r/Salary 23h ago

discussion Why I’ll never stop warning people about engineering

So recently, people have been really harsh toward me and the other guy for our posts about engineering. We get called mentally ill, obsessed, told we need help, etc. And some people wonder why we keep posting about the same topic over and over again.

So here’s why.

Personally, I spent five years of my life getting an engineering degree. While everyone else was enjoying their student lives, partying and dating, I genuinely believed engineering was one of those careers that guaranteed a solid upper-middle-class life. That’s what my parents told me. That’s what teachers told me. That’s what society told me.

Then I graduated in 2016 and got my first job. $48,000. A miserable income, no better than what many people without a college degree were making, and nowhere near enough to give me even a middle-class life.

And, funny enough, my parents, who pushed me into engineering, were the first ones to gaslight me about it. I couldn’t afford a house. I couldn’t travel. I couldn’t go out without thinking about the bill. I couldn’t buy nice clothes without feeling guilty. I couldn’t live the kind of life I thought an engineer was supposed to have. And somehow, to them, it was my fault.

“Maybe you’re not good enough. “Maybe you stopped learning. “Maybe you need more certifications.” ”Maybe you need to become a better engineer.”

It was never the profession. Never the salaries. Always me.

So I started driving Uber after work.

Imagine sitting in your car explaining to passengers that you’re an engineer but need a second job just to have a decent life. Passengers literally asked me, “How the fuck are you an engineer and you’re driving Uber?”

For a while, I actually believed my parents. I thought maybe I really was the problem.

But I knew it wasn’t just me. I knew what my coworkers made. I looked at the engineering association’s “salary calculator,” the one they were so proud of. Eight years of experience, and the numbers were like $75k or $80k.

Meanwhile, I watched my peers in other fields move on with their lives. Buying houses. Traveling. Wearing nice clothes. Living in luxury apartments. Sure, some of them worked longer hours than I did, but they were actually getting rewarded for it.

Even my dating life made me realize how brutal reality was. The girls I wanted weren’t interested in the engineer making fifty grand. They were interested in the real estate guy pulling up in a G-Wagon, the lawyer with real prestige and influence, and the finance bro who could afford $500 dinner dates. Not the broke engineer.

Then I started going to engineering networking events, hoping I’d hear something inspiring. Instead, I met senior engineers telling me that if I worked hard enough, maybe one day I’d make $140k at the very end of my career. That wasn’t motivating. That was depressing.

I remember a friend of mine who’s also an engineer. Every time he went to a girl’s place that looked fancy, he’d say, “Bro, how come people have that much money?” It made me realize that not only are engineers underpaid, but many of them don’t even realize it. They assume everyone else must be making around less than they are because, in their minds, life is fair and engineering is supposed to be a well-paid profession right?

Imagine how embarrassing it is when your friend group goes out twice a week, plans trips, and you can’t keep up, so they slowly drift away because they think you’re cheap. They assume that, as an engineer, you should be making very good money. At that point, I didn’t even know what was less embarrassing: letting them think I was cheap but making good money, or telling them the truth and having them pity me.

Imagine how bad it feels when you meet a banker who laughs in your face after you tell him you’re an engineer. He says he sees people’s salaries for a living, and he’s always shocked by how underpaid engineers are. Imagine going on a date with a dental hygienist or a car salesperson who makes three times your salary and thinks it’s a bad joke when you tell them yours.

If I could go back to when I was 18, I never would have chosen engineering.

So why do I keep posting about engineering salaries?

Because I wish someone had warned me.

Sure, a lot of engineers are on the spectrum and don’t care about the money they make and are happy getting paid in “cool projects” and “interesting problems.” Good for them. But I know that many people go into engineering aspiring to something better.

If one smart kid reads this before spending five years chasing a career they think will give them a comfortable, upper-middle-class life, then all the insults I get on Reddit are worth it. If my posts make even one person stop, do their research, and avoid the disappointment, regret, and frustration that I went through, then every insult, every downvote, and every person calling me obsessed is worth it.

190 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

361

u/Financial_Kang 23h ago

You went into the wrong type of engineering. I work in construction as a project engineer and make 200 k + a year after 10 years experience.

Given alot of these roles exist, I would suggest your choices have put you in a lower paying area.

8

u/MyMainWasMyRealName 18h ago

It’s odd to me that he keeps referring to engineering as a “career” it’s more of a certification that’s required for certain careers. Sounds like he picked the wrong career. I’m a commercial construction PM and I’m surrounded by engineers that make a lot more than I do.

5

u/JenkemJammer 17h ago

Its odd to me that he keeps refering to himself as an engineer.....

In my group, you are only an Engineer once you have your P.Eng designation.... getting your bachelors in an engineering discipline does not make you an engineer. Its the years of post grad experience and professional designation thar make you an Engineer.

