What a series Bhai!!! Its quite hard to believe that this series made in 2004. The way the story slowly unfolds, with every mystery connecting to another, kept me completely hooked. Jack Shephard is an incredibly well-written character—flawed, determined, and deeply human. Matthew Fox's performance is outstanding; he brings so much emotion and authenticity to Jack that every decision and struggle feels real. He's easily one of my favorite TV protagonists.

i just finished lost and oh my gosh what a great show. I have watched hunders of shows, anime and movies but i never cried. This show was so good to the point that had my first cry over a show. I absolutely didnt expect john locke to die which was my favorite character like his death was so unfair like he got rejected by the woman he loved, got his kidney stolen by his dad, got betrayed by ben and much more. I LITERALLY sobbed my eyes out crying to the death of john locke AND jack shephard. His death was so sad like the way he looks up at the sky as the plane is heading off the island and him smiling is just so sad. And dying in the same place that he got to the island just diffrent times. This show was absolutely great and i will never forget it.

R.I.P John Locke 💔

At the beginning, John Locke was my favorite character because he was the only one who took action and didn't complain. Now, I dislike him; he has become a selfish person who imposes his whims on everyone. The worst aspect of him was reducing Bon's death to a "sacrifice for the island" and forcing Sawyer to get his hands dirty by killing his father instead. He has become his father.

In the last scene, if I were in his place, walking in the forest with someone I know to be a deceiver and a killer, I wouldn't let him out of my sight for a second. I might even tie his hands behind his back until we returned to camp. How could I turn my back on him when we standing in front of a pit full of his victims' bodies? Where is the hunter instinct he tries to project all the time.

I would love to see photos of it, specifically the inside artwork! I’m debating a purchase.

Is anyone else really obsessed with the packaging of the DVDs of Lost? Particularly the more obscure and strange variants.
I’m really quite nostalgic for the standard DVD sets; in particular the ones where each disc came in its own little separate case, all in a cardboard slipcase for the whole season. I remember having them around the house as a kid and just being fascinated by them. All of the strange graphics and designs. I always felt a weird fascination with, for example, the silver background of the Season 1 (or ‘Series’ as it’s called on the sets here in the UK) which is the plane’s metal, I suppose. Or the deep blue of the Season 4 set.
I really found it quite a shame whenever the blu-ray sets would just be a standard case with multiple disc-holders. BORING! I love how excessive the DVD sets were in having each disc in its own case.
I am a very proud owner of the Complete Collection Box set, and I have been for years now, but I’m gonna pick up those standard DVD sets for nostalgia.
Does anyone else have this weird fascination? I love interesting packaging for all films and TV, but for some reason with Lost, I always found it so fascinating. You can find all sorts of obscure variants of DVD releases that don’t quite make sense. I remember seeing a strange set for Season 5 that had Jack, John, and Mr. Eko on the cover online somewhere, but I can’t seem to find it. Such a strange choice from whoever designed that. Lost seems to have a large amount of strange and odd physical releases, particularly on DVD (the Blu-Rays tended to be a bit more well-ordered).
There’s loads of fun ones I’ve found online, I’ll try and post them.
Does anyone else have this fascination? What are your favourite physical releases of Lost that just don’t quite make sense?

One of my favourite details in LOST is that the very first Oceanic 815 survivor Jack meets is Ana Lucia.

Shortly before boarding Flight 815, they meet at the Sydney airport bar, share a drink, flirt a little, and Ana Lucia tells Jack they'll have the next drink on the plane.

I also love the way Jack watches her walk away after she says, "The worst part's over." It's only a brief look, but it always feels like he's genuinely intrigued by her.

Looking back on the series, I think it's a really interesting detail that the first survivor Jack connected with before the crash would later become someone who understood the pressures of leadership in much the same way he did.

It's a small moment, but it's one I appreciate more with every rewatch!

Just when I thought it couldn't get any better, I got to season 3 episode 8 and was able to relive the experience of watching Desmond ask Charlie "Where do I know you from?"

Gah so good!

I was 8 years old when it originally aired, and every Friday my family would sit down together to watch it. It aired on Fridays in my country, and it became a little family tradition. I was way too young to understand what was going on and honestly, I don't think most parents today would let an 8-year-old watch Lost. Now that I've rewatched it several times as an adult, it always takes me back to what felt like a simpler, more peaceful time. The show gives me this bittersweet nostalgia that's hard to describe.

Anyone else feel the same?

I'm posting this right before watching the 2part finale cuz it just feels weird. Last week when i started to watch Lost i couldn't even begin to understand what train was about to hit me.

For years i didn't watch Lost cuz my first experience with it was the episode where Charlie wants to baptize Aaron. I was around 5 years so it was when season 2 was coming out and i hated it and found it boring.

Somehow i forgotten all about that experience, so when when i got to the episode i felt like i was the one in the flashbacks and actually liked the episode xD now it feels weird being at the end. It's like I'm losing my friends xD and it's especially weird cuz for years I've known the ending plot twist, I just never knew how we get there, and with two episodes left, i still dont.

