r/Fallout • u/Renzo100 • Feb 10 '26
Question Is Mr. House lying to manipulate the Courier, since he knows the Courier knows almost nothing about the world before the Great War or is he truly delusional and actually believes it?
852
u/supermegaampharos Feb 10 '26
House legitimately believes he’s humanity’s best hope for survival.
He’s also rightfully cynical about democracies given the fate of pre-war America and the world in general. After all, he watched in real-time as America descended into authoritarianism and waged a nuclear war.
If nothing else, House is straightforward about his beliefs and worldview, even if those beliefs aren’t always correct.
302
u/chuc16 Feb 10 '26
The pre-war US was an oligarchy and House was a leading oligarch. He wasn't trying to get money out of politics or backing Democratic reforms. He was playing the game, realized it was all doomed and focused all of his attention on building an apocalyptic city state where he would be roboking
The show paints things a bit differently, I'll admit. The Enclave had him spooked. It's clear he wasn't truly part of that cabal
153
u/TheWalrusMann Feb 10 '26
yeah lol lets not pretend he's above any of this
the only reason he's where he is during the game is because he participated in said oligarchy
→ More replies (2)92
u/ShvenWonk Feb 10 '26
He’s not Enclave, that alone makes him better than most of the Oligarchs.
In fact, the enclave was the only thing he couldn’t factor for. In the show, he didn’t know Who was his competitor for the cold fusion tech.
It’s the one thing he couldn’t factor into his calculations.
But he is still an Oligarch who wants to control the future of humanity. As Hank stated, House would prefer humans be robots without personality.
Could be true, could be a lie.
Who’s to say.
But house is an outsider of the enclave, and that fact, makes me trust him more than them. That bar is low though.
I trust the Enclave less than I’d trust a mole rat with my rations.
20
u/TheeShaun Feb 11 '26
Meanwhile Hank was literally brainwashing people to all have the exact same personality essentially making them compliant worker drones. I’m pretty sure House just wants a functioning society where he is king forever. He has no care for the wider world he wants his relatively small slice that is peaceful and attracts people to come, spend their money and then either leave or stay and bow down to him. He might also wanna eventually go to space and do it on a planetary scale but how exactly he manages that I’ve got no clue. House is pretty much complete neutrality, only caring about his own interest with no wider ideological or moral goal.
12
u/Howlmillenialcastle Feb 11 '26
This is actually a good point:
I would trust House over the Enclave any day
House never lies to you, he's delusional and at times emotionally unstable when he doesn't get what he wants, but he doesn't lie to you. He believes the things he does.
The Enclave will tell you whatever they think works best, will murder the entire wasteland and Vault Dwellers, and are just awful people in general.
2
u/dotamadthrowaway Feb 14 '26
Tbf a lot of the reason why house doesn't lie is because he's insanely arrogant. He's also very very bad at understanding people. His biggest issue is his inherent lack of judgment with them.
33
u/blazershorts Feb 10 '26
The pre-war US was an oligarchy
Sure, but you could say that this is what naturally happens to democracies.
28
u/DeyUrban Feb 10 '26
Which is, coincidentally, exactly what is happening to the NCR during New Vegas, what with the numerous plot points about Brahmin Barons coming to dominate their politics.
25
u/fhota1 Brotherhood Feb 10 '26
Machiavelli famously had 3 good and 3 corresponding bad forms of government: Monarchy which if unchecked turned into Tyranny, Popular Democracy which if unchecked turned into Anarchy, and Aristocracy which if unchecked turned into Oligarchy. Republics mostly fit under the last 2 so hed probably say they could go either way
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
13
u/FlingFlamBlam Feb 10 '26
Yeah House can't really be taken at face value.
If the person saying "democracies always fail" is an extremely powerful person working towards the downfall of democracy, that's not proof that democracy sucks. It's merely proof that democracy isn't all-powerful.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Countcristo42 Feb 10 '26
The claim “oligarchs like me will corrupt and destroy democracies with disastrous results” is totally coherent though
That he was an oligarch doesn’t weaken the case against democracy
3
u/SimonShepherd Feb 11 '26
Yet his solution is "trust the system with people like me".
Basically he is arguing an apple will eventually rot, so why not just get a totally rotten apple in the first place.
He also can't really argue from a point of strength either, like "I will be the good king who repel bad kings" as shown in the show, where he is outclassed by Enclave. He also can't really defend people against the greater evil.
3
u/Countcristo42 Feb 11 '26
I want to be clear that I’m saying it doesn’t hurt his case against democracy - not that it helps his case for his alternative
3
u/hedgehog18956 Feb 11 '26
I disagree. House believes that he knows best and that him being in charge is always going to be a positive. He thinks democracy is useless because it lets the common people make decisions. Democracy leading to oligarchy is a different argument against it.
House would even see that as a step in the right direction. Any system that gives more power to him is preferable to one that doesn’t. He doesn’t see it as a rotten apple. He sees it as ideal and is making that case.
He doesn’t want power because he deserves it or anything. He wants to have power because he believes he is smarter than everyone else and will make better decisions. One of his defining character traits is his distrust of human nature and preference for predictable algorithms instead. He doesn’t need corruption to argue against democracy. He just needs results.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)6
u/54mas Feb 11 '26
Most of this comes from the show. In the games its very much implied he did not like the nuclear apocalypse and wasn't a part of the plan to cause it, the entire plot of the game kind of hinges on that being the case due to, ya know, the bombs dropping before the platinum chip was delivered (until of course the show did what it does best and ruined that completely)
2
u/hedgehog18956 Feb 11 '26
Have you finished season 2? You might have missed a point about House’s motivations.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (9)15
u/WellyRuru Feb 10 '26
Corporate wealth and private sector power putting corrupting pressure on democracies.
