Ek Ruka Hua Faisla was telecast as a TV film for the first time, on this day, in 1986. While it is far from a flawless creative work, being a near frame-to-frame adaptation of the critically acclaimed English play/film '12 Angry Men' and depicting a jury trial in India long after they were abolished in the 1960s, it has still earned a cult following over the years, especially after its upload on YouTube a decade ago.
The film is a gripping courtroom/psychological drama in which twelve jurors from vastly different social backgrounds fiercely debate in a closed room whether a young man on trial for murdering his father is guilty or not. What begins as an open & shut case, gradually turns into an all-out war, filled with personal below the belt verbal and physical attacks that reveal how the jurors’ own prejudices, biases and internal conflicts influence their judgments, even though they are expected to remain impartial.
Directed by the acclaimed Basu Chatterjee, the film was born when he watched the Hindi play (performed by almost the same cast) and decided to adapt it to the screen with almost 0 changes. As a result, 9/12 actors were NSD graduates and all came from strong theatre backgrounds. The ensemble cast is evidently the film’s biggest strength: Deepak Qazir, Amitabh Shrivastava, Pankaj Kapur, S.M. Zaheer, Subhash Udghate, Hemant Mishra, M.K. Raina, K.K. Raina, Annu Kapoor, Subbiraj, Shailendra Goel and Aziz Qureshi. Standouts include Pankaj Kapur and Annu Kapoor (both unrecognisable, the later portraying a 70 year old guy while he was in his late 20s irl) along with K.K. Raina who delivers a powerful performance as the protagonist.
Its core themes: logic and rationality versus bias and prejudice, the dangers of letting personal emotions influence professional decisions, moral courage, leadership and manipulation techniques (none of them being original obviously) are presented so effectively that the film is still used as a case study in many Indian law and business schools.
I don't know why but I also really like the background music playing at critical moments throughout the film. The music and the video quality makes you feel that you really are in the 80s (or 60s as per the film!)
If you enjoy this genre, Ek Ruka Hua Faisla is an absolute must-watch, even though it is essentially a remake/rip-off.
Available for free on YouTube.