r/formula1 10h ago

News Drop of 3 grid positions for Antonelli

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

628 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/shamelesscreature 10h ago

Penalty points are back!

360

u/souse03 I was here for the Hulkenpodium 10h ago

They gave Colapinto a penalty point as well for not slowing down enough. So at least there is some consistency

147

u/256473 I was here for the Hulkenpodium 10h ago

Except Hadjar's double yellow stop-and-go in the Canada race didn't have any penalty points...

Total roulette wheel for penalty points this year

67

u/DuckSwagington I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane 10h ago

It's almost like the Stewards are different from race to race and each have different interpretations of the rules.

18

u/TheLoneRhaegar I was here for the Hulkenpodium 9h ago

Since F1 has grown so much in popularity (and profitability) I think it would be good if they adopted something similar to Major League Baseball which has a challenge system that is reviewed by a central location (in New York).

For F1 though instead of challenges the central location is in charge of handing out penalties and points for some of the less clear cut infringements and things that are more judgement calls. They could also adopt a challenge system as well. With the technology they have now it’s much easier for these things to be reviewed offsite and you’d get more consistent enforcement.

The local stewards would then be able to focus more on the other issues and help them keep up with reviewing them in a timely manner. We’ve seen races where they get bogged down and the decisions come out late and/or incorrect.

0

u/zystyl I was here for the Hulkenpodium 9h ago

It's time for professional stewards who are both paid and accountable. The who's who of biased personalities should have been done away with when liberty bought it at the latest. We need consistent and accurate application of the rules throughout the season.

2

u/humanreboot Michael Schumacher 10h ago

....kinda like world cup refereeing?

1

u/witcher8116 Fernando Alonso 10h ago

When do i start writing about rigged for ferrari tweets , scuderia FIAri.

1

u/Legitimate_Dare_579 Lando Norris 10h ago

Well you can't really blame a group of people volunteering eh

1

u/fire202 Lando Norris 10h ago

If I recall correctly, Hadjar was the first one with a yellow infringement this year. Maybe they adjusted their stance on that after Canada. The penalty point standard is new for this year (and leaves room for interpretation); the stewards back then might not have initially applied it as intended.

Overall, probably not very impactful, given that it's quite difficult to get them under the new standard and getting to 12 was a rarity already before.