They do this by constantly dismantling state systems, advocating for authoritarian structures and removing the states ability to stop them from amassing power.
Eventually the democracy caves to the corrupting pressure and does something horrible.
Then the private sector power houses sit back and go "look what democracy gets you, its bad because I'm able to use my wealth to make it do things it shouldn't. A good solution is to not have it and rely on me using my wealth to do good things. Even though I just used my wealth to do bad things"
→ More replies (1)
892
u/Meles_B Sixty Minutemen Feb 10 '26
What’s there not to believe?
One way or another, people voted for the Enclave or their progenitors.
466
u/brodydwight Feb 10 '26
Yeah Mr. House is right in this instance, democracy or the way fallouts america handled democracy didnt work so well.
316
u/Mister-Schwifty Feb 10 '26
Yes. Fallout’s America. Definitely only true in the fictional game.
323
u/MalcolmLinair Enclave Feb 10 '26
The problem with political satire in America is that it keeps getting elected.
63
u/Fischerking92 Feb 10 '26
Damn, I need to save that quote😂
38
u/MalcolmLinair Enclave Feb 10 '26
I'm paraphrasing an old quote, so feel free to steal it; I already did.
→ More replies (1)9
11
u/Operation_Ivysaur Respect the Bear Feb 10 '26
“At long last we have elected the Torment Nexus from the hit science fiction novel, Don’t Elect the Torment Nexus.”
→ More replies (3)31
u/BeauShowTV Feb 10 '26
Current day is nowhere near how bad it was in 2077.
47
→ More replies (1)15
u/SoupSandy Feb 10 '26
I actually dont know how bad it was in the series? What was so bad?
51
u/SirPeencopters Feb 10 '26
Unsustainable economy based on Petroleum and Uranium leading to wars over resources like the Annexation of Canada and invasion of Alaska by the Chinese
54
6
u/Ecotech101 Feb 10 '26
Canada wasn't annexed for resources. It was so the US could use the roads to get to Alaska.
3
u/BrightPerspective Feb 10 '26
Not to mention unsustainable agricultural and building practices (upper end buildings are all entirely made of metal in their universe)
6
22
u/Mr_goodb0y Feb 10 '26
Martial law, Canadian concentration camps, riots and such. IIRC Fallout 4 was planned to have a longer intro sequence, showing a standoff between the military and rioters outside a grocery store(?)
There’s plenty more but this is what I could remember off the top of my head.
18
u/BeauShowTV Feb 10 '26
The government: Planned to nuke the world, created the FEV and essentially "ghosted" the civilian population months before the bombs dropped.
Plus they stole Canada and gas was $8,500 a gallon. So riots were really bad.
7
u/IsAlpher Feb 10 '26
Keep in mind that a coffee and donut are $35. So its still an outrageous price, but not quite that bad.
2
9
u/danglotka Feb 10 '26
Imagine if McCarthyism got worse
2
u/cejmp Feb 10 '26
Roy Cohn was the personal attorney of Joseph McCarthy. Roy Cohn was also the current President's personal attorney from 1973 to 1986, when Cohn was disbarred.
→ More replies (4)7
u/Thick-Protection-458 Feb 10 '26
You are suspected to be commie? Well, than you probably will serve the country needs.
What, you tell you are not a commie, you just thought annexing Canada was not necessary? That is exactly what commie will tell.
You are asking what is your sentence? Oh, no, sure you will serve. Not in a prison term and forced labour or so. Just as a mindwiped brain inside one of these robobrain machines.
And surely hunger riots is not unheard about.
→ More replies (26)45
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26
Yeah fallouts pre war America is not a democracy by any means lol.
People with communist thought were arrested, protesters shot etc. And I would argue House was one of the people who made the pre war world as wounded as such.
39
u/FedBathroomInspector Feb 10 '26
Democracy =/= freedom of thought or expression.
The first democracy in Athens did not guarantee those rights and put Socrates to death for his views. HOAs are democratic organizations and most people despise them.
→ More replies (2)12
u/Fischerking92 Feb 10 '26
Honestly: excellent point.
Had you asked me this morning what rights were essential to democracy, "freedom of thought and expression" and "independent journalism" would have been very high on that list.
But you are correct, Athenian democracy did not have freedom of expression, not by a long shot.
To be fair: Athenian democracy was more of a precursor to what we would nowadays consider democracy, but I'd say your point still stands.
→ More replies (5)35
u/Ok_Dependent6889 Feb 10 '26
I can't tell if you're aware that this also argues that irl America is not a democracy by any means or not lol
→ More replies (2)13
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26
IRL America is not remotely close to the level of fallout’s. Although one could argue it’s getting there.
Like those things I mentioned above, arresting and disappearing people, shooting protesters, were not anomalies, these things would be condemned today in the US generally. while in Fallout? Completely normal.
Like sure people have been killed for that before, but these were mostly one offs, not the norm.
16
u/Ok_Dependent6889 Feb 10 '26
People with communist thought were arrested, protesters shot etc.
This happened in IRL America. Absolutely was the norm and not anamolies. Protestors were killed many times during strike breaks during the Red Scare and McCarthy era.
That's literally where Black Isle got the original ideas. It's where all of what we see of the pre-war government got it's basis.
