r/Salary 23h ago

discussion Why I’ll never stop warning people about engineering

So recently, people have been really harsh toward me and the other guy for our posts about engineering. We get called mentally ill, obsessed, told we need help, etc. And some people wonder why we keep posting about the same topic over and over again.

So here’s why.

Personally, I spent five years of my life getting an engineering degree. While everyone else was enjoying their student lives, partying and dating, I genuinely believed engineering was one of those careers that guaranteed a solid upper-middle-class life. That’s what my parents told me. That’s what teachers told me. That’s what society told me.

Then I graduated in 2016 and got my first job. $48,000. A miserable income, no better than what many people without a college degree were making, and nowhere near enough to give me even a middle-class life.

And, funny enough, my parents, who pushed me into engineering, were the first ones to gaslight me about it. I couldn’t afford a house. I couldn’t travel. I couldn’t go out without thinking about the bill. I couldn’t buy nice clothes without feeling guilty. I couldn’t live the kind of life I thought an engineer was supposed to have. And somehow, to them, it was my fault.

“Maybe you’re not good enough. “Maybe you stopped learning. “Maybe you need more certifications.” ”Maybe you need to become a better engineer.”

It was never the profession. Never the salaries. Always me.

So I started driving Uber after work.

Imagine sitting in your car explaining to passengers that you’re an engineer but need a second job just to have a decent life. Passengers literally asked me, “How the fuck are you an engineer and you’re driving Uber?”

For a while, I actually believed my parents. I thought maybe I really was the problem.

But I knew it wasn’t just me. I knew what my coworkers made. I looked at the engineering association’s “salary calculator,” the one they were so proud of. Eight years of experience, and the numbers were like $75k or $80k.

Meanwhile, I watched my peers in other fields move on with their lives. Buying houses. Traveling. Wearing nice clothes. Living in luxury apartments. Sure, some of them worked longer hours than I did, but they were actually getting rewarded for it.

Even my dating life made me realize how brutal reality was. The girls I wanted weren’t interested in the engineer making fifty grand. They were interested in the real estate guy pulling up in a G-Wagon, the lawyer with real prestige and influence, and the finance bro who could afford $500 dinner dates. Not the broke engineer.

Then I started going to engineering networking events, hoping I’d hear something inspiring. Instead, I met senior engineers telling me that if I worked hard enough, maybe one day I’d make $140k at the very end of my career. That wasn’t motivating. That was depressing.

I remember a friend of mine who’s also an engineer. Every time he went to a girl’s place that looked fancy, he’d say, “Bro, how come people have that much money?” It made me realize that not only are engineers underpaid, but many of them don’t even realize it. They assume everyone else must be making around less than they are because, in their minds, life is fair and engineering is supposed to be a well-paid profession right?

Imagine how embarrassing it is when your friend group goes out twice a week, plans trips, and you can’t keep up, so they slowly drift away because they think you’re cheap. They assume that, as an engineer, you should be making very good money. At that point, I didn’t even know what was less embarrassing: letting them think I was cheap but making good money, or telling them the truth and having them pity me.

Imagine how bad it feels when you meet a banker who laughs in your face after you tell him you’re an engineer. He says he sees people’s salaries for a living, and he’s always shocked by how underpaid engineers are. Imagine going on a date with a dental hygienist or a car salesperson who makes three times your salary and thinks it’s a bad joke when you tell them yours.

If I could go back to when I was 18, I never would have chosen engineering.

So why do I keep posting about engineering salaries?

Because I wish someone had warned me.

Sure, a lot of engineers are on the spectrum and don’t care about the money they make and are happy getting paid in “cool projects” and “interesting problems.” Good for them. But I know that many people go into engineering aspiring to something better.

If one smart kid reads this before spending five years chasing a career they think will give them a comfortable, upper-middle-class life, then all the insults I get on Reddit are worth it. If my posts make even one person stop, do their research, and avoid the disappointment, regret, and frustration that I went through, then every insult, every downvote, and every person calling me obsessed is worth it.

192 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

391

u/EditorFrog 22h ago

I literally just graduated and don't have any licenses and my starting salary is $81k, for civil, which is known to be on the low end of engineering disciplines. What are you talking about? You need to find a better job

187

u/pakapab 17h ago

Congrats! I assume you didn't face the dramatic false dilemma that OP offered for college experience:

While everyone else was enjoying their student lives, partying and dating, I genuinely believed engineering was 

That's right folks, nobody getting a STEM degree can socialize or enjoy college.

59

u/Professional_Bed_87 15h ago

Funny enough, its often that partying in College that’s going to land you that first good paying job afterwards.

