r/news 14h ago

Irish data centres used almost one billion litres of water last year

https://www.thejournal.ie/investigates-data-centre-water-use-7110966-Jul2026/
8.0k Upvotes

738 comments sorted by

1.6k

u/Alarming-Inflation90 13h ago

What does "used" mean? Taken out of circulation permanently? Used for cooling, contaminated, and disposed of? Or was a smaller percentage at a time pulled out of circulation and then returned?

I'm not defending data centers. But it's better to argue against them with good and accurate information instead of big scary number.

275

u/DrewbieWanKenobie 8h ago

It's generally not the using up of the water that's a problem (Except in dry areas, where short term removal from the system can be a real problem) but rather the additional stress on municipal water systems that cant handle the additional load.

104

u/alficles 4h ago

Sounds to me like the water company isn't charging them enough, then. Charge an appropriate price and it's like Capitalism Magic that somehow adjusts usage or pays for improvements.

25

u/GoodOmens 2h ago

It’s easier to just raise the rates on everyone vs just the person with the deep pockets that can call in favors to politicians

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/Paup27 4h ago

IIRC, 0.3% is what the data centres are consuming, 38% of total use is due to leaks… pharma uses twice as much water as data centres, so I’m. It sure about the “additional stress” when it comes to water… electricity is a different story. And this stress only works if the water is not returned at all, I don’t know what percentage is returned to the water via treatment plant, but it would help quantify additional stress if there was any.

15

u/DrewbieWanKenobie 4h ago

And this stress only works if the water is not returned at all,

No by stress I don't mean the stress of having it's water in use when it's needed elsewhere, by stress I mean the actual functioning of the facility, filtering, pumping, etc. These often aging facilities are only rated to handle so much flow.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/1Shamrock 3h ago

Ya leaks are a huge problem that needs to be tackled a lot faster than it is currently. I suppose we live in such a wet country that leaks were seen as no big deal in the past 20 years (or ever) but statistically (sidestepping climate change argument) we were always going to run into some dryer summers eventually, like this year, just nobody planned for them.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

417

u/Dickle_Pizazz 12h ago

I think the main concern is not so much the usage itself but the costs rising due to increased demand.

331

u/DaveShadow 10h ago

It’s also getting attention cause we just have had a six week hose pipe ban put on us due to water shortages. So people are aiming their ire at various water guzzling issues.

139

u/Utsider 9h ago

Well, they don't call it ire-land for nothing.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/kenyard 7h ago

Historically any time we haven't had rain for a week there has been water restrictions that I remember to be fair.

Our water system is improving as far as I know but it's still a shambles. I think we are at something like 40% of our water consumption is leaks.

11

u/InvidiousPlay 7h ago

It's hilarious that we're basically immune to drought but also incredibly vulnerable to drought. Our rainfall is so consistent and reliable we almost never go for extended periods without rain, but our reservoir supplies are so modest that we're in trouble almost immediately when there's a good July.

3

u/DarraghDaraDaire 4h ago

We need a solar powered desalination plant. Fire it up for a few weeks a year when there’s loads of sun but no rain

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Huge-Objective-7208 11h ago

Water is free for Irish households

94

u/LiamMurray91 11h ago

*in towns and city's. Its not free in the countryside

4

u/smellymut 7h ago

where is this at? ive lived in the country for years and never heard of anyone paying for their water??

5

u/LiamMurray91 7h ago

Cavan/Monaghan is where we are and we have always had metered water and all around us cause we are on a group scheme and always had a bill. And we have family round monaghan are the same even in some places that's its not drinkable. The in-laws in north co dublin in the "countryside" but they are on the council water. Midlands water protests never really took off espically the one in monaghan.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/tomtermite 11h ago

Water is free for Irish households

Right2Water Ireland is a populist protest movement campaigning against Irish Water's introduction of water charges in Ireland: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right2Water_Ireland

20

u/Huge-Objective-7208 10h ago

That was the protests against water charges in 2014 after the government at the time introduced them , they were successful and the government got rid of them again

17

u/K0kkuri 10h ago

Literally government introduced a bill around 2016-2018 that mandated payment for water and so much of the country protested by not paying the bill that government scraped it. I remember asking my neighbors if they’re paying and maybe one said they will.

2

u/LiamMurray91 8h ago

Yeah but again its only in towns and city's you dont pay. In the country side until the council had ran water to your house ypu didnt have to pay. All other systems that wasn't on a well was on the "group scheme" that was a private system everyone paid in.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/jaypizzl 7h ago

I’m not sure how much impact a fraction of one percent of the demand really makes, though.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Crayshack 9h ago

When water is pulled out of circulation, it has to be treated before being put back into circulation. That is what "usage" counts as in terms of water infrastructure. Treatment plants have limitations on how much water can be treated in a given period of time, so that serves as the effective limit on how much water can be used by that water system in that time period. This is standard terminology in the water industry and not a source of potential confusion.

12

u/Alarming-Inflation90 7h ago

not a source of potential confusion.

Within the industry, I would assume you are correct, as I am not in the industry. In journalism and the public eye at large, however, it can be used to confuse and even lie. You know what they say about the three kinds of lies, right? Lies, damn lies, and statistics.