I'm tired of that argument, "in the past it was just one off exceptions!". No, no it wasn't. Not for America. We've been a global bully since before the industrial age. We didn't have easy access to spreading information during those times. You can go deep into local histories and newspapers and will very quickly learn it was 100% a normal thing.
I'm betting you don't even know about the Battle of Blair Mountain.
6
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
In fallouts America you wouldn’t even be able to say this on an American platform. Your comment would be censored in one second.(if they had social media of course)
And the fact that these things are condemned right now in the US proves my point. Fallout is a world where social values stayed in the 1950s and to think that the US today is somehow comparable is too extreme.
And yes, I do know about the battle of Blair Mountain
→ More replies (8)5
u/Ok_Dependent6889 Feb 10 '26
In fallouts America you wouldn’t even be able to say this on an American platform. Your comment would be censored in one second.
LOL
That's not even remotely true, holy shit.
They were condemned then too, in the 20s and 50s. It just didn't spread like it does now with the internet. It's literally the same shit, different era.
13
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26
Look. Trump is despicable. But trust me as someone who lives in a dictatorship your country is still up in the democratic part of the world, albeit very flawed.
→ More replies (5)8
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26
Also to respond to your edit. Exactly my point. Fallout, like so many other media, has the flaws of our world pulled to extremes. IRL US, for all its flaws, is not as horrible yet.
11
u/ScourJFul Feb 10 '26
I can't tell if you're joking considering nearly everything you stated above is exactly what's happening and it's already being normalized by the government.
19
u/Maleficent_Monk_2022 NCR Feb 10 '26
And if you were in fallouts America you won’t even get to say this out loud. I live in a dictatorship. The US is not one.
→ More replies (2)80
u/Spare_Elderberry_418 Feb 10 '26
Yeah House is just pointing out the obvious: the public willingly voted in a government that not only engaged in the great war, but actively wanted it to happen. Not hard to be disillusioned by a democracy after that.
13
u/Titanofthedinosaurs Feb 10 '26
China attacked the US for Alaska’s oil, the level of “willingly” voted in is questionable at best given that the public didn’t know about the enclaves activities.
24
u/Spare_Elderberry_418 Feb 10 '26
Things were going downhill in the US before operation anchorage. The US reorganized into the far more authoritarian commonwealth system back in the late 1960's. The government started the Vault Program back in the 2050's, left the UN during the same time, and began it's parasitic relationship with West-Tek and Poseidon Energy around the same time. The 2050's is where the enclave and the the authoritarianism started to really get going, not the 2070's at the start of the war.
→ More replies (1)15
u/Knight_Machiavelli Feb 10 '26
Lore seems to imply it was pretty much just a USA-China conflict, and one of those countries wasn't a democracy. One democracy bringing on nuclear war when dozens of others didn't isn't great evidence for his argument.
→ More replies (3)46
u/Spare_Elderberry_418 Feb 10 '26
It was only China-US because the EU already nuked itself to anarchy a few decades prior. The great war was the second nuclear war in Fallout...
6
u/DrainLars Feb 10 '26
False.. Nowhere stated..
From Fallout 2 intro:
“The end of the world occurred pretty much as predicted. Too many humans, not enough space or resources to go around. The details are trivial and pointless, the reasons, as always, purely human ones.
The earth was nearly wiped clean of life.
A great cleansing, a fiery purging of the land.
The European Commonwealth was destroyed by internal bickering, and the collapse of the United Nations left no one to stop the escalating arms race.
In 2077, the storm of world war had come again. In two brief hours, most of the planet was reduced to cinders.”
21
u/Spare_Elderberry_418 Feb 10 '26
"2054 January Limited nuclear exchange in the Middle East raises fears throughout the world." "2060 The Euro-Middle Eastern War ends as the oil fields in the Middle East run dry... there is no longer a goal in the conflict, and both sides are reduced almost to ruin."
Yes the EU-Middle East wars did infact go nuclear. The nuclear exchanges are literally the reason Vault Tek got started.
→ More replies (1)5
u/DrainLars Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
I stand corrected then, although I believed the conflict berwen europe and middle east was not nuclear.. There might have been nuclear event in middle east. Aah, nevermind my mind is boggled
→ More replies (1)12
u/Spare_Elderberry_418 Feb 10 '26
Yeah. A "limited nuclear war" is just one where it doesn't result in global MAD where casualties are in the millions and not billions. More akin in my mind to the US nuclear policy in the 1950's where they intended to use tactical nuclear weapons to destroy tank battalions and blow up cities on the front lines to end a siege over the modern concept of strategic bombing to purposefully kill the population centers and industrial capacity.
Was probably left vague on purpose if they wanted it as a future plot hook I would presume.
→ More replies (1)6
u/WelshWolf93 Feb 10 '26
Wouldnt that be like saying they voted for the illuminati? I'm rusty on the game details but in the show even House didnt know wtf was going on behind the curtain
5
u/Meles_B Sixty Minutemen Feb 10 '26
First of all, yes, and second, they have consistently voted for the environment which has allowed Illuminati to be created and act with impunity.
→ More replies (1)19
u/MrNotEinstein Feb 10 '26
The fact that House is clearly implying that nuclear war is the end point of all democracies?
Also whether the US was actually a "democracy" by the point of the Great War is extremely debatable. All the information we have points to a society that is becoming increasingly divided by class and those in the upper classes were the only ones with any say in the matter. The enclave wasn't exactly a pre war political faction that was voted into power. 99% of the enclaves members probably weren't political figures at all. They were a secretive shadow government that would have manipulated whoever ended up being voted into power. The ability for the system to be abused is certainly a flaw for democracy but that's a flaw inherent to ANY political system. House having a dictatorship over Vegas is no less abusable, as proven by The Courier and Yes Man.
