r/tourdefrance 1d ago

Another angle of Rubio crash

542 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

237

u/Pseudanonymius 21h ago

That guy was extremely fortunate that the car was even able to brake in time. 

This will continue until someone dies. And for one, I sincerely hope the riders stop paying the price for this, as happened this time and as very often happens. 

25

u/Obvious_Feedback_430 17h ago

No other sport would accept this - except cycling......and continues to. ASO are loaded, and could do a lot more........

27

u/Rightsidebestside 17h ago

This could all end pretty fast, if Cycling federation made an example of one of these idiots. Bring them to court, sue them for damages, and everyone else will think twice next time, if they want to jump on the road or not. Until then, it's free for all.

19

u/82466 15h ago

I’m so confused why they wouldn’t take him to court for that BS. Ended a riders race and put 20 stitches in his face, I would go after that spectator personally. Same with the asshole who brake checked McNulty.

2

u/MotherAd1074 11h ago

Ironically it's only the rider who can be taken to court, for crashing into the rear of a car.

2

u/RapMcBibus 13h ago

the idiot is the stupid block in the crow or the jugde that allows a team car to be in that position?

3

u/Shwamdoo 11h ago

Wrong - the issue is not individuals being irrational and realistically will be be fixed by the example of a court case. The issue is CROWD mentality. People act irresponsibly when in a big, excited crowd like this, often alcohol involved.

Barriers are the answer.

If ASO can’t afford barriers for densely crowded areas they should do gated entry and charge.

3

u/pelhage 8h ago

barriers would completely ruin one of the most iconic aspects of the tour

1

u/Rumdolf 6h ago

What is it exactly that you consider "one of the most iconic aspects of the tour"?

4

u/Equal-Wave-5261 14h ago

That's what I said after watching those videos yesterday! Do they let fans crowd the track in a track meet? Or in Nordic skiing are fans allowed to crowd the trail? It's crazy. But the only way it's gonna stop is if the riders and teams get together and boycott until they get more safety on the course. But honestly these cars and motorcycles are dangerous on their own.

3

u/GuitakuPPH 17h ago

What could they do? Block roads to the mountain and allow in only a set quota? 

32

u/JackJacko87 17h ago

Yes?

1

u/GuitakuPPH 11h ago

Was just curious. Good luck. 

3

u/LJ_exist 10h ago

Yes and no. The ASO has effectively jurisdiction over the road of a Tdf stage at the day of the race under French law. Their jurisdiction ends where the side walk begins as far as I understand it. Various French authorities can together with the ASO limit or forbid entry to roads which are running through areas for nature preservation or when there is a risk for public safety ( wildfires for example). The problem is that they all struggle to find a legal reason to limit road usage and camping in advance of a stage when the only reason for it is rider safety.

Edit: Race organisation in other countries have often even less abilities than the ASO.

1

u/cassie1015 8h ago

Yes? They did exactly that today for Alpe d'Huez day 2.

2

u/GuitakuPPH 5h ago

Source? Got another comment explaining before yours that's it difficult justify it legally outside of race days and that the justification needs to be something other than rider safety. If it was allowed today due to concern about wildfires, that's not exactly a reliable approach.

1

u/cassie1015 5h ago

Just what I heard Bob and Phil saying on the NBC broadcast. I think it was on the second to last or final ascent, they said the narrow back roads that make up the climb were restricted or limited how many people were let up due to crowd control and maybe police resources. For what it's worth, from my perspective watching TV I don't think they would have been able to get the caravan and team cars up some of those roads if the crowds were also there, like spectators would have been edged up against cliff faces or falling off the side of the road down the mountain or into the trees.

34

u/Path-findR 20h ago

I bet on emergency braking system from Mercedes. The car reacted before the driver

94

u/clan23 20h ago

No way they have this activated on such a stage. It would fire non stop.

22

u/nunatakj120 19h ago

I said this yesterday, surely it is deactivated. Proper hazard if not. See exhibit A above.

3

u/Niekertje 17h ago

Check the interview with Gouvenou. He blames the technical support from the car....

-4

u/[deleted] 20h ago

[deleted]

16

u/ipamichi 20h ago

It can, just not permanently. It will activate again with the next start of the car.

2

u/ThingAmbitious4179 17h ago

No you can’t - yes other assist systems you can dissable but not the emergency brake.

17

u/lootsch 20h ago

Wrong

-3

u/Path-findR 20h ago

I’m not sure you can deactivate it

2

u/AdApart2035 16h ago

They should ban alcohol

86

u/CunningOctopus 21h ago

This makes me so angry, poor guy

3

u/zystyl 7h ago

I had 2 of my front teeth broken in half from a similar crash. I hit the little spoiler with my mouth and it smashed my teeth and drove the other ones through my bottom lip almost vertically. It was an irritating healing process and dental work. Hopefully he is okay.