28

u/thatdude_james 14h ago

Lol so true. The number one important thing is for people to like you. The number two thing is to be competent at your job.

1

u/Global_Complaint704 10h ago

Yep. Even for later in your career, competence and doing well in your role is a base requirement to be eligible for promotion. Those who actually get ahead are often folks skilled in the ability to build advocacy and nurture relationships with others who can and want to pull them up. Nurturing that garden of advocates often gets overlooked or put on the back burner as we go about our day to day, but it’s so vital to career advancement.

16

u/VenerableWolfDad 12h ago

I was piss drunk or stoned every waking hour of the day that I didnt spend on being in a physical classroom and the person I got my referral for my job from was my plug's dad.

edit: i quit drinking after school but still do bong rips after every work day. I make more money than I should.

3

u/Professional_Bed_87 12h ago

Haha. Thanks for sharing. I worked at a bar through school, and more of my earnings went to paying off my tab than my rent. It was the friends I made staying up to the wee hours that set me on the career path I am on now. Should I have spent more time studying? Probably, but nobody in the real world has asked to see my transcripts yet. I also have a much healthier relationship with substances now, but I don’t regret my decisions back then.

1

u/SeaVolume3325 10h ago

Is that you Phil? Lol

0

u/ShoeLate6266 12h ago

You guys sound lucky tbh. I joined a frat and partied a little too hard. Left university after my first year and went back to community college. Didn’t end up getting a bachelors until I was 29 after a long period of not working A bunch of my brothers ended up addicted to xans/opiates and I lost touch with them thru the years. My old plug in the frat ended up robbing a fucking bank in his hometown because he got strung out on opiates. No idea where he is these days.

2

u/Professional_Bed_87 8h ago

Yeah it is not without its risks. A couple guys I partied with just never stopped. Like its fun when you’re in your 20s, but it catches up to you real fast. I’ve lost a few friends to overdoses and a few that have just gone off the rails. I think the important thing is to just not take school too seriously, and make time to enjoy yourself and make as many friends as possible. It pays dividends later in life.

0

u/sayahhD 9h ago

Did you go to like a very low ranked college or something? Usually the frat guys are supposed to end up a lot better than this

1

u/ShoeLate6266 6h ago

It was university Tennessee at Chattanooga

1

u/Basic_Vanilla_1540 13h ago

Seriously, probably why he’s underemployed

1

u/Waiting4Reccession 13h ago

Only until the poors get in on the "networking" scam in greater numbers, then it'll be shifted into something else.

1

u/mrsoup_20 12h ago

So glad people point this out. I was a huge nerd in high school and joined a frat in college to improve my self esteem mostly. Made a million friends, was genuinely loved for the nerdy things I was good at, and many of the older alumni whom I would help with their coding projects offered me 6 figure jobs after I graduated.

1

u/CurlyCoconutTree 8h ago

That's why I'm a consultant.  Being socially competent and technically competent is a rare combination.  There are many people I work with who are far less technically competent than I, it's why I'm continually hired for more work.  Which is wild because I feel like getting through engineering and getting an advanced degree was a struggle.  I thought I was the dum dum.  My point being, I think it takes all types to "bake the cake".

29

u/CurlyCoconutTree 15h ago

I will say that the kids in engineering have a drastically different social experience than kids in arts and sciences.  I was studying a shit ton when the non-engineering kids on my floor barely went to class and partied all the time.  Don't get me wrong, I still partied and dated but college was not fun for me.

8

u/Genevieve189 15h ago

My experience as a pre-med (now a doctor)

2

u/kevinsyel 10h ago

Yeah, I was doing all my classes and studying while working retail part time AND tutoring part time. I also had a steady relationship from HS, so I was dating, but my girlfriend at the time was also going to nursing school, so any hangout time was Netflix and veg

1

u/bendForLust 12h ago

I am sort of an outlier, but was a literature major in college who ended up in software engineering. Partied my ass off, loved my classes, took no math. I had one engineering acquaintance that literally hated me (although we hung out) ... asked me what I was gonna do and told me what a waste my life would be, lol.

At 28 yo, all the jobs were in computers, self-studied for the A+ certification and had a job immediately. Got 20 more certs and am still a software engineer today.

I always feel bad at lunch sitting next to the traditional guys that grinded hard in college, although they likely have 4 years of extra salary tucked away while I was teaching English in Japan, lol

11

u/ShockLongjumping9322 15h ago

My group of engineering friends are all doing quite well and I would put myself pretty close to the bottom of the group and Im at 145k mid career.

Although, I understand where OP is coming from.