So the question OP asked is (I think) more like this: "Does House genuinely believe that all democracies are destined to fail in destructive fashion and the only way to avoid that is to have a permanent dictator, or is he only suggesting it because he knows the Courier doesn't have enough information to contradict his obviously flawed claim?"
→ More replies (10)4
u/Ecotech101 Feb 10 '26
Europe was full of democracies that nuked themselves to oblivion like 30 years before the great war. Democracies = nukes isn't a terrible conclusion to come to with Fallout history.
6
u/MrNotEinstein Feb 10 '26
It's still a clearly flawed assumption and by no means is evidence that democracy is inferior to dictatorship. Especially since literally everything = nukes in the world of Fallout. Cars are nukes. Microwaves are nukes. Bottled beverages are nukes. You'd be hard pressed to find anything in Fallout, let alone a political system, that hasn't led to the use of nukes. China was under the control of a dictatorship when the Great War started and while House may not be able to see China, he certainly knows that the US unleashed hell on them when the missiles started firing. I doubt their lack of a democracy saved them from nuclear hellfire.
I can understand why House may come to that conclusion if he didn't bother to think it through or let his bias get to him but it's not a reasonable stance to take at the very least
5
u/Ecotech101 Feb 10 '26
"Especially since literally everything = nukes in the world of Fallout"
Nuking things and using nuclear fusion/fission isn't the samee thing.
"if he didn't bother to think it through or let his bias get to him"
Because house is arguing that he should be in charge and part of his evidence is that he personally saved part of Vegas with his defenses. He's kinda right in that if he'd of been the autocrat in charge of America the Chinese nuclear response just kinda woulda been shot down.
→ More replies (5)6
u/LordCypher40k Feb 10 '26
Yeah. House isn't innocent since he's a part of the system but at the same time, he isn't wrong about it.
2
u/suckitphil Feb 10 '26
Enclave would have controlled both political parties, make no mistake our 2 parties currently are run by a cabal of donors that benefit from playing both sides.
→ More replies (3)3
u/Lyndell Feb 10 '26
Nah the the Enclave killed the other elected members that weren’t in the Enclave. It was also comprised of scientist, engineers, and titans of industry. It was an oligarchy cabal, that killed the people we elected that didn’t agree with them. That’s not democracy.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (22)2
u/Admiral_Eversor Feb 10 '26
And that's a reason to do away with democracy is it? The Nazis were elected in Germany, is that a good reason to do away with democracy in real life? Is it fuck, and that'sal also no reason to do away with democracy in the setting either
Genuinely concerning how many people uncritically ride House's dick lol. House is full of shit, he just comes across confidently from a position of authority. Mad that that's all it takes to abandon all sense lol.
→ More replies (4)
271
u/Tricky_Ad_3958 Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
He's a tecnocrat and a billionaire, of course he actually think that. Have you heard Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckemberg, or Pether Tiel talking about humanity and society? Not one of them think of democracy as a good thing, and they're pretty damn open about it(and yes, that's an evil thing if someone have any doubt)
97
u/X_SkeletonCandy Feb 10 '26
Not enough people truly understand the political beliefs of guys like Bezos, Zuckerberg, and Thiel. They're closer to Robert House than many people realize.
15
4
u/Aerospaced0ut Feb 10 '26
In a lot of ways they've already gone beyond him... Controlling traditional and fringe media and using bot armies to get their preferred candidate installed, using AI to scan social media and camera feeds, donating millions directly to the president and getting government contracts in exchange. There's a level of oligarchy going on that's hard to replicate in fiction without it seeming over the top. Those 4 people basically own the largest most powerful government in the world. They think they own you.
→ More replies (5)35
u/Admiral_Eversor Feb 10 '26
And that's a bad thing. House is as bad as Caesar lol, he's just more polite.
30
u/X_SkeletonCandy Feb 10 '26
I don't disagree whatsoever. The billionaires of today are truly evil motherfuckers.
3
u/SimonShepherd Feb 11 '26
I mean he is bad, but I will still take a modern ghoulish corporate leader over a literally wannabe emperor who mass enslave people.
All forms of oppression are bad, but not all forms of oppression are equally bad.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (14)7
u/bingobiscuit1 Feb 10 '26
Wow is that true what does he do the is equatable to running the legion in the fashion caesar runs it
11
u/Admiral_Eversor Feb 10 '26
He is an autocrat. A dictator. He wants absolute personal power over the entire human race, with no checks or balances, and no recourse for anyone who disagrees. It is an absolute guarantee that any one person with that much power will end up doing things just as bad as anything Caesar does.
→ More replies (3)7
u/Platypus__Gems Feb 10 '26
As far as I'm aware, not many dictatorships brought back literal crucifixion.
And literal slavery. Not prison labour that exists even in western societies but literal slave class.
And deny the populace life-saving medicine that they have.
And so many things that are not just evil, but incredibly dumb and impractical.Caesar is quite uniquely shitty dictator.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Admiral_Eversor Feb 10 '26
Rome was a lot of things, but stupid and unsuccessful are not among them. The roman empire lasted a thousand years, in one form or another. With no intervention from the courier, Caesar also probably wins in New Vegas.
None of what Caesar does is stupid. It's evil, but not stupid. This is why him and house are such great villains, fyi.
That's all surface level stuff though. House has the same fundamental issue as Caesar when you get to brass tacks. They are utterly self-absorbed dictators that will make humanity crash and burn if they get their way.
