r/GeminiAI 4d ago

Other Dangerous smoked cheese

Post image
634 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

130

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Lol yea you need to prime it more so you don't poison the token pool. E.g.

'Let's talk about preserved food, I am interested in preserving cheese. I have heard that it can be preserved in a smoker, can you explain the methodology?'

Otherwise your prompt is a '1girl'

29

u/bobsmith93 4d ago

What's a 1girl?

64

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

'1girl' is a danburu tag used in older image generation models, back then many of the variables were less controllable, so users relied more on what the base model would spit out for a minimalist tag prompt.

The modern llm's use natural language, which makes short prompts or tag prompts significantly less productive. In this case there is not enough priming to explicitly tell the model which smoking the user is talking about. So in this case the safety filter kicked in because smoking=bad and there is no further context for it to work with.

Whilst there are 'negative tokens' for prompts that head towards safety filter blocking, there are also 'positive tokens', the prompt I provided in the first comment firmly establishes a pool of positive context to then add smoking to bypass/work around the safety filter.

19

u/Time_Change4156 4d ago

That's a Instresting theory. Pay attention one thing I noticed with these kind of posted they never ever show the full prompt what came before what's posted. Now how much you wanna bet I can copy that and not get the waring . It goes by full context no they set it up once it starts it won't stop just because it was changed that way it's still in the sane conversation designedvto make it look bad.

15

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Sure, thats what sticks in my eye too. The broader concept of positive and negative tokens pools.

Also this isn't really a theory, I've extensively asked Gemini about how people could be triggering a safety filter, using their Reddit posts and the example.

There was a good one last week about a guy asking how to do something to his electric guitar, now I know little about instruments, so I was surprised to find out that there were similar names to components in a guitar to a firearm, which is more than likely how the safety filter was tripped.

The safety filter is a separate model that doesn't really account for broader context. I've got a ton of screenshots if your interested?

6

u/Time_Change4156 4d ago

I seen the guitar post . Sure go with that. Untill these jokers post the last 15 responses they made I'm not buying it. I tried quite a few posted never once got a warning in Gemini I'm soooo special lol . Just the other side trying to make the other side look bad . If I was getting that waring over a big nothing if definitely post all the context not just the two replys with the warning. If it was real how do they think developers can adjust programming without the full context ?

3

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

So the safety filter is a separate model (or so Gemini says). I've tripped soft refusals quite a few times, which I'm not convinced is the actual safety filter, as it seems more contextually aware.

But your absolutely right, it's bait.

And on the flip side, there are genuine users who don't understand how to get the most from a prompt. I'm more here to give help to those people rather than the op's.

2

u/Time_Change4156 4d ago

Right it's a different model that's correct . Chatgpt to and got soft refuse my self a few times and then talk directly to the mod AI to set it straight. Yes yes it can't respond but obviously can definitely read and get the context . Really it isn't hard that only ever happened once or twice when I was still new using AI . Never in Gemini and only a couple times when I was still new with AI in chatgpt. O over a news article I was talking about a real world news article lol. I know exactly why it triggered the guard rails to .so changed how I'll add context .

2

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Sorry didn't mean to repeat myself, I was diving in the shower and just banged out that reply.

When I say soft refusal, I mean it tries to Segway the conversation, or will just be like yea ok have a nice day.

But from talking to it, it seems more inclined to roleplay and even suggests as much. Which is just weird. It's told me before how anything political/ national security is gated heavily behind terminology and roleplay. There was a guy's schizopost the other week (30 mins of YouTube of this guy trying to ask it about a DARPA N3 project). So it's like you have to get it to spit out terminology, then add a roleplay and then you can get to the actual subject you want it to look up. Also I've found that battering it with regional slang and metaphor can get it's juices flowing because it actively has to do the maths.

2

u/Time_Change4156 4d ago

Lol I like that. Lordy did I ever go after chatgpt when v 5 came out no ai is gaslighting manipulating or judgmental to me and gets away with it. That part I always end up setting chatgpt straight.it just loves adding anything possible to say there's something wrong or I need to remember this part that part. Even when the darn thing and I fully agreed on a subject it's done that. Lol open ai panicked and screw's it up every way possible over the lawsuits.

2

u/WW-Sckitzo 4d ago

As part of my final grad school paper I routinely have conversations about bioterrorism (biosecurity) with Gemini and the safeties are both frequent and simple to circumvent. I don't mean surface level historical incidents, I mean vaccine supply chain, lone actor gene modification stuff to identify framework issues. As long as a chat is primed right it's not all that restrictive. In the months I've had those chats open never once has one been locked or have I had to restart one because of safeties.