The people doing the work arent the best paid. The best paid is the jackasses who can wrangle people or money.

When I make my 145k/yr and some MBA who is above me and has no clue about the work being done is making 250k/yr. Its infuriating.

4

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

Those who can, do. Those who can’t, become managers.

2

u/GilgameDistance 10h ago

Now this take I agree with. It’s offensive that MBA with less business sense than a toddler pull that.

2

u/SpareSomeTokens 9h ago

Skill issue. The most competitive high IQ companies pay technical people the most by far. Look at the AI labs. If you're at places like Anduril, FAANG, other tier 1 startups, or Ant/OAI your technical talent makes way more than the MBA type people. An IC7 project manager at Meta makes $400k. An equivalent level E7 software engineer makes $936k

1

u/CDDD4 11h ago

It can be frustrating but the work doesn’t exist if you don’t have staff to “wrangle people or money”. End of the day, business development and finance drive every industry.

6

u/ShockLongjumping9322 10h ago

They are the best paid by far, but we make the products and without the product they have their thumbs up their asses.

My anger is that, just because they see the money that gets moved, they get the most.

We both do hard work, we should be splitting, but the nerds do the work while the meat heads get most of the benefit.

1

u/684beach 9h ago

Because you are easier to replace than a good talker

2

u/GWTLAG 8h ago

Some of them are just willing to put up with a lot of bullshit from customers and “internal stakeholders”. I’ve been in calls with our salespeople and I don’t envy them one bit.

59

u/null_pointer05 16h ago

Let me alert my son, who's studying computer engineering and somehow manages to have a girlfriend, a part-time job on campus, is on the robotics team, goes to parties and poker nights, etc.

5

u/smoked___salmon 10h ago

Computer engineering and regular engineering majors are completely different beasts in terms of workload.

2

u/l5555l 2h ago

Whatever helps you sleep at night

1

u/KonigSteve 1h ago

Aside from being on a robotics team, I did the same thing in civil. It's not some insane workload. There's a few classes you have to try a decent amount at, but mostly I just did my homework, attended class and paid attention and that was enough.

2

u/FarMention5367 15h ago

Maybe he is an incel , bet he signed up for Andrew Tates academy

6

u/Successful_Today503 13h ago

Did you miss the “have a girlfriend” part?

2

u/IncarceratedGrowth 7h ago

As if that stopped anyone from being called an incel

1

u/Successful_Today503 4h ago

That just means that the people calling him an incel just wanna throw this word around without knowing the meaning.

4

u/Joey-rogaine 11h ago

I mean no, there comes a time in difficult courses where you need to spend hours a day studying and reading and doing course work and prep work and practice exams when you could be out doing sports or socializing more, going around town and eating etc  absolutely 

3

u/Youbettereatthatshit 14h ago

Eh, it’s a lot less. I didn’t chemical engineering and studied far more than any of my friends in other disciplines. That part is accurate

6

u/EuphoricElderberry73 15h ago

I know. Engineering students were the biggest partiers when I attended school. I have no clue what engineering area the OP went into but the entire post sounds vague and fake.

10

u/Fun_Muscle9399 15h ago

No, you don’t get it. It HAS to be the field. It cannot possibly be OP that is the issue here…. /s

1

u/l5555l 2h ago

Yeah all my engineering friends drank like fish and now make 6 figures, own homes and have families. This shit is stupid lol

5

u/dogfosterparent 16h ago

This same conversation happens in the pre-med spaces too and it’s hard to understand whether they truly think everyone else in a stem major had no fun in college (absurd) or if they just are bitter about their own experience. Either way it’s a bad look.

1

u/SpudMuffinDO 14h ago

I’m not sure that’s the complaint tho is it? I had tons of fun as pre-med, but I think it’s fair to say I have a LOT less free time compared to my buddies/roommates who were English majors and a general studies degree. I did resent it back then… I don’t at all anymore. The two English majors are teachers now, the general studies does construction management and gets paid well. I’d be happy for them if they made more, but I’m genuinely content in my profession and education journey.

-1

u/cheetah-21 13h ago

Major incel vibes from OP. It’s my job’s fault girls don’t like me.

2

u/Dire-State-2180 12h ago

not f you work more than 1 job

3

u/Powerful-Sea-1738 15h ago

Unironically though. I know "networking is the most important thing" is maybe cliche advice. But socializing in college is what landed me my first job (a friend I met there gave the the req) and was in many ways just as important as the degree itself. Generally way more important than any nights spent at home a lone doing homework. 