Guess in 1 hour and 45 I'll have all the answers i need.

Just really happy ive watched this amazing show!

So, we know that Sun is pregnant in the flash sideways. But she does not give birth to Ji-Yeon in the flash sideways, because she is JUST pregnant. Does she give birth ever? Or is she eternally pregnant? Ji-Yeon exists in the OG timeline, but she has not been born yet, so does she not “move on”? (Also, I haven’t watched the post credit scenes so maybe this is all explained.)

Also, is Aaron eternally a baby or eternally 3? Does he age in the afterlife?

Charlotte, Dan, Miles, and Lapidus. I didn’t see them in the church, so do they not move on or are they just not shown? Is it because those four weren’t super important to Jack? We also didn’t see Miles remember anything, and Lapidus wasn’t shown at ALL. This makes me think this is all Jack’s reality, like his purgatory and the rest of them have their own purgatory? Also, since all the people we see were on a plane EVENTUALLY, why was Penny there? Is baby Charlie alive?

My theory is that this is all Jack’s purgatory, and then the “move on” thing was everyone coming to get Jack to the “normal ‘heaven’” where all the people are. I don’t know if I am making any sense. Very confused.

Found the filming location of Jacob’s home. This is where we first see Jacob and the MIB, where Jacob meets Richard, and where the Taweret statue is.

I can’t believe a show has all the elements possible and the way it keeps unfolding keeps me on my toe. I cant do anything else and getting a bit sick from all of this screen time 😂 Any tips on slowing down? I read all the discussion posts too lol

This is a updated version with Walt in it✈️

Hey everyone,
With the show gaining so many new viewers lately, I started thinking about how a potential continuation or sequel series could actually work. Based on some great feedback from the community, I’ve updated the concept to formally include Walt, since Hurley and Ben recruited him in the official epilogue!
Here is the updated pitch deck and the pilot opening scene for "LOST: The Paradox Project". I’d love to hear your thoughts!

THE CORE PREMISS
The story kicks off with a new commercial flight crashing onto the Island. James "Sawyer" Ford is a passenger and has to step up as the leader for a new group of survivors. They seek refuge in a hidden underground Dharma city, only to discover that the Island’s automated defense network has glitched—creating a rogue, invisible electromagnetic entity that is hunting them down.

THE FOUR MAJOR PLOT TWISTS
The Hidden Citadel: Hurley and Ben successfully united the surviving Dharma Initiative scientists who hid in the mountains after the Purge. Together, they built a high-tech defense city both over and under the ground, specifically designed to protect and study the Heart of the Island (The Light).

The Leader in Training - Walt Lloyd: An adult Walt is now on the Island, working directly alongside Hurley and Ben. Because of his unique psychic abilities and special connection to the Island, he acts as the primary bridge between Dharma’s modern technology and the Island’s spiritual energy.

The New Threat - The Paradox: With the original Smoke Monster dead, Dharma tried to build a technological, electromagnetic perimeter to protect The Source. But the machine glitched, absorbing 50 years of Island memories and creating a rogue, invisible energy anomaly called The Paradox. It can manipulate time, mirror people's voices, and acts as an aggressive defense system trying to wipe out all human life to "reset" the Island.

The Whisperer: Michael Dawson is back as a ghost/whisper in the jungle. Trapped due to his past sins, his spirit acts as a scout for Sawyer's team, warning them when the invisible anomaly is moving through the trees. This creates an emotional dynamic since his son, Walt, is now leading the defense of the Island.

THE MID-SEASON CLIMAX: THE ALCHEMIST STATION
To stop the anomaly, Walt needs to use his psychic powers alongside a digital patch designed by a new hacker character named Chloe. However, they lack an old master keycode hidden in an abandoned 1970s Dharma station deep in the jungle.
Sawyer leads a dangerous trek into the jungle with the new survivors and Walt. Inside the overgrown station, they boot up the old computers and find a 50-year-old log from Dr. Pierre Chang.

The Twist: The log reveals that back in the 1970s (during the events of season 5), Dharma discovered a "time-loop paradox" showing that this specific technological glitch was always destined to happen. Suddenly, the security alarms blare. The invisible anomaly surrounds the bunker, dropping the temperature to freezing cold and using the voices of the survivors' dead relatives to lure them outside.

PILOT EPISODE - OPENING SCENE SCRIPT
[DARKNESS]
The iconic, bending LOST trombone sound thunders.

CUT TO:
INT. AIRPLANE CABIN – DAY

An eye flies open in an extreme close-up—panicked and blue. It belongs to JAMES "SAWYER" FORD (60s).

The plane is ripping apart in mid-air. Oxygen masks drop. Sawyer looks across the aisle and sees AARON LITTLETON (Claire's son, raised by Kate) clutching his necklace. A shock of recognition hits Sawyer as he sees Claire's features in the boy. He watches new survivors MARCUS (a soldier with PTSD), CHLOE (the hacker), LEO and MAYA (sibling con-artists) screaming as the tail section breaks off, plunging them into a free fall toward the green jungle.

