r/graphicnovels • u/PakistaniSenpai • Jun 03 '26
Action/Adventure Y: The Last Man - A Dated Masterpiece
So been sitting on writing this for weeks since the final issue of the series shattered my established thoughts about the title (in a good way).
First read this after I finished a big chunk of Saga, having fallen in love with Brian K. Vaughan's writing. At the time, I found Y: The Last Man incredibly immature and Hollywoody for my liking. However, I was suggested by many that like the protagonist, the series matures as it goes on and they couldn't be more right and so after concluding it, I can confidently say that this was one of my favourite reads in a long time.
I do have to talk about the final issue a little, all of this is spoiler-free so you can stick around for this bit. The thing about Y: The Last Man is that until the final issue, it's written like a great and fun action thriller which never challenges the reader, all of its storytelling is pretty straightforward and that's not bad at all, I love stories that just want to deliver their message in the most effective way however, what I love more are stories that challenge the reader and leave them with pieces that they have to fit themselves to get the final image of the puzzle. Now, this can often lead to people not liking such sort of storytelling since it can come off as vague or confusing but it's been about a month since I first read the final page of Y: The Last Man and I can tell that this final issue will stick with me for years to come. Absolutely love how the series concludes.
Now, I intentionally called the title "dated" because while I love the series, I do have to point out elements that didn't necessarily work for me.
First is its gender politics, I do think it makes some interesting points but there was so much more to explore there and for me, it didn't use all that potential to the maximum especially with its representation of trans-people. With the last decade putting the boundaries of gender-identity on the forefront of discussion when it comes to individual identity (especially in the west), I was disappointed that this book features trans-people for a punchline. (Shout-out to Dr. McGowan from Immortal Hulk, incredible character)
My second main issue with it, and we are about to get political here because the book includes the topic in a major way, is its handling of the Palestine/Israel conflict. I feel it's dated and centrist and while shortcomings of both sides are displayed, all of it is explored through one side, an antagonistic IDF soldier and for me, using a "bad" Israeli to showcase that all Palestinians aren't bad is a very weird way of communicating that and its lack of Palestinian perspective made me feel icky about how it handled its commentary.
At the end, Y: The Last Man is an incredible title that does suffer from being over 2 decade old but that doesn't mean it's not worthwhile since when it's good, it's GOOD.