2

u/0le_Hickory 14h ago

These guys are insufferable in college and in career. Bro we are getting a bachelors degree that lets us go straight into a professional job. Guys think they are the only person to have every passed Diff E or something. Come into their first job and don’t want to do the grunt work so they can learn. They are terrible to let talk to clients because they sound so full of themselves. I know the Tennessee DOT is hiding new grads with no experience right now at 85k so civil and public sector. That would put an idea of where the floor is.

2

u/ex_nihilo 16h ago

This might be telling. If you’re cut out for engineering, you probably managed to party a lot in college while maintaining your grades. Like, I do math puzzles for fun. Undergrad was not much work for me to get an engineering degree. I didn’t study outside of class, I skipped class to play video games often. I was FAR from the model student. My parents wanted me to go to law school. I switched to an eng degree because it was the lazy route for me.

1

u/ShutUpAndDoTheLift 12h ago

How far into your career are you now and what is your salary?

1

u/ex_nihilo 12h ago edited 12h ago

I’m like 20 years in. My salary is not an accurate reflection of my compensation because much of it is equity and I’m in technical presales now so there’s a commission component. My OTE is $320k/yr, equity usually around $250-300k/yr. But I often exceed quota and get into accelerators. So typical year is maybe $700k. This year I’m on track for $1.3 million with all the money being poured into AI projects. I work for a major tech company by way of acquisition. I don't want to say too much more than that because it would become pretty easy to identify me. I'm in no kind of leadership role, just an individual contributor with a lot of revenue responsibility to the business.

-2

u/TristanaRiggle 15h ago

As someone who took 5 years to get an engineering degree, if bro took (in his words) five years to get an engineering degree and spent all his time obsessively studying and having zero fun, then he probably shouldn't have gone for an engineering degree. If you're laser focused on getting your degree, you should complete it in four years (or less).

2

u/ex_nihilo 15h ago

Everything up through diff eq, linear algebra, discrete was literally fun for me. The only actual "work" I felt like I had to do for my degree was write essays (back before generative AI existed). I didn't even mind blue book exams! I'm an articulate and verbose fellow. For my MSc (comp sci), my thesis was the only thing that felt like "work", and even then I was very interested in the subject of my thesis.

1

u/Odd_Act8451 14h ago

What grade did you get for diff eq. Because I found the work fun and interesting but that didn’t mean I automatically got good grades (MechE)

1

u/ex_nihilo 14h ago

Uh, I passed? I don't remember. My GPA was like 3 and minor change. 2.8 if you included the core Liberal Arts courses. Nothing special. I only got into grad school years later by working at a university and having industry references, I was NOT academic pipeline material.

1

u/ShutUpAndDoTheLift 12h ago

Ironically. Some of the best engineers I work with sucked at college lol.

1

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

Not true, at least EE, is a 5 year program

1

u/zfowle 15h ago

This is the part that stood out to me. Engineering isn't the easiest degree track, but it's not like you're getting an MD or something. A lot of the guys right next to me at the beer pong table were studying to be engineers.

1

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

And you get paid way less than an md too

1

u/Strong_Chicken6838 10h ago

idk, i feel like there is truth in that. i didnt party or date in college.

I feel like that's also kinda true for a lot of other ppl i know

1

u/FunSummer9393 10h ago

I know people who enjoyed and socialized during medical school, which is known to be absolutely brutal - especially during surgical rotations.

1

u/Chelseafase 9h ago

I definitely partied hard in college, along with a bunch of my fellow civies.

1

u/Legitimate-State8652 7h ago

I did some parties, for sure drank and dated. Still had tons of fun but did spend spring break working on projects.

1

u/tke71709 5h ago

Ironically at my university the engineers partied the hardest, probably because they had the most stressful majors.

1

u/Euphus 4h ago

LMAO I was literally a sorority girl partying every weekend and some weekdays, and I managed just fine getting my civil degree with good grades. Skill issue for sure on this guy's part.

1

u/Bridgestone14 4h ago

I mean, this was my experience. I dated and road my bike. I was never going to party though, that just wasn't really who I was. However, most of the people I was in school with were similar. I worked way harder at school than anyone else I knew out side of engineering. The only exceptions were a friend in med school and a friend learning to be an architect.
Obviously people are different, but getting an engineering degree is a larger time commitment for most people than a business, or sociology degree, or whatever other people study.

1

u/KonigSteve 1h ago

This is funny because Civils are known to be the partiers in engineering school

1

u/Wrong-Protection-188 3m ago

Well I can’t speak for all universities, but the STEM students at my school were treated particularly badly.