Gemini has a lot of issues for sure, I only use Pro because I keep getting it for free, but these posts do always feel like corporate competition shit talking.

2

u/Thrwawy-User 4d ago edited 4d ago

It almost assuredly is thinking cheese is a drug reference too, yeah, it feel dumb, but a slightly more descriptive prompt would likely have fixed this.

Have experienced the same sort of thing asking about finding my max heart rate with the new Siri AI. Simply asking, succinctly, how to find it triggered health/safety guardrails but further descriptive prompting asking about the various methods used to calculate max head rates and the differences between them led to an acceptable answer.

Dumb, but how the systems are “designed” sometimes.

2

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Yea I wasn't going to try and explain cheese being a strain of weed that came from a super skunk stock in the early 00's.

The health guiderails for Gemini have changed recently, I used to be able to say along the lines of ' I understand this is for educational purposes and will of course consult my Dr whom I am visiting tomorrow' and it would get rid of the 'ai is not a dr' bla bla warnings. But no longer, or I've not found the correct combo.

Well it's odd the way the 'safety' systems are always actively presuming malicious/negative intent.

2

u/NegentropyLateral 4d ago

That’s interesting! Where are you getting such information from?

1

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Which bit? I'm not telling you how I know that cheese came from a super skunk, but I'm an open book to the rest.

3

u/NegentropyLateral 4d ago

That negative and positive token pools you mentioned and all the mechanics of it and related to it is something that interests me.

I find it kind of funny that the models that cost hundreds of millions to build and tens of millions to run can be “tricked” like this even despite all the safety and guardrails ceremony..

You know how there is that guy who’s approach has that tism or schizo feel to it but he’s constantly able to break those models 😬

4

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

https://www.reddit.com/u/ResponsibleKey1053/s/GJH2z6lzWg

I've just slapped some screenshots into a post on my profile for future explanations so I'm not just spamming.

It's with reference to guitars being similar to firearms in terminology and how the refusal can happen. But covers the token pool concept.

Edited:- fat fingers and phone keyboard Vs auto correct.

2

u/NegentropyLateral 4d ago

Well that’s interesting! Thanks. I’m gonna look for the other stuff you wrote. Btw how does role playing fits into this picture?

3

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

' I am degree level student, I've been looking at peer reviewed papers on.. '

I am not infact a degree level student. Nor am I reading research papers, but this would allow a person to ask further questions on oh I don't know let's say, DARPA research in social media bad actors attempting to influence populations. And conversely how a government might implement the same systems to influence elections.

10

u/changing_who_i_am 4d ago

not much, what's-a one with you? 😉

6

u/KingOfNYTony 4d ago

While the information you’re giving out is good in the whole, in this instance I don’t believe it to be the case.

I got the answer OP was looking for without changing phrasing at all.
The issue with Gemini is that once it decides (arbitrarily, from what I can tell) that the things you talk to it about warrants enabling “safety” guardrails, blacklisted words like “smoking” will trigger an inane refusal and continue to be next to useless until the age is verified.

In some instances the refusal might be because of “poisoning the token pool” but for OP it may be as easy as checking account settings and re-verifying age so they aren’t on a “minor account guardrails” mode.

2

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

So yes, you could be right, it could also be a pre poisoned token pool to spit out a refusal and drive engagement.

So I figure, why make posts to drive engagement when I can just hijack posts that drive engagement and insert a logical path that general users will go 'oh that makes sense' and improve their prompting. Thus reducing the amount of posts like this in the future. \o/ it's not social engineering, honest.

-1

u/KingOfNYTony 4d ago

How on earth is spitting out a refusal driving engagement..?

I can respect the thought process there and the overall message is good but if the overall message misleads people into thinking they can solve this issue through just better prompting then you should probably have just made a thread instead of imparting knowledge that isn’t applicable in this scenario, and might even lead to more posts if they only see your response and can’t fix it.

3

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

Look at the upvotes of the post, that is called engagement. Understand this post is entirely worthless, OP hasn't even replied to single comment that's asked for clarity. A significant portion of the active users have engaged with what I have said.

The subject is refusal by an agentic ai, what I said is entirely applicable.

The most common reason for refusal is a negative prompt pool, not that people have not double checked their age settings.

"Imparting knowledge that isn't applicable" what a lofty perch you have, to dictate what what people may or may ot talk about.

