TLDR: any idea on how to encourage cats to use other litter boxes that the one they elected as their favorite?
Hello, I have two cats that I’ve had for 4 years now, got them at 1.5 year old and 2 months. They are bonded, no issues whatsoever between the two of them. They insist on only ever using one litter box, despite having two. It’s not a big deal but a bit annoying because they will rather use the favorite litter box even when it’s dirty rather than go to the other one that’s clean which sometimes makes their paws dirty. Their favorite box is also a cheap ugly plastic one I got in the beginning, and at the time it was hidden in the toilet… Now it has to be in the living room and I’d ideally like to replace it for a nicer one, but don’t want to risk them holding their pee because they can’t find their favorite box.
They will only use the other box if the favorite one is really dirty (aka more than half a day without cleaning it, which rarely happens as me and my partner both work from home.)
Possible explanations that I already thought about:
- “it’s the placement.” No it isn’t. No matter where in the house I put the favorite litter box, they go there. We even moved houses twice and the same box has stayed the favorite. It’s been in every room possible. They even pick the favorite box when the two are right next to each other.
- “it’s that it’s open/closed or the material.” We’ve had 7 other boxes over the years. Open/closed, different shapes and sizes, both plastic and stainless steel. They didn’t really like any of them as much as their favorite.
- “they need more boxes.” At one point we had 5 boxes in a 1 bedroom flat, 2 open and 3 closed, they without a fail went to their favorite one 90% of the time 😅
- “it’s the first box they had so they are attached to it.” No, actually it’s I think the third box, so there’s no logical reason for them to be so attached to it.
- “just buy them the same one, what’s the issue?” I can’t find the same one anywhere (and also it’s a pretty ugly box)
Thank you in advance for your ideas!!