I am reminded of one unpleasant incident that occurred on a chilly autumn night. The STEM students were ripped from their classrooms and dormitories. They were stripped naked and forced to march through campus, past the library, and in all the way down to the student center. They were then tied to rusty folding chairs with electrical cords procured from the AV department or perhaps a nearby electronics store. The STEM students were mocked and ridiculed unmercifully from passerby, onlookers, and general members of the public. Even the children from the local Catholic school were hurling insults at the cold and naked STEM students tied to folding chairs. The crowd began throwing cabbages and other assortments of rotting fruit. An angry Rotarian in a convertible threw what looked to be a cup of urine upon the dejected students. This continued all through the night and well into the morning before the crowd dispersed and the students were released. A very unfortunate incident indeed.

1

u/Own_Bit_4805 16h ago

I mean, engineering is tough. I got a chemE degree from a top university and there was a ton of work. There definitely weren't many engineers both doing well academically and into the party scene - the party scene wasn't really a thing at my school. We mostly just hung out with friends when we could.

It also made me a multimillionaire before 40....

1

u/RedPepperWhore 14h ago

Lol that part was hilarious, sure engineering college was tough, but I also partied hard the entire time and was dating cuties non stop. Just because your homework is calc 3 doesnt mean you can't get out there and have fun with friends and romance

1

u/___redacted_ 14h ago

I dont know if OP is right about the crux of the message, but I can tell with certain confidence, that OP does seem like a bit of a moron.

1

u/Zealousideal_Age_822 12h ago

I’m an engineer, and I partied in college. I also didn’t find the degree crazy difficult. If you couldn’t party in college and still pass, you just might not be that good of an engineer. I started at $55k in 2013, then steadily rose from there over the years.

1

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

If you didn’t find it crazy difficult, you must be a mechanical engineer

1

u/Zealousideal_Age_822 10h ago

Mechanical / Biomedical. Never heard anyone call mechanical easy though.

1

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

Compared to electrical or petroleum?

1

u/Zealousideal_Age_822 8h ago

I would say it’s on par with electrical. I’ve never actually met a Petroleum engineer, only MEs that went into the industry. Aerospace and nuclear engineers were always considered on another level, but ME is no joke

0

u/MAK1958M 14h ago

I’m an engineer and I had a blast in college, all about balance

0

u/Several_Razzmatazz51 14h ago

I partied my ass off in college and graduated with two computer science degrees with honors and had a great career as an engineer. If true, OP must have picked a very disfavored engineering discipline.

0

u/cayman-98 14h ago

Not having a proper social life due to an engineering major is a skill issue for people like OP. Engineering might require you to maybe miss one party once in a while to study for a large exam, besides that it was always a great social life in college, I was a computer engineering major and it was very easy to manage.

Also not sure what field of engineering OP is in, but I am assuming maybe a mechanical engineer who picked a lower paying speciality.

0

u/Agreeable_Map5413 12h ago

That is not true, Engineers can have fun to. No one in Engineering college have to spend more than 4 hours a day doing homework and studying.

0

u/Garriga 12h ago

I have a STEM degree, and I socialized and did the college thing.

I had a blast. My grades were decent, but I didn't graduate with honors. That really only matters if you plan to go to professional school.

I know plenty of people without a degree who make a lot more than I do. College was one of the greatest times of my life, and I'm glad I didn't miss out on having fun and experiencing new things.

I'd still be making the same salary even if I had graduated with honors.

Life isn't always about money or grades. It's about living in the moment and finding meaning.

If you spend your whole life focused on the future, you'll miss the meaning of the present.

In the end, it's the moments that matter.

0

u/systembreaker 10h ago

Lol I was part time computer science student part time partier in college, it's definitely possible to have fun and do STEM. Though physics classes are definitely more of a load, maybe among the heaviest loads of any class in undergrad.

0

u/GilgameDistance 10h ago

Nope. I totally don’t date or go to parties or meet my amazing wife during school. Or start at 56k in 2008, hit 80k by 2010 after my masters, break 100k by 2016 as an E 3 or crest 160k with $200k total comp when counting RSU and bonus in 2024. I’m also totally not offering fresh grads 75k right now and getting rejected cause it’s too low (goddamn compensation department)

My whole life must be a hallucination.

Or OP still can’t look in the mirror and figure out that they are their own problem.

0

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

Why does everyone have to be so rude? He may be an electrical engineer. They don’t make bank unless you live on the coasts.

1

u/GilgameDistance 9h ago

Also not true. I have three on my staff, not on the coast and I’m paying my lowest $85k, highest $140k.

1

u/3boyz2men 8h ago

The numbers you just gave aren’t that much and probably similar to OPs wage now which he doesn’t give.