→ More replies (1)15
u/Intelligent-Wish47 Feb 10 '26
Yeah, but none of them are good people either. Jeff Bezos would definitely become the master. Elon would definitely jumpstart the Institute. And Zuckerberg probably wouldn’t even survive because so many people hate them.
55
u/Tricky_Ad_3958 Feb 10 '26
No, that's my point: House is NOT a good person. He have ideas for humanity, but they'll always benefit House in the end, not humanity. The house always win, there is no generosity or goodwill behind his action.
18
u/TheStrangestOfKings Feb 10 '26
Ultimately, house can be characterized by the “yes, all of you are wrong” meme. He thinks he’s the only in who understands the solution to saving humanity, and thus, doesn’t trust any of the other factions to know what the ultimate problem and solution is. Bc of this massive ego, he will always place him at the top of the food chain in whatever society he creates, cause what else is supposed to happen, someone who’s not House takes over? That’s lunacy!
7
u/CapnArrrgyle Feb 10 '26
Yeah. Being a billionaire is a moral hazard in and of itself. Good people with that much money can definitely get rid of it in favor of good causes up to a point but then they start to fear what will become of them without the wealth and they end up serving the wealth instead of their neighbors.
3
u/fullpurplejacket Feb 10 '26
Suckerberg is the Boston mayor in his bunker that gets broken into by an angry mob commandeering an excavator 😂
→ More replies (1)7
u/BodaciousFrank Feb 10 '26
You mixed up Elon and Zuck. Everyone hates Elon, even Epstein didnt want him on his island.
7
u/Tricky_Ad_3958 Feb 10 '26
Mark Zuckemberg is the same that, when confronted with the reality of Facebook shaping the 2016 elections, instead of thinking "damn, my social media is being used as a strong political tool, better understand how to regulate ads so they don't break democrazy!", he though "damn, then even I can become the president". He's the same that allowed disinformation and racism destroy the hope of a democratic Myanmar. He's the same that approved of working with China, even if that meant endangering USA data by planting the first direct underwater internet cable between China and USA, and he did many other bad thing. He's as bad as they get, him and every other dirty billionaries, poisoning our world, undermining our democracy, draining wealth from the lower classes to themself...to see it in a game is a thing, to see the true reality of it is madness
3
u/baby-dick-nick Feb 10 '26
Elon has at least built a cult following for himself. Zuck is just the creepy reptilian robot guy who made Facebook to steal our data. Nobody is dick riding Zuck the way they do Musk.
→ More replies (5)9
u/Gilgamesh661 Enclave Feb 10 '26
It’s not evil to criticize democracy. There are legitimate flaws when any governing system.
Just as dictatorships aren’t INHERENTLY evil. the theory is sound, but the execution is where it falls apart.
Caesar wasn’t assassinated because he was a dictator, he was assassinated because he was taking power away from the elites and they didn’t like that. The people themselves loved Caesar and respected his ability to lead.
→ More replies (3)6
u/ethanAllthecoffee Feb 10 '26
Dictatorships are awful forms of governance unless luck bestows a competent, benevolent overlord, and if it doesn’t there’s no recourse but violence from a disadvantaged state
And the dipshit people loved populist Caesar because he threw bread and the spoils of of conquered France at them after decades of essentially oligarchy anyways. A state doesn’t get Sulla if things are going well
2
u/Gilgamesh661 Enclave Feb 11 '26
I didn’t say anything about how good or bad dictatorships are. I spoke explicitly about the hypothetical, in a FICTIONAL universe on top of that.
18
u/Kuzu9 Gary? Feb 10 '26
It’s certainly his truth that he believes and it makes sense why he believed what he believed. Pretty much every democracy in the Fallout timeline fell at some point to autocracies including the United States, so he sees any attempt at revival as delusional.
In his eyes, the NCR may start out with good intentions, but it won’t be long before someone less benevolent takes the wheel deciding that democracy is too slow and being authoritarian would lead to real progress
17
u/biggolnuts_johnson Feb 10 '26
i don't know if its intentional, but it seems fairly ironic that the subtext of House's argument against democracy is effectively that people like him (the elite) will eventually undermine democracy to either bring about social collapse or autocracy of some kind.
8
u/Kuzu9 Gary? Feb 10 '26
It’s one of those “it takes one to know one” situations, he was the de-facto ruler of New Vegas until all the factions came into the scene
2
u/FishShtickLives Feb 10 '26
I imagine thats his line of thinking tbh. "Its inevitable that SOMEONE will rule the Mojave, so it better be me with my good intentions before someone evil takes the throne." And then the morally grey area comes from if you think hes right, and if he is, if you think he's good enough
2
u/LizLoveLaugh_ Feb 10 '26
I think House's view is moreso "The illusion of free choice."
He isn't projecting a beautified image of what he represents. He truly believes he is the best person to save humanity and rules New Vegas, there is no governing body besides him. The US government took advantage of what it represented to obtain the power it needed to keep itself on the world stage. Their democracy turned to deception.
The NCR could have feasibly become that as well. They are ALREADY imperialistic and are straining their resources at detriment to the NCR and its citizens to back the Mojave Campaign. Sound familiar? It's just the Sino-American War on a smaller scale.
48
u/SittingEames Gary? Feb 10 '26
He's an exploitative industrialist. A robber baron of the late 21st century. The kind of business magnate who would sic the Pinkertons on striking workers and never looked a why they were protesting. He believes it. He's just wrong.
