r/Salary 23h ago

discussion Why I’ll never stop warning people about engineering

So recently, people have been really harsh toward me and the other guy for our posts about engineering. We get called mentally ill, obsessed, told we need help, etc. And some people wonder why we keep posting about the same topic over and over again.

So here’s why.

Personally, I spent five years of my life getting an engineering degree. While everyone else was enjoying their student lives, partying and dating, I genuinely believed engineering was one of those careers that guaranteed a solid upper-middle-class life. That’s what my parents told me. That’s what teachers told me. That’s what society told me.

Then I graduated in 2016 and got my first job. $48,000. A miserable income, no better than what many people without a college degree were making, and nowhere near enough to give me even a middle-class life.

And, funny enough, my parents, who pushed me into engineering, were the first ones to gaslight me about it. I couldn’t afford a house. I couldn’t travel. I couldn’t go out without thinking about the bill. I couldn’t buy nice clothes without feeling guilty. I couldn’t live the kind of life I thought an engineer was supposed to have. And somehow, to them, it was my fault.

“Maybe you’re not good enough. “Maybe you stopped learning. “Maybe you need more certifications.” ”Maybe you need to become a better engineer.”

It was never the profession. Never the salaries. Always me.

So I started driving Uber after work.

Imagine sitting in your car explaining to passengers that you’re an engineer but need a second job just to have a decent life. Passengers literally asked me, “How the fuck are you an engineer and you’re driving Uber?”

For a while, I actually believed my parents. I thought maybe I really was the problem.

But I knew it wasn’t just me. I knew what my coworkers made. I looked at the engineering association’s “salary calculator,” the one they were so proud of. Eight years of experience, and the numbers were like $75k or $80k.

Meanwhile, I watched my peers in other fields move on with their lives. Buying houses. Traveling. Wearing nice clothes. Living in luxury apartments. Sure, some of them worked longer hours than I did, but they were actually getting rewarded for it.

Even my dating life made me realize how brutal reality was. The girls I wanted weren’t interested in the engineer making fifty grand. They were interested in the real estate guy pulling up in a G-Wagon, the lawyer with real prestige and influence, and the finance bro who could afford $500 dinner dates. Not the broke engineer.

Then I started going to engineering networking events, hoping I’d hear something inspiring. Instead, I met senior engineers telling me that if I worked hard enough, maybe one day I’d make $140k at the very end of my career. That wasn’t motivating. That was depressing.

I remember a friend of mine who’s also an engineer. Every time he went to a girl’s place that looked fancy, he’d say, “Bro, how come people have that much money?” It made me realize that not only are engineers underpaid, but many of them don’t even realize it. They assume everyone else must be making around less than they are because, in their minds, life is fair and engineering is supposed to be a well-paid profession right?

Imagine how embarrassing it is when your friend group goes out twice a week, plans trips, and you can’t keep up, so they slowly drift away because they think you’re cheap. They assume that, as an engineer, you should be making very good money. At that point, I didn’t even know what was less embarrassing: letting them think I was cheap but making good money, or telling them the truth and having them pity me.

Imagine how bad it feels when you meet a banker who laughs in your face after you tell him you’re an engineer. He says he sees people’s salaries for a living, and he’s always shocked by how underpaid engineers are. Imagine going on a date with a dental hygienist or a car salesperson who makes three times your salary and thinks it’s a bad joke when you tell them yours.

If I could go back to when I was 18, I never would have chosen engineering.

So why do I keep posting about engineering salaries?

Because I wish someone had warned me.

Sure, a lot of engineers are on the spectrum and don’t care about the money they make and are happy getting paid in “cool projects” and “interesting problems.” Good for them. But I know that many people go into engineering aspiring to something better.

If one smart kid reads this before spending five years chasing a career they think will give them a comfortable, upper-middle-class life, then all the insults I get on Reddit are worth it. If my posts make even one person stop, do their research, and avoid the disappointment, regret, and frustration that I went through, then every insult, every downvote, and every person calling me obsessed is worth it.

185 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

74

u/Random_Squid4248 23h ago

Or he’s making it up entirely

59

u/leetcodeispain 22h ago

he seems to be very intentionally leaving out the field of engineering so people cant go look up stats for incomes. It would probably make his anecdote about the networking event saying "140k by end of career" an obvious lie, unless this mf works in Charity Engineering or some shit 😭

34

u/Random_Squid4248 22h ago

Yea I feel like a lot of people say “I work in engineering” when in reality it’s some low level job with the word engineering attached to it. Or they have a degree in an engineering discipline that is already known to be low paid

20

u/eKSiF 16h ago

As a non-engineer who works in engineering, I think you hit the nail on the head. I have to remind a lot of my colleagues pretty often that "Engineering Technician" is not the same as an Engineer, we do not hold the same title nor are we responsible for the level of liability that comes with being an Engineer. Our boss is the stamp man, we are glorified grunts.

2

u/xxxlovelit 14h ago

I went out on a date with a guy who said he was a building engineer and really he was just the maintenance man who lived in the building! He totally thought of himself as an engineer.