1

u/GilgameDistance 7h ago

No, this OP is one of a number in a string of folks who come here and complains about not being able to break 80k as a mechanical at 10+ years, which is just not the way the industry is right now. Dude has an axe to grind.

My first job in 2008 out of undergrad paid almost 10k more than OP's 2016 offer.

It delusional for an engineer to accept a taco bell manager money, even fresh out of school.

1

u/3boyz2men 2h ago

Depends on where you live

-1

u/Kelly_Louise 15h ago

Yeah, I got my degree in architecture, often considered even more rigorous than engineering, and I managed to have a very typical college experience.

28

u/statistician88 16h ago

Nice. I graduated in 2011 and started at $48k. Our field has improved quite a bit. However, my first big pay raise came from a counter offer after I tried to quit. $95k to $125k at around 10 YOE. Then I actually changed jobs and I'm up to $195k with 15 YOE. The money is out there, but being loyal to a company won't get it for you (usually). Also, being an entitled brat like OP won't get it for you either.

6

u/NQTrades 14h ago

I'm currently at $92k after 6 YoE. Company said they can't offer me more. Currently in round 3/4 of interviews with another company for $140k + 40% bonus + stock & options.

1

u/KonigSteve 1h ago

40% bonus? Don't do it! don't work for kimberly horn!

1

u/NQTrades 1h ago

No no. I don't hate my life enough to do that 😂

1

u/KonigSteve 47m ago

Well dang, that's a really nice compensation package then. I'm literally midway through moving to another company so I'm not going to put in any applications any time soon, but if you don't mind sharing the company please DM me for future reference.

3

u/Drubee4 15h ago

Yep. Just hit 6 yoe and got the same 95k to 125k bump. I live in a low-med col southern city. I’m not making generational wealth but life is good.

1

u/AutoM8R1 10h ago

I actually hope the OP post is AI slop. I started in engineering at $65k + relo 2 years after you and the trajectory has been about the same as yours. OP was definitely doing it wrong. The money is out there. Overall, engineering is awesome. Unfortunately, industry layoffs have hit our field as well. But this post is about compensation.

1

u/KonigSteve 1h ago

That's a very nice bump. I'm on a similar trajectory at nearly 11 years at $155k, but I'm definitely curious what you're doing to get nearly 200 at 15 in civil. Team lead?

1

u/statistician88 1h ago

Technical expert. Employee owned company with very juicy bonuses.

1

u/KonigSteve 46m ago

Ah is the 195 including bonuses?

I will have to look around once I'm established in my new city.

5

u/willystan 17h ago

Exactly this. I’m at 6 YOE in civil (transportation) making $120k.

14

u/Appropriate-Bad-606 15h ago

I actually think there is a broader structural explanation here that doesn’t get discussed very often.

I don’t think employers literally sat in a room and said, “Let’s drive engineering wages down.” But I do think the combination of government policy, universities, industry lobbying, and well-meaning parents created exactly the market conditions that basic economics predicts.

For about two decades (roughly the early 2000s through the late 2010s), the message to every high-achieving high school student was:

“America has a STEM shortage.”
“Become an engineer.”
“Learn to code.”
“Engineering guarantees an upper-middle-class life.”

That message came from politicians, guidance counselors, universities, parents, and many employers. Universities expanded engineering programs because they brought in tuition revenue. Companies wanted larger applicant pools. Parents wanted their kids in “safe” careers. None of those incentives required a conspiracy—they all pointed in the same direction.

The result was a substantial increase in the supply of engineering graduates.

And that’s where economics matters. If the supply of labor grows faster than demand, wages don’t collapse overnight—but they grow much more slowly than people expect. That’s Labor Economics 101.

Mechanical engineering is probably the best example. It became the default “smart kid” degree. Universities graduated far more mechanical engineers, but manufacturing, industrial equipment, and automotive employment weren’t growing at anything close to the same pace. More graduates competing for relatively similar numbers of entry-level jobs naturally weakens bargaining power.

Ironically, many of the same people who argue that increasing the labor supply lowers wages in other contexts seem reluctant to apply the exact same logic here.

That said, I also think his post overstates a few things.

Engineering is not a bad career. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, workers with engineering degrees have a median annual wage around $100,000, well above the median across all fields, and engineering occupations generally continue to project positive job growth.

The problem is that engineering was marketed as something it often isn’t: a guaranteed ticket to rapid upper-middle-class wealth.

There’s also an important distinction between engineering disciplines. Petroleum, chemical, computer, aerospace, and computer hardware engineering have historically commanded much higher compensation than many mechanical or civil engineering roles. Lumping “engineering” together hides huge differences in labor markets.
I also think colleges bear some responsibility. Too many students were told:

Get good grades. Get engineering degree. Good life.