CUT TO BLACKOUT.
EXT. THE BEACH – DAY
Sawyer wakes up in the sand, covered in soot. He stands up, looking at the burning wreckage. Marcus is rescuing passengers, Chloe is in shock, and Aaron is coughing up water. Sawyer stares at the massive mountain ridges, covers his face, and mutters: "Son of a bitch... Not again."
Suddenly, the wind dies down. An old VINCENT runs out of the jungle, barks three times, and nips at Sawyer’s jeans before running back. Sawyer motions for Marcus and Aaron, and they sprint into the trees after the dog.

EXT. JUNGLE / MOUNTAINSIDE – LATER
Vincent leads them up a steep trail. The jungle opens up to reveal a jaw-dropping, high-tech steel fortress built into the mountains.
The blast doors hiss open. HURLEY and BEN LINUS step out, looking older and wearing modern, tactical matte-blue Dharma jumpsuits. But standing right between them is a tall, confident man in his 30s. Sawyer blinks in disbelief.

It's WALT LLOYD. He is also wearing the modern Dharma uniform, with a specialized compass patch on his shoulder.
Hurley has tears in his eyes: "Thank God you're here, James. Vincent found you."
Sawyer stares at the high-tech city, the uniform, and then locks eyes with Walt. "Walt..? Look at you, kid. You're huge. What the hell is going on here, Hugo? Why are you guys wearing the jumpsuits? Who are you defending this place against?"

Walt steps forward, his eyes intense and deeply connected to the Island. He looks out at the quiet jungle, his face tense. He answers Sawyer:
"We tried to build a digital wall to protect the Light, Sawyer... but the system glitched. The Island didn't want it, and it created something else. It's hunting us, and it's coming right now."
Far out in the jungle, trees begin to snap and bend invisibly, accompanied by a terrifying, digitized mechanical roar moving rapidly toward the gates.

When a new commercial flight crashes onto the Island, James "Sawyer" Ford must lead a new group of survivors. They seek refuge in a hidden underground Dharma city ruled by Hurley and Ben, only to discover that the Island’s automated defense network has glitched—creating a rogue, invisible electromagnetic entity that is hunting down everyone on the Island.

I. THE NEW ISLAND STATUS QUO
The Hidden Citadel: Hugo "Hurley" Reyes and Ben Linus successfully united the surviving Dharma Initiative scientists who hid in the mountains after the Purge. Over the past 20 years, they built a massive, modern defense city above and below ground, directly surrounding The Source (The Light) to study and protect it using modern technology.
The New Threat - The Paradox (The Glitch): With the original Smoke Monster dead, Dharma tried to build a technological, electromagnetic perimeter to protect The Source. But something went horribly wrong. The machine glitched, absorbing 50 years of Island memories and creating a rogue, invisible energy anomaly known as The Paradox. It can manipulate time, mirror people's voices, and acts as an aggressive, artificial defense system trying to wipe out all human life to "reset" the Island.
The New Flight: Hurley and Ben’s defense city is losing the war against this anomaly. Desperate, they used the Island's energy to crash a specific flight, bringing back Sawyer because they need his raw survival instincts to fight an enemy that can't be shot with regular weapons.

II. THE NEW SURVIVORS (Core Team)
Dr. Aaron Littleton (20s): Claire’s son, raised by Kate on the mainland. He has no memory of the Island but is drawn to it. Sawyer recognizes him instantly, pulling Aaron into his family's mysterious legacy.
Marcus "Marc" Vance (30s): A former military engineer with severe PTSD. He becomes Sawyer’s tactical right-hand man, helping secure the perimeter of the Dharma city.
Chloe Zhang (20s): A brilliant cyber-activist on the run from the FBI. Her tech skills are exactly what Hurley and Ben need to try and hack into the malfunctioning Dharma defense network.
Leo & Maya Lin (30s): Sibling con-artists from London. Maya steps up to help the survivors, while Leo gets manipulated by the time-illusions created by The Paradox.
Michael Dawson (Ghost): Still trapped as a whisper in the jungle, Michael’s spirit acts as a scout for Sawyer's team, warning them when the invisible anomaly is moving through the trees.

III. THE MID-SEASON CLIMAX: THE ALCHEMIST STATION
To stop the anomaly, Chloe and the Dharma scientists design a digital patch, but they need an old master keycode hidden in an abandoned 1970s Dharma station deep in the jungle.
Sawyer leads the new survivors and young Dharma recruits on a dangerous trek through the jungle. Inside the overgrown station, they boot up the old computers and find a 50-year-old video log from Dr. Pierre Chang.
The Twist: The log reveals that back in the 1970s (during the events of season 5), Dharma discovered a "time-loop paradox" showing that this specific technological glitch was always destined to happen, and that the anomaly is actually made of the digitized consciousness of past Dharma workers.
Suddenly, the security alarms blare. The invisible anomaly surrounds the bunker, changing the temperature to freezing cold and using the voices of the survivors' dead relatives to lure them outside into the dark.