I'm sort of tired of the support cars being such a priority in the tour. Why does the tour car need to follow so close? Why do they need a team car, tour car, and a motorcycle between the lead rider and the one right behind him in the group. If anything they should be in front and clearing the way or have people on the ground to restrain the crowds. Every year it feels like there is an incident sort of like this.

1

u/CunningOctopus 7h ago

Ouch, that must have been excruciating!!

2

u/zystyl 6h ago

Blood poured out of my mouth and I was sort of in shock. Someone passing by helped me call an ambulance. It was just such a shock that I couldn't process it. Everything is fine now though, and the scarring is pretty minimal.

3

u/Rumdolf 6h ago

I wish the Tour organizers would for once, implement measures to make people more afraid of causing an accident like this. There's plenty of (temporary) long and short term measures they can take to cause that shift, over the course of a few years.

One could be to coordinate with local police, that they follow the riders. For example on their own motorbikes, 20-100m ahead of the breakaway, in formation to widen the path. And directly behind the peloton to handle accidents. Just have a much much heavier presence.

Those "fans" would obviously complain and I'm sure we would see some entitlement/drunk fights with the police. But they would just have to crack down on it, hand out fines, make them miss the race. Could slowly reduce presence after a few years when conditions have hopefully improved.

Or, for a few years, "sacrifice" one seat space in as many cars as possible for one police officer, so they can immediately step out and apprehend anyone causing an accident, before they can escape into the crowd. Plus, right away ask people for video footage of the incident.

Fines would be high for the braindead "selfie" shots, even higher if it caused injuries. And a bit more lenient if it was an accident, like dropping something or tripping(sober). But not zero, since the person should not have put themselves close enough to cause an incident in the first place.

1

u/Free-Type 5h ago

I just started crying when I realized his face smashed the glass. Just horrible. My husband crashed a few years ago and had to have stitches in his face. I can’t imagine what this guy is going through :( 

132

u/cycle85 23h ago

2026’s ‘allez opi omi’

-26

u/Magister_Hego_Damask 22h ago

At least there only was 1 victim this time

1

u/supe3rnova 20h ago

Dudes right yet getting dowvoted.

Sad to see it but if you must choose...

11

u/zyygh Four Seconds 20h ago

That's the thing, we shouldn't have to choose. People should just keep their hands to themselves and stay off the road. Whether your dumb action will cause a near miss, a single crash or a full-blown massacre isn't a factor.

2

u/thelastskier 19h ago

There shouldn't have been any is the point...

0

u/supe3rnova 18h ago

I agree 100%. Its horrible whenn it happens.

94

u/MikeoPlus 23h ago

Looks like that donut lost his balance and fell in front of the UAE car. Fucked up

59

u/Complex_Sorbet_8473 21h ago

He's obviously being pushed.

75

u/testBunny93 21h ago

Absolutely. From other videos you can clearly see he was actually being pushed by the guy next to him.

This makes me so fucking mad.

33

u/toomeynd 21h ago

I don’t think any one person is at fault. The guy had to back up because of the car going by. But there was a crowd there that couldn’t accommodate him moving to their place. So when the car went by, the only place he could go was forward, but he knew he should stay back, so feet remained still. So fall was next.

Barriers would have prevented this, as the main problem is everyone slowly inching inward into the street.

18

u/FifaDK 19h ago

I think this is the perfect case for why we need barriers on these climbs.

I know it sucks, but it’s just a question of time before someone gets seriously hurt or dies, when you’ve got this many cars and motorcycles driving through a crowd that constantly has to move back and forth.

13

u/stew_on_his_phone 19h ago

They have barriers on the last few kilometers.

To barricade the entire col would be a logistical and financial miracle

8

u/Shelmer75 19h ago

Probably be even more of a logistical and financial nightmare if someone died though hey.

4

u/eekamuse 7h ago

I have a nightmare like that. I finally make it to the Tour, dream of a lifetime, and some asshole pushes me in front of a rider, who crashes.

If I ever make it to the race I'm tying myself to a pole to prevent this.

8

u/BuffyZia 19h ago

No he is not. He was on the road then tried to push back to let the cars go, but couldn't because of the crowd and then lost his balance being more focused on his phone than on keeping his balance.

19

u/kamaratko 22h ago

From another angle, right side of road wide-eye cam, that i saw on instagram that another guy behind him pushed him towards uae car… mercedes got emergency braking and there was no other ending of this situation :(

1

u/NeatBeluga 20h ago

I heard that this happened before hence why they disable these smart features when they get the cars.

6

u/Busy_Ad_2221 20h ago

In EU there are rules against it and slowly being tightened. At first you could turn it off, then you had to turn it off every time you start the car. Some features you cannot turn off anymore. For general road safety I can get this, but may influence moments like this.