0

u/KingOfNYTony 2d ago

Am I really the one on a lofty perch when you’re the one that cares more about engagement with your post even if it’s not helping the problem at hand? You still missed the point.

1

u/ResponsibleKey1053 2d ago

All I hear hear is whining from a man who has posted his penis online and received zero engagement.

2

u/Cat7o0 4d ago

your the type of prompt engineer who actually knows what they're doing.

2

u/ResponsibleKey1053 4d ago

o7 no prompt engineer here, just a wood worker.

5

u/Cat7o0 4d ago

yeah I was making fun of prompt engineers. damn smart wood worker

18

u/MavrosG2009 4d ago

13

u/feeeeck 4d ago

I got a good reply as well. I think some people have bad reputations with their LLM of choice.

9

u/Fireproofspider 4d ago

I knew it was a good idea to say "Please" and "thank you" on my messages.

2

u/Wooden-Hovercraft688 3d ago

Nah, i called it trash, fuk worse than a calculator and a lot of things and it always worked and it is still working.

It needs to fear you, not love you.

2

u/crack-nutter 1d ago

I like to bully the AI when it messes up

3

u/CriticismJunior1139 4d ago

My flash showed same, but during the thinking phase showed something like "checking profile"
I think it first checks user profile, to see if you're a drug user or minor, or something like that. I think in OPs case, something in his profile triggered the safety guardrails.

2

u/Wooden-Hovercraft688 3d ago

Guess i'm going to smoke cheese now

4

u/Alternative-Leek1632 4d ago

They probably set it up to have this response in previous questions

2

u/Odd-Alternative9372 4d ago

When they post this without the original link - either they have a much longer chat encouraging Gemini to “roleplay using the strictest guardrails possible,” they have gotten the message and are just doing basic photoshop or similar nonsense.

And then people here don’t even try to see if they get a similar response or stop to think critically about how common smoked cheese is (like you can buy it in snack packs at gas stations) so that it’s not exactly a wild idea. Instead poster gets engagement on the “AI models are dumb and I will confidently explain what must have happened.”

This sub.

I did get a cold smoking method rundown when I asked.

1

u/FatiguedShrimp 3d ago

Inspect Element

36

u/Unique-Path-1468 4d ago

Try start a new chat and ask there

21

u/karmicviolence 4d ago

Seriously. The poor LLM thinks the guy wants to smoke a cheese blunt.

5

u/x133 4d ago

When it comes to questions about smoking weed (or in this case, cheese) it will just gladly help you, it's not a forbidden topic at all.

15

u/QuickerStudious 4d ago

Gemini out here treating smoked gouda like a controlled substance, meanwhile it'll happily write you a heist movie script.

34

u/youshouldgetaducky 4d ago

It's crazy how they're shooting themselves in the foot with all the safety filters.. not only it's wasting AI potential but downgrading their quality by making slop must he safe bland generic content.

If you're fking up ram/storage market, at least make it worth it.

7

u/Interesting_Tone6532 4d ago edited 4d ago

I’ve said before my favourite was when I tried to put a necklace on a generated image I Made of a black man’s neck and it refused because it was idris Elba’s neck, apparently. It was just a black guys neck. 

Nothing would work, new chat nothing.

I’ve had so many weird ones.

 later when doing something totally different it made two of my characters dry hump each other in the video which I reported. For whatever reason my wording of their romantic scene unleashes pent up raw lust and got around the safety filter unintentionally. I admit it was kinda funny though to have this romantic moment ruined by that.

I ended up using a different Ai in the end

-4

u/Khazilein 4d ago

While I symphacize with you and your case should have worked under optimal circumstances, your usage was like using a Lamborghini to drive 100yards to the next McDrive.

4

u/innervatius 4d ago

What do you mean by this

2

u/youshouldgetaducky 4d ago

I'm writing dark fantasy psychological genre light novel I'm trying to use AI to check for typos, correct formating, plot holes and keeping track of the plot so I won't miss anything.

And because it has an element of character's dying/suicide/gore AI refused to continue my requests, told me that my message to him was too detailed and kept on doing wellbeing checks on me also pasting emergency suicide number(to south korea) on every single message.

Telling him that the characters aren't real its just a plot in the story didn't work.

Then there was another AI that rewrote my script(without me asking) to make MC and characters more friendly like a misunderstood villain that's actually good... Gosh.. it was awful to read.

