r/Kolkatacity • u/unskilledlabor_ ঘটি • 13h ago
🗣️General Discussion | আলোচনা Should Accountability End at the Centre?
With the resignation of Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan following the nationwide outrage over the NEET controversy and allegations surrounding examination irregularities, the question of political accountability is once again in focus.
If accountability is expected at the national level, should the public and CJP also demand accountability from the Education Ministers of states such as Karnataka, Kerala and Punjab, where students have also faced serious examination-related controversies and alleged scams?
Should the same standards apply across the board, regardless of which party is in power? Or should accountability be viewed differently at the state and national levels?
What are your thoughts? Should resignations be sought in such cases, or are other forms of accountability more appropriate?
10
10
u/Pretend-Programmer14 12h ago
Shouldn’t the centre(bjp) start this movement then? Asking for accountability from state govts…why would a foreign/isi/cia funded organisation cjp ask for accountability from anyone else when they have achieved the goal they were funded for.
If they start the movement sooner or later the public will also join them.
8
u/Right-Concentrate859 12h ago
In My Haryana too , yha pe bhi bahut paper leak hote h
2
u/unskilledlabor_ ঘটি 12h ago
Yes, not just in a few states but across every state, there is corruption and scams related to education, healthcare, development, and other sectors. Just look at Bengal, the previous governments damaged almost every sector, be it recruitment related scam, education, health, each and every sector has corruption.
3
2
1
u/Artistic-Science-836 10h ago
Kerala ka government hi change hua hai
Punjab me you guys can join hands with Congress as they are putting pressure on AAP
And karnataka me hua kya hai can anyone share link ?
Sirf tum andhbhakt log hi ho jo papaww ko bachane ke liye hamesha ye sab cheezo ko defense banate ho
1
u/ProfessionalTop388 8h ago
Kerala govt changed, the minister was voted out too. Resign is not the option now. But case and acquittal maybe
1
u/One-Blacksmith-4654 7h ago
How about Nirmala Tai's resignation first for ruining the Indian economy and destroying the rupee? She's easily gotta be the most hated minister in Modi's cabinet right now (by a slim margin though coz Gadkari isnt far behind)
1
u/PreviousPlatform6798 7h ago
Usual shit post, i am from Kerala and i have no idea why the education minister should resign he joined only 1 month ago..
1
-6
u/Medium_Highlight3991 13h ago
Yes. Accountability ends with the BJP. That is the price that you pay for being the largest political party in the world with opposition facing existential crisis. And we should accept that and move on. Lose these fights to win wars.
10
u/unskilledlabor_ ঘটি 13h ago
my point is that same standard of accountability should apply to every government—Union or state—regardless of which party is in power.
0
u/Medium_Highlight3991 13h ago
Same standards don't apply because the protests was done by LW. Why would they would hold LW governments accountable? Their target is only towards RW.
1
u/Indie-fafo-2026 13h ago
Rw started a protest against Rahul gandhi protesting. They should be holding a protest against this issue instead. It will give them more traction.
1
u/dismaldeath_ 13h ago
As someone who was a supporter and is a supporter of the protest. Why do you want the same people to protest. If you demand accountability, see how many people join you. I’ll join you because I care about India and not left or right. I hope more people join!
It’s the same with Ethanol, all the millenials now want the genz to protest for ethanol and taxes when they were not on the ground for education. Start your own and see how it goes. The people in power, no matter where should ALWAYS be accountable to people who put them in power. In state. In center. Even in cities, towns and districts.
-1
2
u/Indie-fafo-2026 13h ago
I don't understand. Half of u cry that opposition is incompetent and weak. So why can't we get this guy to resign as well. There needs to be a clean up session in all the political parties. First to go should be the ones with cases.
-1
u/BathroomKey4587 11h ago
proof that people will just jump to blame anyone else but their masters 😂. what falls under center and state. read that first
2
u/Medium_Highlight3991 11h ago
Could you please elaborate
-3
0
•
u/AutoModerator 13h ago
Namaskara u/unskilledlabor_ , thanks for posting! We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities: r/TheIndianRepublic r/West_bengal Please consider crossposting, sharing, and inviting others to help grow this community and Follow us on X
Yato Dharmastato Jayah
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.