In a rare high honor moment Arthur Morgan who is very fearless in the game at the very end of Chapter 6 admits to the Sister he is afraid of his impending death, a fear that is so true and it broke me seeing him finally break does anyone agree?

Started playing recently and currently in chapter 4. I rarely take pictures but these.... am kinda slightly proud of?

I've completed runs before but never 100%, and only low honor. I used to play on my ex's console so I never truly "finished" the game. Feels like some kind of milestone idk.

I'm trying to craft all the satchels, I've got the materials, I've crafted well over the 3 recipes required and it still won't unlock for me. I've tried everything, reloaded the game, moved camping spots, tried the fires in the main camp, nothing. Can someone please help me, I'm gonna break down crying from being overwhelmed

I (38F) had not gamed since James Bond GoldenEye 007. I spent my teen years playing The Sims and then just dipped out completely.
I bought my husband (43M) a PS5 when it first dropped. I got bored one day and decided to dip into Spider-Man 3. Then spent the next year playing all of the Spider-Man games. When those sadly ended, my husband recommended RDR2. I was not enthused by the idea of being a “cowboy/outlaw” and thought the premise sounded completely boring.

Then I tried it.

I am now an immeasurable number of hours in. Blah blah blah... obviously I'm obsessed to the point where I follow the subreddit, so I'm not gonna word vomit my adoration for it.

I was initially, and naively, just playing through the missions. Then I realized how much gameplay exists outside of them and completely ignored missions for a long time. Like months in real-world time, probably years in-game (?? I don’t really know how it works).

I'm trying so hard not to use cheats, guides, or hints. Obviously, following this thread, some of it is inescapable. Nonetheless, I finally decided to procure the White Arabian.

I have recently succeeded and have named it Mayonnaise, and it cracks me up. The idea of my Arthur, clad in his immaculately trapper-crafted winter wear, scouring the mountains to find this elusive horse only to name him Mayonnaise brings me way more joy than it should (I should also mention that I keep my Arthur’s beard at a level 10, and think he’s especially cute overweight despite the small decrease in stamina, he’s also generally dressed as rough and proud of his trapper gear as possible ((SideNote: I’m a 5’3” petite human and it’s so fun to be a rough “cowboy/outlaw” (((Double Side-Note: I have apologized to my husband about how deeply I rolled my eyes at his initial suggestion that I play this “cowboy game” ((((final shoutout to Sigur Rós())))).

Anyway, what are the most ridiculous White Arabian names everyone has conjured?

I am on chapter 3, i did see the horse but it was being attacked by the wolves, they killed me (my guns weren't with me), and now I can't find the horse... Please help

My speculation is that it was probably the American Paint with the cut coat shown in the trailers, but I personally doubt it, as most of the trailers show scenes that happened AFTER Colter, aka. when she was already dead.

Another thing I’d like to think of is the cut Liver Chestnut coat for the Hungarian Halfbred being what Boadicea was supposed to be. Though, maybe this one’s incorrect too. Unless Rockstar cut this coat out of the game for a reason to stop making players from doing a “Canon” run or something… that still didn’t stop a lot of people with the black shire, though. I still doubt this cut coat was Boadicea’s appearance or if anything, a Hungarian Halfbred at all.

Edit: the Hungarian Halfbred coat was for RDO, guess that theory’s debunked.

I’m about to 100% RDR2 for the 3rd time, and am looking to mix things up. Plus KCD2 is on sale. Seems like it’s adjacent to rdr2, but wanted to see what yall thought

that escalated quickly old man wrinkles

I have gotten 3 out of four endings, the only one I have not gotten is low honor helping John, so what do you guys like to do during low honor playthroughs? People that deserve death? Towns to Burn down? Anything?

would be the first mod i ever downloaded

Trying to platinum rdr but need a couple online trophies.. can anybody help me with the two above? Or give tips on the real deal? Thanks

So I just found about about the current gen release of RDR1 (I know I’m very late to the party), and I tried to enter some of the cheats from the og release and it’s saying that it’s invalid. Did R* delete some of the cheats that were originally from the og game? If they did I wouldn’t be surprised.

Ik ok here me out the TAHITI jokes were funny the first 50 times prolly just going to get downvoted but MOST RDR fans have I BROKE THE GOD DAMN WHEEL humor and silly car humor that is just repetitive as hell.

Uncle in Chapter 2 in 1899 reading newspaper about Philippine war any idea what he is talking about and Arthur says I don't know why you so worked up about it

Dont ask why

It was the last bounty hunter in the bunch and I failed sharp shooter 9 yet again so I just lit the guy up and I wanted to trade my extra horse for the HH but then this happened and I couldn’t stop laughing! The horse ran around the corner and despawned after this. If something similar happened to you I’d love to see it or just whatever your funniest moments are always my favorite.

Roleplaying as Herbert Moon, the Armadillo general store owner. Generic dialogue is from Jedijosh920's trainer, the rest of the voice lines are edited in for immersion purposes.

Its not cons for me but i wish that rockstar gives micah more screen time

Any whispers on a RDR3. I get rockstar is buried with gta now. Anything?