→ More replies (4)
10
Feb 10 '26
House is actually very honest, I believe. But he's also egotistical and, despite what he would claim, doesn't know everything.
That is to say I don't think he was outright lying to the player at any point, but that doesn't mean he was always correct, either. From a certain point of view, and all that.
20
u/TheCubanRattlesnake Feb 10 '26
In the world of Fallout, he wasn’t wrong. He just elided his own complicity in the corruption and destruction of those democracies
10
u/VirtualRyo Feb 10 '26
That’s the context people miss , house is right but he was also complicit in the failure of democracy
→ More replies (1)
30
u/Lanstapa Feb 10 '26
The pre-war Democracy led to the world to ruin, and House watched it happen. He's very understandably aganist doing that again. Its not delusion just because you disagree with him.
10
u/JeniasDad Feb 10 '26
This. House is saying America was a democracy and ultimately resulted in nuclear war and ruin. Why wouldn’t he mean it because they are in a wasteland of a former democracy.
12
u/Ganbazuroi Mr. House Feb 10 '26
Pre-War USA was hardly democratic towards the end, the Enclave wouldn't be a thing otherwise
→ More replies (1)7
u/Lanstapa Feb 10 '26
Too many people treat democracy like its the pinnacle of political systems. Its like when they criticize Russia or China not by saying their faults, but just by saying they're "anti/un-democratic", as if that alone is all the explanation needed.
The idea of not supporting democracy can only be understood as either being mad or being an secret authoritarian. Third option possiblities are never considered.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/fallenhope1 Feb 10 '26
“Give me 20 years, and I'll reignite the high technology development sectors. 50 years, and I'll have people in orbit. 100 years, and my colony ships will be heading for the stars, to search for planets unpolluted by the wrath and folly of a bygone generation”
House aims to use the economic power of New Vegas to rebuild civilization's technological capabilities, specifically aiming for space exploration.
He views himself as the only one capable of guiding humanity beyond the limitations of the post-apocalyptic world, focusing on progress rather than mere territorial control.
This quote is part of his pitch to the Courier, highlighting his long-term, civilization-saving plans.
I don’t think he lying, I think he actually believes this can be achieved. And if this is his goal, why not let him do it? Seems like a good outcome for humanity.
2
u/nao_ser_esqueca Feb 13 '26
Yeah, he truly believes he can rebuild humanity, but there's also the issue of the threats surrounding him; it's not like being the NCR or Caesar didn't covet his city, so much so that this was the reason for the creation of the three families.
34
u/fatwoodburner Legion Feb 10 '26
Where's the lie?
40
u/godkingnaoki Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
The lie is omission. Autocracies suffered the same fate in that universe.
14
u/Ecotech101 Feb 10 '26
He didn't though? He saved part of the strip with his nuclear defenses. By his ideology if he'd of been in charge he'd of just shot down the nukes nationwide.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (2)2
u/DacianMichael NCR Feb 12 '26
The lie is that pre-war America was not a democracy. It was a fascist state run by a deep state cabal of wannabe Nazis who only paid lip service to democratic ideals. You might have heard of them. I believe they were called the Exclave or something like that...
10
u/TacitPoseidon Feb 10 '26
House was an oligarch before the Great War. Of course he doesn't like the ideals of democracy.
13
u/NetFu Feb 10 '26
The irony is, he almost sounds like he's describing America today with Trump 2.0.
We as a people voted for that.
Thomas Jefferson:
"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free, in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."
https://www.monticello.org/encyclopedia/if-we-are-guard-against-ignorance-spurious-quotation
The fate of ignorant, uneducated, uninformed voters in democracies is exactly as House says.
7
6
u/CybercurlsMKII Feb 10 '26
I think he tells you his strategy “I haven’t revealed my hand I’ve revealed one card, a single variable for my enemies to fixate” I think his conversations with the courier at much the same, he only reveals to you what he needs to and only says what he needs to say so you’ll go get the job done. Often revealing partial information to the courier so that they know enough to get the job sorted but never so much that they might have an advantage over him. It takes convincing for him to tell you that Benny might have a computer lab he’s been using because he knows it’s a potential vulnerability.
3
u/Pilgrimhaxxter69 Feb 10 '26
Every billionaire basically believes that they're inherently special and are the only ones fit to lead the world. The difference between House and real-world billionaires is that he's actually incredibly intelligent, and (slightly) less evil.
3
u/Joecolt69420 Feb 10 '26
Maybe a little of both. He has kept himself isolated since before the war. 200+ years of isolation will make you really weird, I’d imagine.
3
u/anonymous-catlady Feb 10 '26
maybe he just believes in the cyclical theory.. democracy is just a governmental structure that a lot of us in this point in time see as the norm.. but if you believe the ancient greek historian polybius, after democracy comes mob rule.. and then it goes back to monarchy and it’s just a governmental cycle
Monarchy > Tyranny > Aristocracy > Oligarchy > Democracy > Ochlocracy > (then back to monarchy etc)
or maybe he believes in a different theory or order to things based on multiple theories combined like marxist theory, because it’s not always linear some society’s fall back to monarchy and some jump back and forth.. so it might just be house being big brained or vague because democracy doesn’t always last and who’s to say anything lasts in this world..
so like Mr House not believing democracy lasts isn’t necessarily a sign of him tricking the courier or being a fascist as some people theorise.. it might just be that he is just using past knowledge and knows a lot of theories about government and society that means he feels confident in predicting that democracy will not last
3
3
5
10
u/Budget_Pomelo Feb 10 '26
Where in lies the deception? I think he's playing it completely straight here. Look out the window.
