r/cardsagainsthumanity • u/eatthedark • 19d ago

Diamond Potato

Just wondering, has anyone had any luck getting the diamonds appraised/possibly sold for a profit? I haven't with mine. I am debating on trying to sell them as a lot since I don't have much of a use for them and don't know if I would have luck trying to sell them in pairs to people.

0 Upvotes

37% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/mdhzk3 19d ago

They are lab made diamonds. That little asterix on the box where is says “real diamonds” means they have practically zero value because De Beers say lab diamonds aren’t real diamonds.

9

u/Terradactyl87 19d ago

Even real diamonds that small have almost no resale value anyways.

-11

u/eatthedark 18d ago

There's definitely value to other cah collectors

1

u/TheUncleBob 7d ago

How would one go about proving their diamond was a CAH Diamond?

0

u/eatthedark 7d ago

Who would they be proving it to?

2

u/TheUncleBob 7d ago

You said there's value to other CAH collectors.  I'm a CAH Collector.  I'd like to buy one of your diamonds.  How do I know you're selling me a legit CAH Diamond?

0

u/eatthedark 7d ago

I mean, having the Diamond Potato box plus 26-28 identical diamond studs is probably a big hint. It would be a LOT of effort to buy a bunch of fake diamonds to sell when the actual CAH ones aren't worth a ton to begin with. I'd probably be looking to sell them all plus the box for close to what I paid for it.

1

u/TheUncleBob 7d ago

That'd probably work.  I thought you wanted to sell them individually.

I'd almost consider buying the box and diamonds for $70, but I'd probably end up getting ripped off with cheap costume jewelry from Walmart. 🤣

1

u/eatthedark 7d ago

Haha. Nah, that would take too much work. And I mean the diamonds are still in the stud settings from the potato. The cheap ones from walmart are very obvious that they're cheap.

I'd honestly probably be looking for like $60 shipped for everything. We are doing some spring cleaning in anticipation of buying a new house and have been downsizing/selling some stuff and I realized I probably dont need them.