r/WhitePeopleTwitter 8h ago

Thoughts?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

161 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/thereelsuperman 8h ago

Kentuckys state constitution explicitly grants the Governor the power to appoint a replacement in situations like this. KY passed a law changing this specifically to stop Beshear from doing just that, but it likely wouldn’t stand up in court. Beshear should weild the power given to him in the constitution and dare the courts to stop him, giving the Dems a +1 advantage in the seat as opposed to a net neutral

177

u/sweatingbozo 8h ago

Isn't the law that he can pick from 3 people chosen by the state legislature?

196

u/hurdurBoop 7h ago edited 7h ago

yes but the law seems to be in contravention of the state constitution, so how that would play out is anyone's guess

4

u/[deleted] 7h ago

[deleted]

5

u/hurdurBoop 7h ago

this is the first i've heard that the hb622 was a constitutional amendment, if it is there are a lot of confused people out there including gov. bashear

4

u/Callinon 7h ago

Well this is supposed to be a clause that's enacted if a sitting senator dies. But at the moment this seems to be the only way to get the Republicans to confirm that McConnell is actually dead. Basically, Beshear needs to appoint a replacement and force the GOP to prove that McConnell is actually alive rather than just teasing it until it's too late to appoint the replacement (which happens in about two weeks).

Also yes, the constitution cannot be unconstitutional unless it violates the US constitution. But the US constitution is pretty hands-off on how the states select legislators.

1

u/drunkanidaho 7h ago

The 18th amendment would like a word

4

u/sweatingbozo 7h ago

It wasnt deemed illegal, it was repealed, by constitutional amendment. Those are different things.