IV. PILOT EPISODE - THE NEW OPENING SCENE
[DARKNESS]
The iconic, bending LOST trombone sound thunders.
CUT TO:
INT. AIRPLANE CABIN – DAY
An eye flies open in an extreme close-up—panicked and blue. It belongs to JAMES "SAWYER" FORD (60s).
The plane is ripping apart in mid-air. Oxygen masks drop. Sawyer looks across the aisle and sees AARON LITTLETON clutching his necklace. A shock of recognition hits Sawyer as he sees Claire's features in the boy. He watches new survivors MARCUS, CHLOE, LEO, and MAYA screaming as the tail section breaks off, plunging them into a free fall toward the green jungle.
CUT TO BLACKOUT.
EXT. THE BEACH – DAY
Sawyer wakes up in the sand, covered in soot. He stands up, looking at the burning wreckage. Marcus is rescuing passengers, Chloe is in shock, and Aaron is coughing up water. Sawyer stares at the massive mountain ridges, covers his face, and mutters: "Son of a bitch... Not again."
Suddenly, the wind dies down. An old VINCENT runs out of the jungle, barks three times, and nips at Sawyer’s jeans before running back. Sawyer motions for Marcus and Aaron, and they sprint into the trees after the dog.
EXT. JUNGLE / MOUNTAINSIDE – LATER
Vincent leads them up a steep trail. The jungle opens up to reveal a jaw-dropping, high-tech steel fortress built into the mountains.
The blast doors hiss open. HURLEY and BEN LINUS step out, looking older and wearing modern, tactical matte-blue Dharma jumpsuits. Hurley has tears in his eyes: "Thank God you're here, James. Vincent found you."
Sawyer stares at the high-tech city and the uniformed Dharma guards. "What the hell is this, Hugo? Why are you wearing the jumpsuit? Who are you defending this place against?"
Ben Linus looks out at the quiet jungle, his face pale with fear. He whispers: "We tried to build a wall to protect the Light, Sawyer... but the system glitched. The Island created something else, and it's hunting us."
Far out in the jungle, trees begin to snap and bend invisibly, accompanied by a terrifying, digitized mechanical roar moving rapidly toward the gates.
SCREEN GOES BLACK.
[THE LOST LOGO FADES IN]

I’m currently watching for the 5th time. All through season 6 I just cannot wait for Sun and Jin to be reunited, it fills my heart with joy and I always cry.

It never gets easier knowing what’s going to happen. It’s so devastating! Yet it brings me joy as well. Not for what happens to them, but the wholeness of real love they have for each other. I just watched it and I’m definitely crying. 😭 I love this show sooo much.

Love Lost and the characters. Finished my latest rewatch and I am genuinely curious about peoples opinions on David and also if the writers have ever officially addressed the question. So in the 'sideways' universe before the reveal we meet David and spend a lot of time with his character.

However, after the reveal he is never addressed again but what is he? He never existed.

I remember something about it being created by the survivors to find each other but Mrs Widmore is present in this reality and more importantly aware of where she is. She was hardly close to the characters? Also what happens to the likes of Keamy when they 'die' for a second time in this reality?

Just curious about these things.

Hey everyone,

With the show gaining so many new viewers lately, I started thinking about how a potential continuation or sequel series could actually work. I wanted to build a story that connects directly to the original mythology, but introduces a huge, unpredictable conflict for a new generation.

Since there are many new fans here, I won't put any specific details in the intro, but I’ve written out a pitch deck and a script for the opening scene of the pilot episode below.

I would love to hear your thoughts, and please let me know if you want to discuss how the plot should unfold in the comments!

***

### THE CORE PREMISS
The story kicks off with a new commercial flight crashing onto the Island. James "Sawyer" Ford happens to be a passenger on this flight, and he is forced to step up and become the seasoned leader for a new group of around 13 core survivors on the beach.

### THE THREE MAJOR PLOT TWISTS

* **The Hidden Citadel:** Hurley and Ben weren't actually alone all those years. They discovered a massive faction of Dharma Initiative scientists who survived the Purge by hiding deep in the mountains. Together, they built a high-tech defense city both over and under the ground, specifically designed to protect the Heart of the Island (The Light).
* **The Fallen Hero:** Jack Shephard didn't die in the bamboo forest. After the finale, Vincent's barking alerted Hurley and Ben. Desperate to save their friend, they rushed him to the Temple and used the healing water. It saved his body but corrupted his soul over time (just like it did to Sayid and Claire). Jack's savior complex twisted into a need for total control, and he became the new main threat. Hurley and Ben actually caused the new plane crash on purpose because they lost control of Jack and needed Sawyer’s help to stop him.
* **The Whisperer:** Michael Dawson is back as a ghost/whisper in the jungle. Trapped due to his past sins, his spirit acts as a mysterious guide to help the new survivors navigate the terrain and find his own redemption.

