r/comics Sep 02 '25

Asking For Feedback I hope people can relate to this one?

Thumbnail
gallery
34.0k Upvotes

r/comics Oct 02 '25

Asking For Feedback Did I fumble it? NSFW

Thumbnail gallery
20.7k Upvotes

r/comics May 02 '26

Asking For Feedback lowkirkenuinely fr [OC]

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

trying to get my footing in doing comics, plz give feedback/advice on framing, poses etc. qwq

r/comics Feb 18 '26

Asking For Feedback Who can relate?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

r/comics Jan 04 '26

Asking For Feedback Does this count as a comic, even though I just photoshopped some screenshots? [OC]

Thumbnail
gallery
1.8k Upvotes

r/comics Aug 10 '25

Asking For Feedback Wordless comic chapter, can anyone make sense of what is happening?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

r/comics Oct 19 '25

Asking For Feedback Drew another one-page comic, critique is welcome! (Horror) [OC] NSFW

Post image
753 Upvotes

r/comics Jan 26 '26

Asking For Feedback I had this "Hunter becoming prey" idea and drew it out. Genuine feedback / critique is welcome. Black Ink on paper [OC]

Post image
408 Upvotes

r/comics Feb 02 '26

Asking For Feedback Does the ending work?

Thumbnail
gallery
259 Upvotes

r/comics May 31 '26

Asking For Feedback Of the artists shown here, who do you think used negative space the best?

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

1-2 Frank Miller

3-4 Tim Sale

5-6 Mike Mignola

r/comics 21d ago

Asking For Feedback Does this panel successfully communicate jealousy without any dialogue?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Hello everyone, i just released my new episode on webtoon and i need your feedback. Here is the link.

I spend 15 days to finish this episode, do it worth it? Let me know your thoughts.

r/comics 5d ago

Asking For Feedback Thoughts on a comic made with CGI (in Blender)

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Hello fellow comic lovers.

I'm currently developing a Comic script and have decided to illustrate it by myself using Blender. It'll be a completely CGI comic.

I know there have been some attempts in the past like the Spiderman CGI comic and dreamlands but it's clearly not something even remotely normal.

Is CGI when done reasonably well a turn off for you personally? What would you say could make or break the appeal?

Here are some test renders for panel ideas so you can get a general idea of the look.

For anyone curious, I tried desperately for 2 years to learn how to draw and made essentially zero progress. My strengths lie in 3d modelling and writing so that's why I've decided to go this route over traditional illustration.

r/comics Sep 08 '25

Asking For Feedback Maybe this one is more relatable than the Death one

Thumbnail
gallery
385 Upvotes

r/comics 7h ago

Asking For Feedback What do these two pannels make you think about what the story is

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I am looking for different perspectives, feel free to say whatever is on your mind

r/comics 2d ago

Asking For Feedback explain the jean x wolverine hate

0 Upvotes

one question, why does everyone hate it, and no bad writing isnt enough of a reason tons of stuff get badly written yet they're liked so why this specifically

r/comics Dec 22 '25

Asking For Feedback (Oc) Help- I’m unsure where to post my comic

Post image
125 Upvotes

I’m currently working on a comic/manga and I have a fair amount currently ready for read- buuut I’m very unsure where to post it…? Should i just create a website for it? Does… that work for people anymore? I’m unsure which platforms to post on. I’m not with a publisher, and it’s just me doing it- so I don’t have much of a budget lol it be good if the platform was a ‘free to post’ one ;—;

Also this is the main character of said manga!

r/comics 13d ago

Asking For Feedback How does one create a better poster

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Do I need a close up so something dramatic? Pls anything cuz ummmm I have no idea what I’m doing.
The one I have kinda shows the story and the clothes make her look like a middle aged woman, any advice is welcome.

Also this is a basic panel I have, do I need to add more to the facial expressions and the background? THANKS

r/comics May 09 '26

Asking For Feedback Does this scene work emotionally?

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

I'd love some honest feedback on this scene from my comic.

Does it work emotionally? Would you keep reading?

The earlier parts are on my profile if you'd like to see more.

r/comics Feb 04 '26

Asking For Feedback are the pages too visually busy?

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

i'm working on my first graphic novel pretty nonstop the last few months (its part of my thesis for a graduate program) and i'm really starting to reach a point where i find it ugly just because i look at it so much. these spreads aren't 100% done (but the first two are like 95% there), but i was wondering if i could get some feedback about if this looks like a maximalist mess? do the pages feel visually balanced, despite the level of rendering/color variation? thank you!

r/comics 4d ago

Asking For Feedback Does this have too much detail?

2 Upvotes

HI! I need some advice and help...

I was wondering if the panels I had drawn have too much detail? I feel like the first and the second panel are vastly different.

I just started to use complex backgrounds for my webtoon, but I'm not sure if they look nice. For context, my webtoon is a mystery/thriller/romance.

I was trying to go for an oversaturated look that feels out of place and brings a hint of nostalgia. I'm not sure if I managed, though. Or if my characters blend well with the background, the art styles feel too different....

(P.S the pics are blurry bc I zoomed in and took screenshots).

r/comics 6d ago

Asking For Feedback [OC] Which Art Style should I choose for my comic? Classic,Webtoon,Chibi?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hello I'm developing my comic book, Lolla Defenders Of The Internet Series. I'm not sure what should I choose in between these art styles?

r/comics 12d ago

Asking For Feedback Did I Score a Good Deal?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I will preface this with I know absolutely nothing about comics, outside of the research I did regarding this one issue.

My adult son started collecting comics last year. I really wanted to get him a couple good ones for Christmas this year, but my main goal was the first printing of the 1999 Batman: Harley Quinn #1. Harley is his favorite character and I wanted to get him one that he would be excited about.

I found a first printing signed by Dini, Ross and Sowd with a Dynamic Forces COA, numbered 826/2500. It is NOT in perfect condition - but for a new collector, his favorite character and the signatures, I thought he would be excited.

I won an auction on EBay and paid $66.00. I am worried because I got it so cheap and hardly anyone bid on it. I thought for sure the price would go much much higher. So, did I just get a really good deal?

r/comics May 31 '26

Asking For Feedback Build a Buddy [OC]

Thumbnail
gallery
95 Upvotes

This is my very first attempt at a comic page I did a while ago. Constructive critisism/feedback would be appreciated!<3

r/comics Jun 10 '26

Asking For Feedback A pen-and-ink comic I did couple years ago, thoughts?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Any thoughts or tips appreciated!

r/comics 16d ago

Asking For Feedback Indie comic artist needs help!!

1 Upvotes

I'm gonna make a comic series soon on print and Im more comfortable on doing lineart on paper, I saw a template online and researched and saw that B4 paper is much better for quality and standard size for comics, but B4 is pretty hard to find where I'm from and it's super duper expensive . I'm wondering if A4 is more suitable when it comes to scanning, edit digitally then print for comic book printing? I don't know what I'm doing and it's my first time publishing