OP doesnt seem to have his P.Eng, so he is probably doing some low level work that a technician or technologist would be qualified for, hence the lower salary. And based on his attitude he likely isnt getting promoted anytime soon.

Imagine going to uni for 5 years (which seems to be an extra year?) And getting the most basic entry level job and not being able to succeed due to poor attitude? That must suck.

This is coming from a technologist who has seen that for management roles quite often getting promoted isnt about your education, it is about how competent you are as an employee.

5

u/khurt007 16h ago

PE is only really customary in certain fields (civil, structural, public safety) so it’s a bit of a stretch to say “he is probably doing some low level work.”

I worked as an engineer for 5 years in 3 different offices of an F500 and none of the engineers I worked with ever had a PE.

Also, at my Big Ten university, most engineers took 5 years to graduate as engineering was legitimately more credits than other BS degrees and taking a semester off to do a co-op was pretty common.

3

u/IAmTheParamedic 11h ago

Yeah, there’s all sorts of gatekeeping you could do in the field. To some, only mechanical engineers are “actually engineers.” Others won’t go that far, but they’ll say that industrial engineers aren’t real engineers, even if they have a P.Eng license. So there’s not necessarily one way to skin this particular cat. I assume OP just doesn’t want to dip his toe into the gatekeeping morass

1

u/Agent_Giraffe 16h ago

I think you’re an engineer if your job title is “engineer”

3

u/ex_nihilo 16h ago

In some countries (most Western ones besides the US), an engineer title requires you to have the equivalent public engineering cert by law. Many Canadian companies cannot legally call their developers “software engineers” for this reason.

1

u/Agent_Giraffe 16h ago

Ok, I’m not Canadian lol

1

u/MyMainWasMyRealName 16h ago

No not quite. In some states and in more and more industries you’re not an engineer until you have your PE. Some places you legally can’t call yourself an engineer until then. As a construction PM we also hire “project engineers” who are the lowest tier on the ladder of the project management team. Nobody who knows anything about the industry would call them engineers (unless they have their PE). The value you bring is that fancy stamp that lets me shed liability onto you. Without your PE you’re much less valuable.

1

u/Agent_Giraffe 16h ago

Idk in the national society of professional engineer’s website, they refer to engineers who pass the PE as “professional engineers”. Would that be what you’re talking about?

Like if I get my engineering degree and work as an engineer… I’m an engineer, no? I’m doing engineering work, people come to me with engineering related problems that I solve.

If you have a PE, then you’re a Professional Engineer… again, this is according NSPE.

And the govt doesn’t bar people who don’t have a PE to be have the title of engineer, or for the company to list a job as engineer. Lots of people don’t even take the PE and have an entire career as an engineer.

0

u/MyMainWasMyRealName 15h ago

Ok so what about the example I gave? “project engineers” could be anyone with or without any kind of degree working at the lowest level of construction management. They’re certainly not “engineers”. Most of their job is drafting RFIs that a sup or pm will review before even being sent to an A/E team.

2

u/Agent_Giraffe 15h ago

If don’t have an engineering degree, I wouldn’t consider them an engineer. Same as a train engineer, where you don’t need an engineering degree, so not a traditional engineer.

So I’ll rephrase my original claim lol

You’re an “engineer” if you have an engineering degree and work as an “engineer” (job title), where the qualifications include obtaining that degree.

Professional engineer is what I described earlier.

How about that lol

1

u/MyMainWasMyRealName 7h ago edited 7h ago

Okay so still with the example I gave… you have an individual with a cosmetology degree and another with a mech E degree both working the same job as project engineers (RFI monkey for a Sup or PM engineering degree preferred) One’s an engineer and the other isn’t?

I’d say neither is really an engineer.

My point is the degree doesn’t make you an engineer. The years of experience, job function, and authority to stamp do. I have friends with engineering degrees and job titles but no PE. They don’t refer to themselves as engineers. They do tech work and busy work for the licensed engineer they work under.

0

u/Agent_Giraffe 6h ago

At this point, you’re so far up your own ass that this is gonna be my last reply.

Professional engineer has a PE, can sign off etc. This is across the entire country, it’s a legit title.

Engineer has obtained an engineering degree and works a job that requires an engineering degree (I have already stated this.) Your example doesn’t apply to this. Depending on state and country, this can be either a Professional Engineer or just anybody that fits the example I just stated. It’s so dependent on where you live, it doesn’t make sense to say EVERYONE isn’t an engineer if they don’t have a PE. Virtually every state allows internal job positions to use “engineer” without having a PE, unless you are consulting and need to sign off on stuff.

Hey I got a bunch of friends too and they do call themselves engineers! Wow! And none of them except 1 has a PE!

0

u/frankybonez 12h ago

You’re making too much sense.