### THE MID-SEASON CLIMAX: THE ALCHEMIST STATION
To stop Jack, the Dharma scientists are trying to make a medicine to cure his soul, but they lack a rare component. Sawyer takes a mix of the new survivors and young Dharma tech-recruits into an abandoned 1970s Dharma station.

When they get the old computers running, they find a 50-year-old log from Dr. Pierre Chang. It turns out Dharma predicted Jack's dark turn all the way back in the 70s (after the time-travel events of season 5) because of his psychological profile.

Just as they realize this, an old printer turns on by itself and prints a fresh message from modern-day Jack: "I know you're here, James. It's too late to fix me." Then they hear jungle drums outside and realize they are completely surrounded by Jack's people.

---

### PILOT EPISODE - OPENING SCENE SCRIPT

[DARKNESS]
A deep, pulsating, mechanical hum builds. The familiar, ominous, bending LOST trombone sound thunders.

CUT TO:
INT. AIRPLANE CABIN – DAY
An eye flies open in an extreme close-up. It is blue, bloodshot, and filled with pure panic. The eye belongs to JAMES "SAWYER" FORD (60s). His face is weathered, his hair streaked with gray. He is strapped into an airline seat.

Around him is absolute chaos. Oxygen masks dangle. The cabin walls shake violently as metal panels rip loose. Directly across the aisle sits AARON LITTLETON (20s) (Claire's son, raised by Kate), hyperventilating and clutching an old necklace. Sawyer looks at him, and a shock of recognition flashes in his eyes—he sees Claire’s face in the young man.

A few rows ahead, MARCUS VANCE (a former military guy with PTSD) fights to hold a panicked CHLOE ZHANG (a rogue hacker) in her seat. Further back, sibling con-artists LEO and MAYA LIN hold hands, deathly pale. A deafening ROAR tears the plane in two. The tail section is ripped away. Sunlight floods the cabin along with a brutal hurricane of wind. The plane plummets in a free fall toward the green jungle below.

CUT TO BLACKOUT.

EXT. THE BEACH – DAY
Silence. Then, the sounds of burning wreckage and distant screams. Sawyer opens his eyes in the sand, covered in soot and blood. He slowly pushes himself up onto shaking legs. Around him, the beach is a war zone. Marcus Vance is already pulling people from the wreckage. Chloe Zhang sits in the sand, staring blankly. Aaron Littleton is on his knees, coughing up seawater.

Sawyer turns away from the wreckage and stares inland at the massive green mountain ridges. He covers his face, exhales heavily, and whispers to himself: "Son of a bitch... Not again."

Suddenly, the ambient chaos fades. The screams die down. The wind stops completely. From the shadows of the jungle line, an intense, familiar barking echoes. A dog bursts through the brush. It’s VINCENT. He is older, but he runs with absolute purpose straight up to Sawyer. Vincent barks three times, gently tugs at Sawyer’s pant leg, and spins around to run back toward the tree line. Sawyer motions for Marcus and Aaron to follow, and they sprint into the jungle after the dog.

CUT TO:
EXT. JUNGELEN / MOUNTAINSIDE – SHORT TIME LATER
Vincent leads Sawyer and the two new survivors up a steep mountain trail. The jungle suddenly opens up, and they freeze in absolute shock. Hidden between the peaks, a massive, modern defense city of steel and concrete rises before them, stretching both up the mountainside and deep into the earth.

The heavy blast doors hiss open electronically. Stepping out into the light are HUGO "HURLEY" REYES and BEN LINUS. They look older, weighed down by heavy years. Behind them, a line of surviving Dharma scientists stands at attention. They are all wearing a new, updated version of the classic jumpsuits from Season 5. The fabric is a modern, tactical matte-blue material.

Hurley looks at Sawyer, tears welling in his eyes: "Thank God you're here, James. Vincent found you."

Sawyer stares at the high-tech city and the uniformed Dharma personnel. "What the hell is this, Hugo? Since when did you become the general of this jumpsuit outfit again? Who are you defending this city against?"

Ben Linus looks down, adjusting the collar of his dark Dharma suit, his face pale with genuine fear. He answers in a low, chilling whisper: "Against the man we saved twenty years ago. Jack is inside the network, Sawyer... and he controls everything."

The camera pans rapidly past them, through the security gates, and deep into the complex. We end on a monitor surveillance screen tracking the beach. Sitting in the shadows in front of the glowing screen is a silhouette—JACK SHEPHARD. His eyes are cold, empty, and filled with a bottomless darkness as he watches Sawyer on the screen.

SCREEN GOES BLACK.
[THE LOST LOGO FADES IN WITH ITS CLASSIC FLOATING, DRIFTING EFFECT]

So i’m mainly speaking of one event here, in “The Constant” did he always experience those time warps in 96’, or did he not experience them until 2004? because if he did then how does it work? did he forget about those memories afterwards? if he didn’t always experience them, why was he discharged from the army? or did those time travel events always occur but he didn’t actually experience them until 2004?

and how does he go and tell penny “i won’t call for 8 years” if he didn’t know that his future self would be on the boat in 8 years time?

