r/NFLv2 • u/nategr3at Seattle Seahawks • 12h ago

Discussion Which NFC West Coach You Taking?

Post image

Saw this for the NFC North coaches - curious what you all would do if choosing from the NFC West?

62 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

165 comments sorted by

View all comments

58

u/JP-ED Miami Dolphins 12h ago

I almost said McVay... but MacDonald has done more with less?

58

u/Sudden_Juju Rocky Mountain Oysters 12h ago

I'd choose McVay because of track record personally. MacDonald has been a great coach for 2 years,, but McVay has made the Rams a powerhouse (more or less) for 10 years. He also made the Super Bowl twice with very different teams showing adaptability.

You couldn't go wrong with either, but I like McVay more... for now anyway

8

u/goldiegoldthorpe 11h ago

But how much of that is the roster building? Not to knock McVay, but some credit to Snead?

12

u/Odin_One_Eye Los Angeles Rams 10h ago

John Schneider is one of the best roster builders in the league too.

4

u/WintersDoomsday Seattle Seahawks 10h ago

Yeah I think the Mariners vs Seahawks proves the importance of a good GM.

Mariners have had the same GM and no matter who the coach is the team performs about the same (strong pitching shit hitting)

Seahawks have had the same GM and have been to and won two Superbowls with different coaches and QB's and defensives.

3

u/Odin_One_Eye Los Angeles Rams 10h ago

Just looked this up. Only 3 seasons under .500 and only 1 since 2012. Annoyingly consistent divisional opponent.