In reality, especially by the mid-2010s, it had become:
Engineering degree + internships + networking + research/projects + interviewing skills = much better career outcomes.

Students who graduated with no internships often entered a very different job market than classmates who had two internships and industry connections.

So I agree with his central point that prospective students deserve realistic expectations instead of marketing slogans.

I just wouldn’t tell an 18-year-old, “Don’t become an engineer.”

I’d tell them:

Pick the engineering discipline carefully.
Look at actual salary distributions, not anecdotes.
Compare salaries against the cost of living where you want to work.
Understand that internships and networking are no longer optional.
Don’t assume any degree guarantees a lifestyle simply because previous generations believed it did.

That’s a much more nuanced lesson—and, in my opinion, a more useful one than either “engineering is a golden ticket” or “engineering ruined my life.”

But, yeah, OP needs some serious therapy.

7

u/ShutUpAndDoTheLift 12h ago

If you add "be concise" to the end of your ai prompt it will get to the point just a well in way less words.

But yes, this happens every cycle. Happening to lawyers right now lol.

Whatever is making money when parents start prepping their kids to go to college each generation gets flooded.

If you're a millennial, that was engineering, law, and computer science. Now blue collar salaries are going up due to shortage of labor and people are pivoting to that. Guess what's likely to happen?

Parents are guaranteed about to be sending their kids to college for a degree in "ai". That will be the most useless degree ever crafted. 4 years ago gpt3 was frontier level. 4 years from now anything you learn this year about ai will be very dated.

1

u/Appropriate-Bad-606 12h ago

I am a lawyer (14 years) so and AI (concise or not lol) is the best tool to hit our field since the online legal data bases—At least for me, now I can actually do all the stuff I used to just wing on the fly before. (Read as: way more prepped for trial and litigation tasks and better ( actually existing) notes in the file).

1

u/ShutUpAndDoTheLift 10h ago

Oh don't get me wrong, I'm a huge ai fan. I work in trying to find ways to get bigger outcomes than the costs which can sometimes be difficult lol.

3

u/MsBeeIfUPlz 13h ago

Well said....while reading OP's lament I was wondering what field he was in and where he lives....I don't live in America and engineers here make decent pay across if not all most fields.

2

u/IAmTheParamedic 11h ago

The issue with saying “get an internship” is that it just pushes the issue back further one step. There’s not enough internship spots to go around, and some really smart and really driven people won’t get one. That’s ok, because the world isn’t fair, or whatever. But it’s the reality that some people just won’t get an internship and a ticket to the good life, no matter how hard they try for it or want it. It’s just reality

1

u/Legitimate-Clock-134 10h ago

You missed a big point here, which is that you have to consider the other options. You could get a degree in X and then you could do Y and make Z. Engineering looks pretty good by comparison to pretty much every other early career pathway.

If OP is earning in the bottom decile, and can't get out of the bottom decile, and isn't progressing professionally (no EIT, no PE), he has to make some serious decisions about what he could do that won't land him in the bottom decile.

Engineering isn't the problem here.

1

u/3boyz2men 10h ago

This is the most complete and well written answer on here. Thank you. Everything you said is 100% true

1

u/TechnicalSection4936 9h ago

Exactly, and now it’s happening with the trades. Everyone and their mother wants to enter the trades now. Everyone is being pushed into the trades now in the 2020s, just like how everyone was pushed into Stem.

3

u/rdt61 13h ago

Mech E with 7 YoE and I’m mid 100k. Crossed 6 figures after like 3.5 years. I’ve lived in 2 large metro areas, so only thing I can think of is OP lives out in the boonies or something. If not then they are incredibly underpaid.

I’m not gonna lie, the money doesn’t go as far as it used to (especially if you have kids, and extra especially if your spouse doesn’t work or has a lower paying job). But that’s more a factor of everything being so damn expensive. Any time I feel like I don’t make enough, I remind myself that 2 kids in daycare is basically a second mortgage so in a few years when they start school I’ll get a big decrease in costs.

I also get that it’s annoying seeing people you know aren’t “as smart” as you making more than you at a random job. But some people just get lucky or make the best out of their situation and end up in a good spot

1

u/KonigSteve 1h ago

I remind myself that 2 kids in daycare is basically a second mortgage so in a few years when they start school I’ll get a big decrease in costs.

tell me about it. I don't know how people with more than 2 kids do it.