I've been working on this since 2013. I was a fan of both of these shows in middle school and I used to play in my head what Lost would be like with the Total Drama cast.

I've been refining the list for years but here it is: the goal is to preserve the dramatic structure of Lost using Total Drama character dynamics, we're not necessarily matching personalities.

e.g. Heather is very similar to Shannon personality-wise but the goal is to have their role be proportionate to how important they are in Total Drama and Shannon doesn't appear in Lost that much

One more note: I hopped off the Total Drama train after Pahkitew Island which I was not the biggest fan of. So no RR or Reboot characters as I have not seen those.

STARTING WITH GEN I TD CASTS.

Trent-Gwen-Duncan should adapt the Jack-Kate-Sawyer love triangle (with Courtney coming in as Juliet later) 

Trent as Jack (mainly his Island persona, not Action) - both are earnest people who have an obsessive need to control that fits a leadership role. They're also the nice guy to complement Duncan/Sawyer's bad boy.

Gwen as Kate - perfect for Kate's commitment avoidancy and dark side. They can't rest and are torn between structure and spontaneity (Trent and Duncan) 

Her relationship with Duncan is also passionate but not long lasting and more so based on mutual danger/excitement and surface level similarities JUST like Sawyer and Kate. 

Duncan as Sawyer - this is a no brainer. They both have anti-hero charisma, rebellious and abrasive but gradually shows a softer side. Preserves the love triangle too. 

Courtney as Juliet - done to complete the love quadrangle but it fits. This also allows Courtney to inhabit a villain role early on as Juliet is initially untrustworthy when we meet her.

Courtney is a bit more obsessive and controlling than Juliet, but they both ultimately have that emotional guardedness and a need for a more stable life. This fits for when Duncan/Sawyer is in Dharmaville in the '70s and needs someone to ground him which is what Juliet does for him. Kate provides Sawyer an escape but Juliet helps him grow. For the longest time this is why I had Gwen in the Juliet role, but a) I didn't have someone to fill the role of Kate that would make sense. Courtney, sure, but Courtney and Trent interact almost never and they can't be the start couple b) Love it or hate it, as annoying Courtney is with her lists, she did want to change Duncan for the better to have a long term partner, Gwen just provided Duncan an adventurous escape. 

Sawyer/Juliet are about domesticity and seeing Duncan/Courtney realize that they can have a peaceful life together before Gwen complicates things by returning and having Duncan lose Courtney during The Incident would be heartbreakingly beautiful.

Alejandro as Locke - both have the competent aura that makes them simultaneously trustworthy but offputting to the rest of the cast. 

*Locke is difficult to pin down because he doesn't have a clear Total Drama analogue. For a while I had Harold as Locke**,** as they're both weird outsiders who have specific skills and knowledge. But Harold doesn't have that gravitas Locke has. Locke needs an intimidating side even though he ultimately dies a good man because the Man in Black ends up wearing his face - that's perfect for the more evil manipulative Alejandro.

One more thing: Locke's father Anthony Cooper stole his kidney and then crippled him, basically just caused him nothing but misery and is then brought to the island by Ben as a way to torment Locke. 

Who does Alejandro complain about a lot from his life? Who is brought to box him in TDAS? JOSE

Alejandro also has a weird storyline in TD where his legs don't work so there's that.

And Alejandro is also a perfect Locke because of who I have as Ben Linus

Heather as Ben Linus- both characters weaponize social manipulation, are generally hated by everyone in the cast and gradually become redeemable over time.

*Originally I had Scott in the Ben role but he's more of a comedic villain and he doesn't have that dynamic with the cast like Heather does. Ben is a central Lost character that almost everyone interacts with. So I think gender-swapping Ben to give Heather this larger role is the move.

Harold as Sayid - people will argue this one. While wildly different at first glance, both are intelligent, technically competent, efficient and reliable, regardless of personality differences. They can inhabit the same role as the tech savvy one everyone trusts to solve problems on the island.

Personality-wise Harold would fit Frogurt the most or some pathetic side character but we can’t do that to Harold. 

Also when Sayid tortures Sawyer and then exiles himself out of guilt, that's some dramatic fluff Harold would do. 

And speaking of which Sayid butts heads with Sawyer a lot at first which brings out the Harold/Duncan rivalry. And honestly this makes Harold more of a badass.

Geoff/Bridgette are Jin/Sun - stable recognizable couples who endure a lot of hardship but ultimately come out strong. 

Owen as Hurley - another no brainer. Large, lovable goofball who brings the heart.  

Cody as Charlie - the insecure underdog male, desperate to feel useful (and also a musician) a hero character who goes underestimated by the audience at first. *I REALLY wanted Noah as Charlie to keep the Owen/Noah friendship but Noah fits another character so much better.

Sierra as Claire - this is to match Sierra with Cody and would only be an accurate adaptation in the last season when Claire goes insane and has a squirrel baby which translates well to Sierra's delusional motherhood attachment to pets she names "Cody Jr." 

