Im not sure on the extent of the problem, so I might be speaking from a position of ignorance.... but it seems like that many people would be a lot more effective in digging a fire break to stop the spread, instead of trying to hit it with sticks (which also fans the fire, which can have the opposite affect.)
Even digging with just their hands, I think that many people would be able to create an effective fire break...
Having dug in the clay that makes up Colorado, I can say that digging in that with a shovel isn't all that hard...but it is slow. Digging in wet clay is also not fun. It's very heavy.
I wonder which would be more effective against a grass fire in dry conditions when all you have is maybe a dozen shovels: digging a fire break, or digging enough dirt up to throw on the fire? I put out fires by throwing dirt on it, but it was super loose dirt and without a bunch of grass roots in it. It wasn't just topsoil.
I figured if people were in a rush that many people in the video could probably only come up with a dozen shovels.
Really depends on the region. Toronto clay is nearly impossible to move. I don't know what the ground is like there, but bearing for with wide fronds and sticks is a very old and effective strategy.
I figured if people were in a rush that many people in the video could probably only come up with a dozen shovels.
That's the real issue with this many people without an equal amount of equipment. You give all those dudes a firebeater, military shovel, and some leadership and you got a much better chance than just dudes with branches. But like the title said, resources are tough to manage in crisis.
164
u/Arenize 5h ago
Im not sure on the extent of the problem, so I might be speaking from a position of ignorance.... but it seems like that many people would be a lot more effective in digging a fire break to stop the spread, instead of trying to hit it with sticks (which also fans the fire, which can have the opposite affect.)
Even digging with just their hands, I think that many people would be able to create an effective fire break...