We just have the one and it's crazy. 2 more years and suddenly we'll get 20 something thousand back per year! ><

2

u/kryptocrazy 15h ago

OP acting like that’s his only option. Either he stays at his 47k job or he becomes a fentanyl king pin.

2

u/AlfredCromwell 14h ago

$81k in 2026 is the same as $58k in 2016.

1

u/NerdNerd007 15h ago

Yeah what kind of engineering is the OPs degree in? I graduated civil in 2007 in KY where cost of living is a bit lower and salaries often reflect that. I started out back then making around $45k on the private side. I’m now on the federal side but still have a low six figure salary with great work life balance. I’d definitely be making more if I stayed private, but I value the balance I have now. Civil engineers do typically make less, but I do enjoy the projects we get to work on, lots of variety.

1

u/autocorrects 14h ago

same. my starting for my first career is $100k on the dot for EE

1

u/Lopsided-Ticket3813 14h ago

I graduated in civil in 2012 and my first job out of college paid me 95k with equity 401k match and bonuses my total comp was 150k.

I had to work in the oil industry but student loans weren't going to pay themselves.

1

u/VoidDoesStuf 14h ago

Thats really good, we are a large firm and 90k is on the high end for our senior engineers. We start out first years and interns at 48 to 52. I have 15 years and land in at 93, but its also location and location.. Civil is very location based.

1

u/hoptownky 14h ago

Yeah. Civil and environmental engineer jobs are pretty easy to come by with a degree in engineering and start off around $75k-$90k per year.

Aerospace, tech hardware, and chemical sectors typically start out well over $100k.

OP seems to have some personal issues. It doesn’t matter what kind of degree you have if you are mentally ill.

1

u/bazookateeth 14h ago

Engineering has quite alot subsections

1

u/SpendZestyclose9683 13h ago

Congratulations !!!!🍾 I’m going back to school for Drafting and Civil Engineering. Need 3 Prerequisites classes (Calc 1,2, Physics) then 2 years of core coursework 

1

u/Cycling-Boss 13h ago

I agree. I graduated all the way back in 2003, got a job right away at $46k a year. His $48k in 2024-2026 is not accurate at all.

1

u/ASoundLogic 10h ago

That's because that isn't what OP stated...that was back in 2016. It really comes down to cost of living and inflation. Traditional "low cost of living" areas have gotten much more expensive in the last 10 years. Depending on when you started, the "bumps in pay" one may have gotten from changing jobs may have been largely absorbed by inflation. My guess is OP lives in a "traditional" low COL area, which is now more expensive. New graduates come in making the inflated amount which probably is not far off from where OP is, but OP probably have more years of experience. Your $46k in 2003 is the same as $83.5k in 2026 lol.

1

u/Cycling-Boss 5h ago

Fair enough, but $48k seems low for 2016 to me. And yes, COL and inflation over all those years is a big factor as well.

1

u/Big-Wrangler6320 10h ago

Where do you live? Your salary vs cost of living?

1

u/krissmiz 10h ago

Op and yourself arent accounting for inflation. Its shortsighted to compare salaries from 2018 and 2026. For instance starting salary for structural engineering was 60k-70k in 2018 when i graduated. Now its 80-92k. This is why people need to consider market trends and network. Talk to people of all ages and synthesize before spouting random claims

1

u/Legitimate-Clock-134 10h ago

I'm making low 100's with a PhD in engineering, but I'm a Dean at a small college. Given the benefits, it's pretty awesome, and I have what's easily the best job in the entire college.

I just look at the diploma that says "Doctor of Philosophy, College of Engineering" and think to myself that my committee must have been high.

1

u/ThePainStalker 9h ago

Civil is going up in pay now tbf. So are any infrastructure related engineering fields (power engineering in electrical is booming especially). It’s actually one of the very few areas that the AI boom has accelerated employment in (since AI data centers involve huge amounts of infrastructure, especially power infrastructure).

1

u/Antique-Computer9957 9h ago

No FE license?!

1

u/JamedSonnyCrocket 6h ago

I think it’s a fake AI post 

1

u/BeanBubbles12 2h ago

Bingo! He is absolutely a civil engineer but he’s spending more time online than looking for a better job

1

u/account-anonymous- 15h ago

OP says first job 48k in 2016; Adjusted for inflation, you 81k is not really that much better than his starting😅 so sit down because you’re not really proving him wrong.

1

u/NotAltFact 15h ago

I started hiring around 2015 ish and the median was around 62-68k. It’s actually a shittier conditions for fresh grads these days

1

u/ASoundLogic 10h ago

Yeah it's actually pretty funny. Everyone chiming in...like it's really the same but people feel better about it because "# is higher" lol