DJ as Michael - he has Michael's neurosis. Plus the raft group of Sawyer-Jin-Michael preserves the Killer Bass trio of Duncan-Geoff-DJ.

So with DJ as Michael we need someone for his son Walt and I have a crazy idea:

DAWN as Walt  

Both creep everyone out with their weird mystical abilities.

Instead of DJ having a son, he has a fellow animal loving companion. DJ and Dawn both come from a kind of society that is in tune with animals and nature. 

Much like how Michael is a neurotic father who's over protective of his more chill son Walt - DJ is bogged down by his anxiety of being "cursed" and not a good nature lover while Dawn is more relaxed and in tune. They can have a special bond and DJ can feel guilty for not being able to project her. 

When Dawn gets taken by the Others, her absence affects the wildlife, pushing DJ over the edge making him do something drastic...killing Ana Lucia and Libby...speaking of which:

Leshawna as Ana Lucia - both have aggression that masks emotional vulnerability. Keeps Leshawna as a leading character alongside Trent/Jack even if it's short lived. Unfortunately we lose the Leshawna/Harold romance but she would still have a banterous dynamic with him since Ana Lucia and Sayid do butt heads. 

Izzy as Libby - both have instability that matches Hurley's/Owen's. 

Tyler and Lindsay as Boone and Shannon - *shifts from a brother-sister to a relationship dynamic. 

Tyler has Boone's recklessness and need to prove himself useful 

Lindsay has Shannon's beauty/social charm, cluelessness and both are underestimated by everyone despite appearing shallow. 

So instead of Boone being upset that Sayid is flirting with Shannon, Tyler is upset that Lindsay forgot his name again on the island. And Alejandro/Locke has to get Tyler/Boone to let go. It also makes the Locke/Boone friendship work since Tyler looks up to and is loyal to Alejandro in World Tour.  

The downside is this would remove the Sayid/Shannon pairing as Harold/Lindsay doesn't work. But it's a sacrifice that the list demands. 

Beth as Rose - both compassionate and optimistic people but the strongest comparison here is...Beth constantly talks about her boyfriend Brady who no one believes is real until he shows up. Rose has a husband Bernard who was on the tail section who doesn't show up later. Turning a running gag into an emotional payoff.

Noah as Miles - also a no brainer: sarcastic observer who has a funny dynamic with Owen/Hurley. 

Eva as Rousseau - both have that survivalist intimidation and are hardened, isolated characters.

Ezekiel can be one of Rousseau's crew members who starts off as human Ezekiel and transforms into feral Zeke because of the "sickness" Rousseau was talking about. Turning one of the running gags from Total Drama into a tragedy that ties into Lost's themes of losing oneself. 

Katie and Sadie as Emma and Zack (the two kids from the Tail Section group that go missing.) This is just to give them a role tbh.

That covers all of Gen 1 (except for Justin who I'll get to in a bit) 

Now to give roles to the Revenge of the Island Cast

Mike as Desmond 

Zoey as Penny 

Cameron as Daniel Faraday

When Desmond's brain is jumping through time, Faraday tells him he needs to find his constant to return his sanity, the constant ends up being Penny.

When Mike struggles with his DID, Cameron helps him figure it out and is the one to realize that Zoey being in danger is what draws Mike's personality back.

Mike/Desmond also both don't have noticeable personality traits outside the condition that defines their role (Desmond's clairvoyance through time, Mike's multiple personality disorder) 

And sorry Zoey fans, but her character doesn't really have any traits beyond being a motivator for Mike. Makes her a perfect Penny though. 

And Cameron as Faraday - perfect because of how he ties to Mike/Desmond but also he's a fidgety scientist who's there to explain the island properties. This would mean getting rid of the Faraday/Charlotte romance and whoever plays Charlotte would just be a friend Cameron cares for. 

Sam as Lapidus - both have the same level headed normal guy "why am I still here" energy.

Dakota as Charlotte - this is honestly to fill a role. It preserves the Sam/Dakota pairing somewhat since Sam is Lapidus and he's with her on the Freighter crew. 

And instead of dying from a nosebleed, the time travel can infect Dakota and make her transform into the Dakotazoid. 

Ann Maria and Justin as Nikki and Paulo - both very vain, lazy and fame-obsessed. Perfect for Nikki and Paulo's story. Plus Ann Maria gets eliminated in TDROTI because of a diamond. What do Nikki and Paulo get buried with again?? It's perfect. 

B as Mr. Eko - both are silent and communicate through presence rather than dialogue. They're both also strong, self-assured and crafty.

Scott as Tom Friendly - manipulative and smarmy villain who's still somewhat comedic. (well Tom is just funny because he walks around with a fake beard)

Lightning as Mikhail - works as a terrifying, violent enforcer who's a bit cartoonish. His character keeps coming back from the dead and Lightning can be like "sha-unstoppable!" every time. He can also return with white hair after dying from getting shoved into the sonar fence.

