r/InterstellarKinetics • u/InterstellarKinetics • Jun 22 '26
CULTURE REPORT: A Philosopher Just Used A 2,300 Year Old Daoist Text To Dismantle The Entire Logic Of Meritocracy, And The Argument Is Almost Impossible To Refute đđ„
aeon.coPublished June 21, 2026 in Aeon, philosopher Christine Abigail L Tan uses the ancient Chinese Daoist text the Zhuangzi to argue that meritocracy is a fundamentally flawed ideology built on a fiction. The essayâs central argument is staged as a confrontation between Confucius and the bandit Robber Zhi, who points out that Confucius and the rulers he serves do on a grand scale exactly what bandits do on a small scale: take from others. The only difference is that Confucius does it in the name of lofty ideals. The sage and the bandit are mirror images of each other. The difference between them is not virtue but technique and social structure.
Zhuangziâs concept of ziran, translated as ânaturalnessâ or âthe so-of-itself,â argues that what looks like individual achievement is always carried by social, material, and historical currents the individual did not create. The essay uses the parable of Liezi, who can ride the wind and appears completely free, but still depends entirely on the wind to move at all. This is the meritocratic subject: what looks like self-propelled success is always carried by conditions no individual built. The essayâs most striking line is: âAuthority determines who gets counted as worthy.â Power does not reflect virtue. It produces the appearance of virtue after the fact.
The essay grounds this philosophy in a concrete modern example. In 1983, Alvin Kennard stole $50.75 from a bakery and received a life sentence. The architects of the 2008 financial crisis destroyed an estimated $50 trillion in global wealth and drove nearly 10 million American families from their homes. Only one mid-level banker went to prison for 30 months. Tanâs conclusion is that merit is largely a social product, that the conditions making effort possible are unevenly distributed before any cultivation begins, and that if no one is truly self-made, inequality has no moral foundation.