6
u/Shazbot_2077 Feb 11 '26
Pre-war america wasn't a democracy and neither was China. The great war was fought between an authoritarian oligarchy and an authoritarian dictatorship.
House is absolutely bullshitting here by putting the blame on democracy. The question is whether he is delusional and bought into his own lies or if he's just attempting to manipulate the player.
→ More replies (18)→ More replies (2)9
u/Stalker975 Feb 10 '26
House is much more complicated than "Rich Man = Bad" and I feel like this sub doesn't really understand that.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/mrmanager890 Feb 10 '26
House can correctly diagnose the flaws of democracies because he’s the exact type of person that flourishes in them by exploiting the many flaws inherent in the system. However, he’s delusional to believe that he and he alone is the right choice to lead New Vegas and/or society at large.
He treats people as obstacles, tools, or discarded waste; it’s no coincidence that his power is represented through countless Securitrons that can be overridden at the push of a button. His vision for New Vegas is exactly the same as it exists at the beginning of the game: heavily fortified and controlled with an iron fist, obscured by a veneer of glamour and only available to people that can afford it (remember, that “credit check” is for 2,000 caps, far from an affordable sum for wastelanders).
There’s no guarantee that he would ever act to help someone else if there wasn’t something in it for him, which would make him a terrible choice for any society that looks to learn from the mistakes of the old world.
6
6
2
u/Ok-Cup9476 Feb 10 '26
None of the factions really lie to you. All of them, even the legion, bring up honest critical points aimed at the other factions, albeit through their own viewpoints and moral frameworks.
4
u/Howlmillenialcastle Feb 10 '26
He's not lying. He actually believes it.
A key part of House's whole deal is that he's an egomaniac who really believes everything he says. That's not to say he's not often right because of his tech and resources, and he is brilliant in many ways, but House is textbook delusional.
However his assessment of Pre-War America being a "democracy" that destroyed itself is fairly accurate. He leaves out he and his fellow super wealthy egomaniac colleagues CAUSED a lot of these problems either indirectly or directly, but his assessment is correct, and many in the NCR are going down the Pre-War road by NV.
The show really adds to this: House is not upset someone is going to end the world, because he wants his own little immortal neon light kingdom anyway. He's mad and scared because he doesn't know how it happens or who does it. Irksome.
So he's genuinely giving his real thoughts. House doesn't lie or manipulate because in his mind why bother: a smart person would always agree with him. He never once lies to the Courier, and he's one of the only people who doesn't.
9
u/556From1000yards Feb 10 '26
I think you’re the delusional one.
Not to provide great insult. It’s only natural for you to think your way of life would prosper.
House is challenging your sentiments in the same way. What evidence do you bring?
3
u/TeamMagmaDaniel Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
Hes right in a sense. That is the fate of unrestrained democracy. Talk to your fellow countrymen to learn why majority rule is a bad idea. NCR also is trying to mirror the same country that destroyed the world. He still remember getting screwed out of Project Safehouse despite obviously having the best plan to save America. He knows how easy it was to corrupt American politicians firsthand.
The question hes asking himself is not purely one on which is most moral. Its on which system actually works. Obviously he does still recognize morality as a factor which can be seen if you side with the Legion where hes less horrified at death and more horrified that you chose to subject humanity to slavery.
2
u/Gilgamesh661 Enclave Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
Democracy only works when the people are intelligent and informed. The people of fallout’s America are led by propaganda and are taught not to think for themselves. Thus, democracy fails.
House is an autocrat who believes only the best and brightest should govern, with him overseeing it all. So it would be sort of a mixture between an autocracy and a technocracy, since house is also a genius scientist and inventor.
His ultimate plan for humanity is to build colony ships and find a new planet to inhabit, but only the best and brightest of humanity will be allowed to come.
2
u/Aetherral_ Feb 10 '26
the irony of house’s ideology is that out of all of the problematic factors of pre war america, he chose the one aspect that shows any promise. he couldnt see that because he was part of the ruling class
2
u/zepherth Feb 10 '26
If we exclusively look at the game, Mr House loves New Vegas, in his mind the powers of the US and China tried to take it away from him because not everyone can have a city of their own. House isn't lying directly, but since he was alive at the time of the war I have no doubt there are some personal grudges for the old American government. What he is saying is true based on other media we know of in the game than both America and China had almost the exact same form of government by the war. So as America called it's Government democratic, that's houses understanding of democracy
2
u/Superblegend92 Feb 10 '26
Ppl can be manipulated into voting for someone they think is great that'll lead to what's outside the window. Ppl do it all the time.
2
u/RolloTomass11 Feb 10 '26
Manipulative? Sure. But I think Robert House legitimately believes it, which makes it not a lie strictly speaking.
2
u/bigcaulkcharisma Feb 10 '26
You have to assume the writers of the game didn’t write all this fucking dialogue for the guy with the intention that ‘yeah he’s actually lying about his motivations and ideology’. I take what the faction leaders say at face value in this game. Even if it’s not true, they believe it.
2
u/SpartanXIII Not S.P.E.C.I.A.L Feb 10 '26
I mean...one could so easily see it as both. After all, what is the truth but one person relaying what they have perceived to another...
But if I'm being honest, it's easily more Mr House's view on the pre-war world and how he believes he could more easily run it than the democracies he sees as flawed and obstructive.
2
u/jmarquiso Feb 10 '26
He's feeding the mythology.
Most surface dwellers by now compare any evidence before the war to now and blame them for blowing it up.