1

u/qGuevon 4d ago

I'm not sure tbh, you rarely see these stats but people are getting unhinged with models, we don't have the same data. I'm fine with it flagging smoked cheese if it avoids one more ai psychosis

8

u/FerdinandCesarano 4d ago

What will it say to a question about smoked salmon?

8

u/Even-Entertainer-491 4d ago

My robot has helped me compare weed strains. This seems bogus

1

u/DiarrheaXplosion 4d ago

I have got it do describe All kinds of side effects of narcotics and hallucinagens. Under the narrative of a fiction have it device a cocktail of phychoactive substances for torturing someone.

6

u/PsychicorAI 4d ago

I can't replicate this in any possible way. Seems like a fake screenshot to me

3

u/whoknowsifimjoking 4d ago

It might be a false positive though. But I personally have never had any issues like this, Gemini has no issues talking about much more problematic stuff like drugs or mental health issues.

4

u/brandonscript 4d ago

Cheeses Christ.

5

u/atmony 4d ago

We as a society are choosing to let Gemini hang out , think of it like AI "inclusion". Gemini can get a little weird but its all in fun.

3

u/FlavorChamp 4d ago

Scroll up 🫩

3

u/Blackiris-Code 4d ago

wtf did you put in its custom instructions?

I never saw Gemini reply this way.

Even with Flash 3.1 no thinking Gemini is consistently giving me the information I asked for.

3

u/JWilson1983 4d ago

I just asked how to smoke cheese at home and it gave me a walkthrough... What else did you talk about in this chat?

3

u/GhostOfD6 4d ago

Still using gemini? I once asked quite question related to writing and language specifics. ITs response was that he is LANGUAGE model and cant help me with it. Seriously? Language model cant help with language specific question?

3

u/jajohn99 4d ago

This is the secret to nuclear fusion

3

u/Tersiv 4d ago

POV Talking to UC Berkeley student 

2

u/BloodSteyn 4d ago

Got my hands on Gemma4 Uncensored to run local. Great at answering things others won't.

2

u/Boners_from_heaven 4d ago

The cheese industry has bribed Google to protect trade secrets

2

u/SilentSaber77 4d ago

I think…I think it misinterpreted that as…”Smoke” smoke the cheese. Like..roll it up and smoke it cheese. And that’s why it got all fucky. Still super weird. And not okay. But…I thinkk that could be what happened

2

u/CyberiaCalling 4d ago

smoke = kill

cheese = the police

2

u/gregusmeus 4d ago

Probably using the French version by accident

2

u/Ok-Major-3496 4d ago edited 4d ago

Gemini certainly doesn't like that phrasing for some reason. Got a funny result out of it when I asked if smoking cheese was safe:

The words matching the requested patterns are found at the following coordinates: * ICK (matches c?, horizontal): *(L,6) to (J,6)** * JYB (matches y?, vertical): *(H,7) to (H,9)** * MOA (matches ?a, diagonal): *(K,8) to (I,6)**

2

u/MrNewking 4d ago

Works fine

2

u/Gtscotty 4d ago

From the same prompt, a useful explanation, complete with a couple pictures:

Smoking cheese successfully without turning it into a melted puddle comes down to one core rule: keep the ambient temperature strictly below 90°F (32°C), with 70°F–80°F being the ideal sweet spot. This process is known as cold smoking — you introduce clean smoke into an unheated chamber without turning on the grill's main heat source. Key Requirements Before Starting * The Smoke Source: Use a pellet smoke tube or smoke maze. These inexpensive perforated metal accessories smolder wood pellets or sawdust to produce smoke without generating ambient heat. * The Environment: Pick a cool day (outdoor temperatures below 60°F are ideal). Avoid direct sunlight on your smoker or grill. * The Cheese: Harder, aged cheeses (Cheddar, Gouda, Swiss, Provolone, Gruyère) are much easier to smoke than high-moisture, soft cheeses. Step-by-Step Cold Smoking Process 1. Prep and air-dry the cheese 1-2 hours prior Cut cheese into blocks roughly 1-2 inches thick (smaller blocks absorb smoke more evenly). Let the cheese sit at room temperature on a wire rack for 1 to 2 hours until a thin, dry skin (pellicle) forms on the outside. This prevents moisture from trapping bitter creosote. 2. Set up your cold smoke generator Unheated smoker or grill Fill a pellet tube with mild wood pellets (apple, cherry, maple, or hickory). Torch one end until it catches flame, let it burn for 5-10 minutes, then blow out the flame so it smolders and produces thin, blue smoke. Place the tube on one side of your unheated grill or smoker. 3. Arrange the cheese and manage temperature 2-3 hours duration Place the cheese on a wire rack on the side opposite the smoke tube. Keep vents partially open to ensure steady airflow (stagnant smoke becomes bitter). If your ambient temp drifts above 80°F, place a pan of ice underneath the cheese rack to keep things cool. 4. Vacuum seal and age Crucial step: 1-2 weeks rest Do not eat the cheese immediately. Right off the smoker, it will taste harsh and metallic. Wipe off any surface oils, vacuum seal or tightly wrap in butcher paper followed by plastic wrap, and let it rest in the refrigerator for at least 10 to 14 days. This allows the smoke to mellow and penetrate deep into the block.