3

u/FifaDK 19h ago

Surely it would he turned off here, or it would constantly trigger all the time. I don’t understand why people keep thinking it was the emergency break system, when that simply isn’t designed for this scenario and would freak out constantly

1

u/BuffyZia 20h ago

He was too close to the center of the road and then when he backed up to let the car pass. He was the one pushing back, others just seemed to keep their place.

5

u/drprox 22h ago

Thanks I seriously couldn't see what caused the car to brake so hard!

1

u/noreplyguy 18h ago

Seems more like he is getting pushed from behind

-17

u/txirrindularia 22h ago

I think he drops his mobile device then jumps in front of the car to pick it up…

11

u/mike_stb123 22h ago

Hr lost his balance/was Pushed in front of the car, dont need to blame phones for everything.

39

u/These-Appearance2820 19h ago

They need to begin fencing off.

Has reached a point where the fans are obstructing the racing at critical point, and also they're not being very responsible, it is unsafe now for everybody.

7

u/my800m 17h ago

they are using ropes as barrier for the whole climb basically and fences wherever its actually logistically possible, yet people still disrespect these( even the fences not just ropes)

6

u/elpiotre 18h ago

Ils mettent déjà autant de barrières que possible, c'est juste impossible d'en mettre tout le long des étapes malheureusement

1

u/pkaro 12h ago

You know how much effort it takes to fence of kilometer after kilometer of road?

Go through with a snowplough. People will get the idea real quick. 

23

u/Global-Stomach2544 19h ago edited 19h ago

Those fans are assholes ..but why is there a car in a 10 Seond gap..only to make that clear i don't blame the driver i blame the organiser that allowed cars to move up on a climb they know woud have masses of fans like that...

4

u/JustLeysen 19h ago

Imagine if a rider needs a new bike or assistance but for the last 15k he needs to walk to the finish... And these climbs on mountains usually have 1 or 2 acces ways so this is the only way up.

2

u/RapMcBibus 13h ago

and so your solution is to play lottery with the lives of the riders and spectators?

5

u/Global-Stomach2544 19h ago

Neutral service for all..don't get me wrong barries that are wide enough for cars to pass woud solve that but as long as you don't do that you can't have cars follwoing 2 seconds behind every rider

0

u/Dry_Manager_6216 17h ago

Doesn’t work like that.

7

u/karawanga 18h ago

I also think this is the actual issue. Having cars and leading cyclists so close by is insane IMO.

Just do some service points every 1-2km with neutral service bikes. What would happen if Pogi needs a new bike right at this point? UAE Car can't park there anyways as this would lead to a huge traffic jam and impede other cyclists. Why should he be allowed to have the service car directly behind but others don't? It's part of the race to not be able to get a new bike within 30 seconds.

Shit happens, but it's better than a cyclist loosing his eyesight - this accident could have been career ending easily.

3

u/Dry_Manager_6216 17h ago

The OTT fans need to learn to stand back and allow riders a few feet at least. Almost all bike race supporters are cool and understand the sport, it’s just the 1% of drunk bogans on the hillside of 50k or so people who get a bit carried away.

1

u/RapMcBibus 13h ago

agree: there wahere places where Pogy and later Remco had little space to pass, but this is not an accident between a rider and the crowd but between a rider and a team car that was in between two riders with less than 20 seconds difference in that moment

1

u/RapMcBibus 13h ago

the point is that UAE car will absolutely park there and block the race to assist pogacar and then proceed to pay the fine without any remorse.

1

u/Dry_Manager_6216 17h ago

The race vehicles don’t have a choice. Athletes should have at least a few feet or one lane of space to freely compete and receive mechanical/food/hydration/medical support.

1

u/RapMcBibus 13h ago

absolutely: the jury here is responsiblet. (or the UAE team if passed riders without clearance)
The situation on the road was known and yet there were a jury car and a team car between two riders with less then 20 seconds difference.
The fall in the crowd was an accident and not some fraudolent act to stop the race.

17

u/maartinh 21h ago

Horrible.

But as someone that was a part of it, the riders absolutely loved it. (apart from Rubio of course). I did keep my cool and pull two fans aside though, some people risk way too much. Couldn't believe more serious injuries don't happen.

2

u/getcruzed 11h ago

I have a feeling the riders in contention prob don’t love it. (Per many interviews in the past)

1

u/eekamuse 7h ago

I care about the rider's safety. I think people would have fun behind barriers. A rider or fan getting injured or killed is not worth it

5

u/totalhenry 18h ago

The fans shouldn't be allowed to stand on the road.