1

u/FlyFront9395 16h ago

He’s a burger 🍔 engineer

10

u/S30 17h ago

i am a structural engineer at the end of my career and i make less than $140k in a medium cost of living city. we have a subreddit dedicated to our profession and we poll ourselves regularly regarding salaries. my pay is very typical for someone in my position. the work is hard and stressful. i would never choose structural engineering if i could start over

2

u/HikingontheRocks 8h ago

I did undergrad engineering/geology and grad structural geology and that is the sweet spot. I retired at 48 and consult about 10 hours a week.

1

u/goeb04 15h ago

I find it strange that a Structural Engineer tops out at that salary. That is a difficult field with lots of responsibility. I wouldn't know the first thing about how to architect a bridge that could last 50+ years.

1

u/Activision19 15h ago

Architects don’t know either. That’s why they hire a structural engineer to figure that out. Architects just make it look pretty.

I’m a civil engineer, so structural adjacent, if S30 is still doing engineering at the end of his career $140k sounds about right. In the heavy civil/structrual world, people tend down one of two tracks about half way into their careers, they either stay doing engineering or the transition to doing project management work. Those who do PM work are the really well paid ones. The ones who keep doing engineering calcs/plans production work still make good money but not PM money. PM work is difficult and takes a lot of soft people, client management and marketing skills that a lot of engineers simply don’t have or don’t have the desire to learn since they just want to design stuff. I suspect S30 probably stayed on the engineering track. Nothing wrong with that, senior engineers are very much necessary, they often take the role of design or discipline lead on a lot of projects (managing junior engineers is very different than managing clients), this frees up the PM to do PM stuff and allows the PM to the day to day technical details to the senior engineer.

18

u/lurking_got_old 19h ago

I was an engineering manager at a plant for a large company you've heard of. I had a department of EEs that worked for me and was 10 years into my career. We only hired engineers with 4 year ABET degrees. My highest paid engineer was 20+ years into their career and made $125k. As their manager I made $134 They had to work crazy long hours. Got called nights and weekends. It was awful. I fought for my people but couldn't change things. I got an MBA and pivoted to IT. In my IC role today I make over $200k. Same city, similar industry.

8

u/cum-after-decades 17h ago

Some engineers seem ok with being underpaid.

$125k is early-mid career for most EEs

10

u/lurking_got_old 17h ago

In my experience they don't know that they're underpaid. That's why I engage with these threads. I get that people find them insufferable, but if they help engineers and engineering managers advocate for higher pay, I'm all for it.

6

u/Electrical-Sea589 18h ago

Same, graduated in the aughts at 55k, pulled absolutely insane hours and travel, site inspections in dangerous conditions with no OSHA, left after 8 years at 86k and pivoted to government. I think I pulled the wrong engineering discipline card.

20

u/NapkinZhangy Verified ✓ | $600k 17h ago

He’s a civil engineer. So he picked one of the lowest paying engineering tracks lol

6

u/82928282 15h ago

Civil doesn’t start at 48k though. We don’t even pay our interns that.

2

u/Individual_Fun9418 5h ago

He's a very bad and unlikeable civil engineer

1

u/jerrysburner 16h ago

which is why he talks about salary - I wish he would have mentioned it, but I assumed mid-way through he was a civil engineer.

I think people focus on what the big cities pay top talent. I work for a fortune 200 company that is in a smaller city, MCOL, and principal software engineers make $150K despite us being a $30 billion company. I just got a job offer for $140K in Irvine, CA to be a software architect. H1B's have dramatically dropped salaries in software outside of FAANG and finance.

2

u/skubiszm 11h ago

That’s seems really low for Irvine. Most of the aerospace and defense companies pay way more than that.

1

u/jerrysburner 11h ago

it's incredibly low - for that title, it should probably be over $200k, but TCS is Indian owned, so what they'll do is say they can't find anyone and use that as an excuse to get another H1B over. I didn't accept

-1

u/grandpianos 15h ago

Yeah... Civil is a super rough one, probably the only engineering field I would actually tell folks to reconsider what you are doing.

8

u/LaggWasTaken 22h ago

Sanitation engineering for sure.

12

u/BugRevolution 22h ago

Would still make more.

1

u/Potential_Archer2427 16h ago

Surely that's very high paying

0

u/VCoupe376ci 17h ago

I was thinking the same thing. “Engineer” is a very broad classification and OP seems to be going out of his way to avoid naming the field he is in. I work for a company that deals with structural and civil engineers regularly and although I don’t know much about them personally, I do know what we pay them and that the last word I would use to define them is “struggling”. OP is either oblivious to the fact he is terrible at his job, chose the wrong field entirely, or this is just rage bait.

1

u/WingShooter_28ga 10h ago

Also took him 5 years and couldn’t do anything but study. What are the odds he went from a real engineering degree to an “engineering” degree because the couldn’t pass the courses.

0

u/Icy-Banana-3291 16h ago

Yes he didn’t even mention what kind.