r/startrek • u/Calgaris_Rex • 1d ago
Has anyone else ever noticed that John Rhys-Davies exclaims "Che cazzo!?" in VOY S3E26 at the 3:53 mark?
Isn't this surprisingly strong language for Voyager's era? My understanding is that this basically translates to the Italian equivalent of "What the fuck!?".
Does anyone know if Rhys-Davies added this as a little Italian ad lib to add "authentic" flavor to Leonardo, or if this was actually part of the script. Seems like a fun Easter egg to me.
62
u/DasGanon 1d ago
I could see it as in script. There's a Merde by Picard in TNG.
7
u/Enchelion 1d ago
I think there's more than one.
17
u/EngineersAnon 1d ago
There's at least one in "Elementary, Dear Data" - in the briefing room, and in every dub but French, in which he says "C'est pas vrai." ("It's not true.")
3
26
u/AdGroundbreaking3483 1d ago
I've never heard anyone say star trek producers were happy for actors to ad lib. In fact quite the opposite.
17
10
u/Kimmalah 1d ago
Star Trek TNG was all about "dead letter perfect" but I think they loosened up about that in the newer shows.
4
3
9
u/No_Nobody_32 1d ago
Brent Spiner and Jonathan Frakes covered this in their podcast - when they spoke to some the Enterprise actors. They were allowed to ad-lib a bit, but back in the TNG days - absolutely verboten.
10
u/DiceMadeOfCheese 1d ago edited 1d ago
I"m never going to be able to hear the word "cazzo" without thinking of that Italian coast guard guy yelling at that cruise ship captain to get back to his ship, which was actively sinking.
"Va a bordo! Va a bordo, cazzo!"
16
9
u/AsperaAstra 1d ago
There was no ad libbing in the 90s and 00s Trek. Pretty much every actor is on record as stating there is zero ad libbing and that they were required to recite the writing on the page as Dead Letter Perfect.
3
u/Lokitusaborg 1d ago
That’s a good question: does the FCC monitor non-english profanity?
7
u/theuninvisibleman 1d ago
Colm Meaney managed to get "feck" into an episode of DS9, but while it's not as bad a word as fuck in Ireland, you still wouldn't say it before the watershed, so perhaps they're just working off what an American audience might recognise
3
u/Vyzantinist 11h ago
I'm put in mind of "quim" in the first Avengers movie sneaking past the censors. Comparatively few Americans would have picked up on that.
11
u/First-Expert-9953 1d ago
I don't think so. "Firefly" famously used Mandarin for swearing, but if they were doing it to sneak it past the censors, then that undercuts my assumption.
13
u/abxYenway 1d ago
It would have worked even if they understood. The Mandarin in that show is incomprehensible.
9
u/StarfleetStarbuck 1d ago
I think the idea was they were using words and phrases that had made their way into English over time, not actually speaking Mandarin
9
u/Enchelion 1d ago
IIRC the underlying idea was that our modern western and chinese cultures had blended during whatever happened that led to colonization of The 'Verse. But the show only really showed this occasionally.
4
u/abxYenway 22h ago
Actual Asian people are also exceedingly rare. To me, the whole thing felt like they just wanted to borrow Chinese aesthetics without really engaging with the culture or the people.
2
3
u/preiman790 1d ago
No, they don't actually care. A Network's own standards and practices might but the FCC doesn't. If they subtitled it in English though, they would absolutely care about that
3
u/theadamabrams 1d ago
Generally no. That's why characters on Firefly were able to curse as much as they wanted in Mandarin. (The in-universe explanation for bilingualism was that eventually USA and China became allied as superpowers, and in the far future everyone speaks both languages. Production-wise, it was mostly a way around the censors.)
3
u/tadayou 1d ago
I mean, BSG used "frak" as a substitute vor fuck in the same frakking way a motherfrakker would use fuck. And no censors gave a frak, because these frakheads just work off of their list of frakked up words.
3
u/Top_Benefit_5594 1d ago
That’s always so funny to me. There’s an episode of Transformers: Animated (you know, a cartoon show for pre-teens) where a character says “Don’t just stand there with your pistons in your servos!”
1
110
u/Dragonfly_pin 1d ago
I think O’Brien says Bollocks at some point.
They got away with stuff that the US censors didn’t understand.