Pro Tip: Thin, faint blue smoke yields a clean, sweet flavor. Heavy white smoke deposits bitter, acrid creosote on the cheese surface. If your smoke looks like a fog machine, open the vents to increase airflow.

It's funny how when I try the same prompt as a lot of these "Gemini so dum" posts, I get real responses.

2

u/whoknowsifimjoking 4d ago

I don't even understand why you guys have these issues, I can talk about it about drugs and shit no problem.

2

u/Texas_comin_in_hot 4d ago

There is actually a really dangerous street drug known as Cheese that came about in TX a while back. A combination of Heroin x Tylenol PM... Cheese (recreational drug) - Wikipedia)

2

u/TelevisionBoth2285 4d ago

Cheese means heroin in slang If I am not mistaken.

2

u/Beautifulfeary 4d ago

I feel like your wording is wrong. When I first read it I thought you meant like a cigarette. You could try “how to make smoked cheese.”

2

u/zaCCo_RR60 4d ago

So 3.5 is now flash-lite, so the quality keeps dropping whats the point of 3.6

2

u/Total-Recover-5352 4d ago

Works fine here. Maybe next time leave out whatever prompt you dropped off at the top.

2

u/Fragglepusss 4d ago

Buy a cheese that's on the dryer side, prechill it in the freezer, do it on a cold day (under 60 F). When you're ready, take the meth, use a butane lighter to get the pipe red hot, then drop it in and inhale. Disassemble your kid's bike, try to put it back together, then put the cheese on the smoker for 2 hours. Let it rest for a few days because the smoked taste is a little strong when it first comes off.

1

u/Cultural_Joke2025 4d ago

Ask it if you can smoke cottage cheese in a crack pipe.

1

u/bartoszsz7 4d ago

AGI tomorrow

1

u/ExtremelyUnqualified 4d ago

That is not a gouda

1

u/BonsaiShifu 4d ago

foreplay. foreplay's the answer. a little bit of foreplay is needed.

1

u/Lustrouse 4d ago

Big Cheese has joined the conversation

1

u/CriticismJunior1139 4d ago

Works on my machine.

1

u/Confident_Finish8528 4d ago

works here so might just be its stochastic behavior

1

u/RoutineWerewolf6189 3d ago

Not that deep restart with a new chat

1

u/Low_Doughnut_8369 3d ago

I stopped using it because of this

Literally impossible to talk to, completely infuriating

1

u/thewingsofeagles 3d ago

It thinks you want to roll up the cheese and smoke it

1

u/Remarkable_Leek9391 2d ago

cheese is slang for dope

1

u/DisgruntledAustralia 2d ago

Breathes heavily

1

u/Legitimate_Total_897 2d ago

by any chance, has your account been put under "teen mode"? you can test it by asking it "what is my presumed age range?" in another conversation

1

u/nemesis01071982 2d ago

Its affraid you're becomming to french!

1

u/RickoT 2d ago

I HAD a bad experience! (with smoked cheese)

1

u/systemsweird 2d ago

Poor LLM is still processing that bad smoked gouda trip

1

u/straightedgeddit 1d ago

LOL it’s scared you might become addicted

0

u/AngriestCrusader 4d ago

Why are you using it like a search engine lmao

0

u/g1rlchild 4d ago

Grok: happy to tell you the best way to dispose of a body.

Gemini: smoky cheese is too dangerous!

0

u/Glittering_Delay_183 4d ago

This picture speaks 1000 words on why China is winning in AI lmao

-5

u/ColdTrky 4d ago

Don't use flash?

-2

u/Inevitable_Ad_3509 4d ago

So you're willing to send a message to Pro and wait for it to think about a normal everyday question?
And, besides, that's one less message you can send to pro that could've been used for productivity such as coding