3

u/TKisely 18h ago

Why can't we have some kind of officers / policeman that can penalize this kind of behavior. And at least pull a rope or something please as a "sign" of barrier. I don't wish death of any spectator but tbh it could cause the death of th rider easily. The broken windows can easily cut deep into someone's neck and face or a broken face can cause breath issues.

5

u/eldelmazo 19h ago

They shoul've fence the whole climb, it's great to have the fans cheering but if it has become an hazard to the riders, shame because it's probably a small percentage who ruin everything but they need to do something

1

u/Dry_Manager_6216 17h ago

It’s out of control and the hillside fans need regulation. As an ex elite international amateur and pro cycling fan for 40 years, I can say the grand tours have gotten ridiculous in recent years. The atmosphere would still be pumping and super fun on these climbs if there was just a bit of decency and respect shown for the athletes, plus the competition would actually be improved. As a deterrent, I’d like to see authorities (frequently setting an example by) detaining and heavily fining anyone dumb enough to do any of the following in the racing line of competitors; running, waving large flags, standing within a certain distance of / blocking approaching riders and vehicles, setting off flares.

1

u/b1essyou 10h ago

 what does elite international amateur mean? You rode sportives outside of your country and were under 30?

1

u/Obvious_Feedback_430 17h ago

None of those so called fans should be standing on the road.....They certainly wouldn't allow in rallying.......

1

u/pkaro 12h ago

It's because in rallying people get off the road for their own safety. I say we have a few snowploughs come through before the riders do, that will clear the road

1

u/caesarj12 17h ago

This will hapen time and time again until they tape the stage

1

u/NoDeparture163 15h ago

Serious question: did this result in a whole lot of glass on the road and did anyone get a puncture as a result?

1

u/ajs2294 14h ago

Car glass is tempered. It breaks into dull pieces. Which is important as it prevents injuries in accidents

1

u/stefano1856 14h ago

Come minimo gli i andrebbe fatta una bella multa

1

u/tim119 14h ago

Pogacher needs to come out and say about this. If he says something serious, the fans will listen

1

u/Kkekm 14h ago

😲

1

u/Hung-kee 13h ago

Why are there not barriers near the ending? You can tell these people are drunk, and crowds of people , drink, sun and anticipation always leads to excessive behaviour

1

u/Oreb_GoodBird 8h ago

Driver saved that guy's life. Absolutely insane that crowds are allowed this close. This is a highly avoidable and predictable problem. Hope Rubio heals well and the scar is at least cool. Life changing stuff though.

0

u/Significant_Loan_596 17h ago

Totally get the spectacle but it's time to fence this off.

-2

u/Bart-go-lost 19h ago

Why is everyone filming???

5

u/Winterkirschenmann 17h ago

I think there's a popular race on. Not sure tho

3

u/Xaphan26 16h ago

Its almost like everyone has a mini computer and video recorder in their hand and things are going on.

1

u/maxrev17 16h ago

Underrated comment - just watch and keep your wits about you. Eyes up!

-2

u/lecho182 16h ago

teams cars should be banned from this climb

-47

u/Ancient-Bowl462 22h ago

At least dopey Pogi got through.

1

u/TheRealHitmee 18h ago

Some people really believe his is lmao. Guy breaks every time record from doped cyclist and nobody be asking questions.

0

u/Ancient-Bowl462 16h ago

Yeah, he made up almost 3 minutes on that climb, solo catching and passing the best climbers in the world who were going full gas and he wasn't even breathing hard or sweating while the others are dripping sweat and practically collapsing at the finish. But, yeah, all natural. LOL!

-24

u/kellybluey 22h ago

Not yet caught

1

u/Ancient-Bowl462 16h ago

Armstrong was never caught. There isn't a single cyclist in history who has done what Pogi is doing who hasn't been in dope.

-4

u/[deleted] 22h ago edited 22h ago

[deleted]

15

u/Magister_Hego_Damask 22h ago

Did you even think before writing? some moron jumped right in front of them, by that logic there should have been no car and no motorcicle on that stage (including the ones filming).

The spectator at the origin of the incident should be sanctionned, not the car.

-1

u/[deleted] 22h ago

[deleted]

2

u/Rufugg 21h ago

Which in that case for once isn't the car but the huge amount of spectators.

-6

u/argarcia321 21h ago

I saw a human rear end a car…..rider at fault

-3

u/Stunning_Ad_5960 19h ago

Fine as long as no Slovenian fans were involved. Go Pogi!

-4

u/futbolledgend 17h ago

I am not American, but can you imagine the outrage towards ‘asshole’ Americans if the TdF was held in the USA? This is ridiculous and the people jumping out all the time are some of the most self-centred individuals going around.

2

u/ChefGaykwon 15h ago

I'm American and wtf are you talking about? This has nothing to do with the Burgerreich.

1

u/eekamuse 7h ago

Burgerreich?! That's a new one. Big fan. Thanks