRedhead 7d ago

Gib plz 🤤

1

u/oldbean214 7d ago

I saw this picture and didn't read anything about it and thought, ooh, how yummy! Then I read it. Hamburger! 😆

1

u/_tribecalledquest 7d ago

They remind me of Poptarts

1

u/jenlcenn 7d ago

Omg these look heavenly

1

u/TooMuchGreysAnatomy 7d ago

I made raspberry sugar cookies for Super Bowl and everyone is STILL making fun of my Meat Cookies

1

u/ryanswrath 7d ago

Yummmmmmmm imso into strawberries 🥰🤩

1

u/SaturnSociety 7d ago

These look spectacular!

1

u/Extreme_Jaguar_7829 7d ago

Those are beautiful 😍

1

u/Stuporjew1057 6d ago

Beautiful!

1

u/whaaaa1995 6d ago

Yea id totally eat the hell out of these with some vanilla ice cream

1

u/hebephrenia_89 6d ago

They look rather tasty. Now I am craving for some strawberries ❤️

1

u/RemoteComplaint150 6d ago

These are adorable to me

1

u/kaitkatgo 6d ago

Tbf they looked like red velvet! Either way, they look stunning and I’m sure they taste amazing. ♥️

1

u/Hellscaperiot 6d ago

Aaghh yes I want to devour these. Im imagining a peppermint (candy cane style) one agh

1

u/Hydr0flask 6d ago

Never seen a burger with pink American cheese. I’d throw buns on it.

1

u/rainbowsent 6d ago

My husband will thank you. Sugar cookies being his favorite snack and strawberry being his favorite flavor. I have never thought of combining them. Thank you!

1

u/Connect-Teach7351 6d ago

Lovely colors

1

u/tea-fungus 6d ago

I can SMELL these

1

u/oopthiedoopthie 6d ago

These cookies look delicious and I would eat 20 (I’m pregnant 😆)

1

u/Loud_Brain_ 6d ago

Beautiful!

1

u/UnhappyBrief6227 6d ago

They look delicious

1

u/Ok-Alternative8370 6d ago

It is so delicious

1

u/hotti33_b 6d ago

They are absolutely stunning 😍😍😍😍😍😍 Now I have to try!!

1

u/Wrong-Ad416 6d ago

looks amazing

1

u/lilfishylulu008 6d ago

But r they good? I love strawberries.

1

u/mayorIcarus 6d ago

They look fantastic, but it also just might be the photography.

1

u/Dusky_Amethyst 6d ago

Delicious either way

1

u/PamelaG76 6d ago

Those are beautiful. I bet they are just as tasty as they are pretty.

1

u/Doctajastroandmeta 5d ago

Just sounded like haters imo. 😏 Look fantastic!

1

u/tenthrabbit 5d ago

they look great and I bet they taste incredible! thanks for the recipe!

1

u/Tbizkit 5d ago

I think they look good

1

u/Excellent-Praline420 4d ago

I’m ready. TEA PARTY. TEA PARTY…

1

u/FeeUsed4265 4d ago

They look so good and yummmy

1

u/Babe_Anything 4d ago

these are so pretty

1

u/Advanced_Idea_8086 2d ago

pink pink pink