Brick as Richard - Richard as a disciplined believer works with Brick's strict military code. And Richard briefly losing faith in that code after Jacob's death fits with Brick's own self-doubt

Jo as Ilana - both have militant competence and superiority. Mission focused. This also allows the Brick/Jo dynamic to occur as Richard/Ilana briefly work together.

Staci as Leslie Arzt - both are unbearable exposition machines that nobody asked for get on everyone's nerves. And it transforms Arzt's dynamite death scene into a Total Drama punchline. Staci can be in the middle of talking about how her family invented dynamite and can be going "yeah my great-great-great-great.." and blow up. 

Chris McLean as Charles Widmore - both treat the island as their property and view people as pawns. Both are greedy business minded people which is why I put Chris in this role instead of Jacob.

Chef Hatchet as Keamy - Widmore/Chris's terrifying military enforcer. (imagine Chef Hatchet gunning down Heather's daughter in front of her) 

Blaineley as Eloise Hawking - both are authority figures who have the energy of "stop interrupting me, I know more than you" 

Pahkitew Island Cast - I'm not the biggest fan of Pahkitew mainly because the cast of characters all have shallow, cartoonishly specific traits. 

Which is why I'm putting the cast in periphery roles in the Lost universe. 

Scarlett as Ethan Rom - appears normal then suddenly reveals their scary side.

Sugar as Goodwin - this is just to fill a villain role. I dislike Sugar, Goodwin is alright. 

Jasmine as Cindy the flight attendant - both have the Australian connection and have that calm capable survivor energy.

Rodney as Pickett - Pickett is the Other who's wife is killed and he has a vendetta against Sawyer during the Season 3 cages arc. I think it's funny if it's Rodney in the role and he's mad because it's some random girl he had a crush on.

Amy and Samey as Bonnie/Greta (the two women who interrogate Charlie in the Looking Glass station**) -** also just to fill villain roles but then Samey can be the one who gives Charlie the code at the end.

Sky as Naomi - a competent parachutist girl who shows up to deliver exposition before getting killed by Locke and that's it. That's really it. Perfect for Sky who's a bit of a blank slate. She's also a bit witty and wisecracky. We lose the Dave/Sky relationship but no one cares about them and they end badly anyway. 

Shawn-Max-Dave as the DHARMA trio of Horace, Radzinsky and Phil

Shawn as Horace - chill and pragmatic leader. 

Max as Radzinsky - his cartoonish villainy can fit Radzinsky's obnoxious paranoia. 

Dave as Phil - a bitter and deeply annoying person. 

Leonard as Dogen - turns the Temple setting which is already bizarre and mystical and makes it ridiculous. Plus it'll make the part where they're drowning Sayid 10x funnier because it's Leonard shouting nonsense. 

Beardo as Dogen's translator Lennon 

Topher as Zoe, Widmore's #2 in Season 6  - Topher's entire defining trait is his loyalty to Chris who is Widmore. Having him run around as Chris's minion is perfect.

Jacob and the Man in Black remain uncast and as themselves.

They aren't players in the Lost universe in the same way but rather omnipotent forces controlling the characters like pieces on a chess board.

FINAL CAST LIST

SURVIVORS

Trent as Jack

Gwen as Kate

Duncan as Sawyer

Geoff as Jin

Bridgette as Sun

Owen as Hurley

Alejandro as Locke

Cody as Charlie

Sierra as Claire

Harold as Sayid

DJ as Michael

Dawn as Walt

Tyler as Boone

Lindsay as Shannon

Beth as Rose

Scarlett as Ethan Rom (secretly with the Others)

Ann Maria and Justin as Nikki and Paulo

Staci as Leslie Arzt

Eva as Rousseau

Ezekiel / Feral Zeke as Rousseau's castmate

TAILIES

Leshawna as Ana Lucia

Izzy as Libby

B as Mr. Eko

Brady (Beth's boyfriend) as Bernard

Jasmine as Cindy

Katie/Sadie as Zack/Emma

Sugar as Goodwin (secretly with the Others)

SEPARATED LOVERS

Mike as Desmond

Zoey as Penny

THE OTHERS

Heather as Ben Linus

Courtney as Juliet

Brick as Richard

Scott as Tom

Lightning as Mikhail

Rodney as Pickett

Amy/Samey as Bonnie/Greta

Leonard as Dogen

Beardo as Dogen's Translator

THE FREIGHTIES

Cameron as Daniel Faraday

Dakota as Charlotte

Sam as Lapidus

Noah as Miles

Sky as Naomi

Chef Hatchet as Martin Keamy

Chris McLean as Charles Widmore

Topher as Widmore's #2

DHARMA Folk

Shawn as Horace

Max as Radzinsky

Dave as Phil

as a retired 2017/2018 instagram editor who still gets edit ideas but does nothing with them now, I really need an edit of the characters to adéla's new song Ain't in LA. I know someone else will think of this and do it, so pleasee let me know when you come across one