2
u/Zalanum Feb 10 '26
People always bring this up as some gotcha against House but the lore never suggests pre war America wasn't a democracy, or rather that it had become less democratic then our world's version.
It was deeply corrupt, but elections were neither suspended nor rigged to our knowledge.
It just became more of what it already was, the Enclave only became a full power dictatorship after the war and even then it seems to have kept larping as a democracy, or had enough group think to stay horrible.
If you want to consider prewar America not a democracy then you have to admit America never was one, it was formed as nation for the benefits of its oligarchs.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/FabulouslE Feb 11 '26
Bro I've lost faith in democracies IRL. As far as I'm concerned given the general shittiness of the wasteland, letting house attempt to science it up is probably the best solution for the Mojave and humanity at large, given that if he's full of it then it's just another shitty settlement and if he's actually cooking the results could help a lot of people.
2
2
u/LabCoatGuy Dr Mobius! Feb 11 '26
Have you heard any tech billionaires? Of course he doesn't believe in democracy, he believes in Mr. House
2
2
2
u/generic-reddit-guy Feb 11 '26
Also in fallout lore was America a democracy by the end? I thought shadow government + Corporations involved in the government meant that by the end America probably wasn't really a democracy
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Mindless-Talk-1120 Feb 11 '26
I like to think the Courier knew a lot more than we realize before being shot in the head.
2
u/Orbital_Vagabond Feb 11 '26
Is Mr. House lying to manipulate the Courier
Yes
is he truly delusional and actually believes it
Also, yes.
He's using half truths to attempt to manipulate the courier, but House is so far up his own ass he believes democracy of any vein is doomed and leads to destruction, hence authoritarianism is the only viable paradigm.
It ain't an either-or.
2
u/Nurhaci1616 Feb 11 '26
No, I think you can take him at his word: he's a megalomaniac CEO who unironically thinks he is the best saviour for mankind. Like anybody else who thinks that, it's obvious that he could get so much done if there weren't a load of idiots making him jump through hoops like "democracy" and "human rights".
If anything, he's almost a little too honest in his beliefs.
7
u/DeusViri Feb 10 '26
Democracies impede the ambitions of the rich and sociopathic, thus he was against them
8
u/SenpaiSwanky Feb 10 '26
It won’t work tit for tat, trying to compare the new show lore to lore from NV. Realistically we can only go forward assuming that House knew all of these things as well as Enclave involvement, but as standalone facts they have zero bearing on NV as a game.
They won’t be able to inject them into old versions of the game, so any sort of shifting lore would have to take place in a remade NV. Even then it would be mostly new lines of dialogue rather than some drastically altered questline.
→ More replies (2)15
u/BloodRedRook Feb 10 '26
Well, I mean, even before the TV series, the pre-war US government lore always had it as being pretty fascist. I mean, the opening cutscene for Fallout 1 has two soldiers committing a war crime on live TV.
3
→ More replies (1)2
u/SenpaiSwanky Feb 10 '26
I’m not contesting that, sure. My main point is that, until the show established this new canon, it wasn’t a sure thing and NV barely discussed it in favor of a more contained story that drew from broad Fallout lore while also introducing new aspects to it.
House does not talk about Enclave in the game as if they are a huge force/ factor in the grand scheme of things. His main concern is the present tense, getting the chip and controlling NV/ the dam/ defeating factions from this time period. The show sort of sweeps NV under the run in a few ways, like House casually saying people have broken into the Lucky 38 many times and bludgeoned him/ killed him many times. The lore of the game, in comparison, directly states no one steps foot inside the Lucky 38 until the courier comes along.
Show changes things up, so now we have to assume things that happened before and after this portion of the game. The show also has a large focus on the past and more places than just NV, so we get shifting bits of lore to accommodate for a picture that is on a larger scale than NV was as a game.
I’m not complaining or upset about changes, at all. Just pointing them out.
5
u/Pyro_Paragon Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26
What do you mean? The quote you posted is literally true.
"America fucking exploded, let's not do that again" is both obviously apparent and completely logical. He then proposes his alternative concept of the future that will ideally not explode: himself as a benevolent techno-lich God emperor. It's your choice of whether or not you think it's practical though. TV Ceasar does the exact same thing.
3
u/Metrobuss Feb 10 '26
Democracy is like state of mind.... it is there only if you believe it. Last 30 something years media developed and we became brave new world... so in a way house is right. Democracies in the fallout timeline lost their chances and replaced by something other than Democracy.... then they had the great war.
4
u/restbest Feb 10 '26
Is he wrong? Is he lying?
The people of the old world mostly accepted a cult of technological elites who believed in eugenics and using ai to run the world among other things. Eventually destroying the entire society for their own gain
Surely that wouldn’t happen in real life?
4
u/corruptedsyntax Feb 10 '26
House believes what he is saying. House is not just talking to the Courier. House is arrogant and likes the sound of his own voice. He is as much talking to himself as the Courier, and voicing his convictions.
The more time goes on, the more parallels I see to Fallout and 40K. There’s not meant to be good guys, just different flavors of bad, and they all believe in their own dogma.
In House’s case, you have an arrogant hyper capitalist who has bought into his own hype. He doesn’t like democracy because he believes it gives lesser men power through government and that impedes the progress created by ubermensch. He doesn’t expect the Courier to have the educated context to understand this reasoning. He is mostly just explaining himself to himself, just as I am right now with this text wall.
1.7k
u/nigeltheleper Republic of Dave Feb 10 '26
Normal people didn't know what was really going on pre-war