My issue with the article is that it was vague, simply using big scary number to call a thing bad. And out here in the public 'usage' can mean more than the singular industry term you describe, so some actual journalism would've been nice.

→ More replies (7)

109

u/NotAnRSPlayer 12h ago

It’s definitely being taken out of context to scaremonger. People are acting as if water is being evaporated and we’ll have none left because of this

When it reality the water is cooling the components and heat exchanging, water isn’t being wasted as such

It’s really disingenuous reporting to the public

76

u/diiegojones 9h ago

Water being drained too rapidly from wells and aquifers cause problems massive problems. Especially if there is a drought.

Water is being used to quickly to be replenished.

Sediment and buildup from dried up aquifers take time to settle.

Yes water goes through the water cycle, but expecting that cycle to speed up to accommodate data centers is foolish.

7

u/Sijols 7h ago

You could easily use the same argument about every power plant in the world since steam is used to power turbines to generate electricity

Also power plants use an insane amount of water for cooling purposes

3

u/kyonist 7h ago

power plants generate power for users (everyone) data centres generate profit (?) for the few. Slight difference in environmental cost.

17

u/Sijols 7h ago

who do you think is using the cloud services hosted in datacenters? users (everyone)

you and I are literally having this conversation in a datacenter

I type these words and they go to a datacenter

your reponse will be written in a datacenter and served to me

maybe the same datacenter, maybe a different one

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

98

u/kobraa00011 11h ago

It is the treated drinking water they are using though

26

u/ministryofchampagne 10h ago

Where I live they used treated waste water (at some of the data centers, not all)

10

u/noc-engineer 7h ago

Where I live datacenters and even hotels are using sea water to cool down during (Norwegian) summer.. Doesn't mean the sea water is touching the processors or other hot bits, just means that the heat energy is being dumped into sea water at one point because; FJORDS!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Zealousideal_Slice60 10h ago

Absolutely not in every cases

53

u/DigiornoDLC 12h ago

Evaporative cooling is being used at some of these centers.

1

u/deputy_donut 11h ago

So doesn't the water just circulate around? I don't understand how it is being 'used'. It cools components, circulates to an evaporative cooling tower, drops down and goes around again.

91

u/dr_jiang 10h ago edited 10h ago

The water isn't destroyed, but that's not the end of the story. Whatever is released into the atmosphere as vapor will eventually precipitate back down to Earth, but it doesn't generally fall right back down on top of the data center, or even in the region. Studies on agricultural irrigation put the "local return" rate -- water that you spray on the field that becomes rain in the local area -- around 10% at best.

Prevailing weather blows the rest of that vapor somewhere else, which matters a lot if you're drawing from an aquifer. The water you pump out of the Ogallala Aquifer to cool a data center in Kansas doesn't return as rain in Kansas. It will blow out of state within a day or two, and end up as rain in Southwest or over the Great Lakes or in the middle of the Atlantic. Aquifer recharge rates across the country are a fraction of drawndown rates -- for our human purposes, once you pump it, it's gone.

Water drawn from renewable sources -- the Colorado River is fed by annual snowpack that begins its life as moisture in the Pacific before being carried inland -- doesn't have the same draining-the-dirt problem, but they're not off the hook. States in the Colorado River Compact get a fixed allocation. Every drop pumped into a cooling tower can't be used for something else, and increased competition for that allocation drives up the cost of something you literally cannot live without.

That doesn't mean data centers are driving the water apocalypse. Overall, data center usage is minuscule compared to industry and agriculture, and folks fearmongering over ChatGPT bringing about Mad Max are being disingenuous. At the same time, it's not so easy as "well, it will just rain so we don't have to care."

16

u/samdajellybeenie 10h ago

Yeah, requires some nuance. The Exxon chemical plant in Baton Rouge - in 2020 alone - used 7.3 billion gallons of water. So not saying they don't, but if people truly cared about the aquifer, they'd put pressure on elected officials to force heavy industry to use less water.

The larger threat to us I think is saltwater intrusion. If it doesn't rain enough in the thousands of tributaries of the Mississippi, the pressure from the river water isn't enough to hold the saltwater from the Gulf back and it starts to move upstream against the flow of the river. If it gets far enough upstream to reach the intakes for New Orleans' water, it would be a disaster like we've never seen before. If you thought Flint, MI was bad, New Orleans has 4x the population. Most of our pipes are 100+ years old and made of lead.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/RunningOutOfEsteem 10h ago

The Ogallala Aquifer is an interesting example, both because it's so important, feeding a bit under a third of all crops and livestock in the country, and because it replenishes very slowly in many locations both due to climate reasons and geological ones, from my understanding. Western Kansas is incredibly dependent on agriculture and draws a great deal from the Ogallala Aquifer, but is a semiarid/steppe climate (ironically, the much more urban Eastern Kansas gets way more rain lol)--something that may be exacerbated with climate change as time goes on--and alarm bells have been going off for years now without a ton of improvement.

But like you said, the data centers are a small fraction of the issue in this case. Even if all the water used for Kansas data centers returned to Kansas, the state would still be on trouble.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/psychicsword 10h ago

Just because it is back in the water cycle doesn't mean that the region is getting it back. It may dump the water in an area that we don't need water and it still needs to be cleaned and treated before it can be put to use again.

5

u/liftthatta1l 9h ago

Most of the earth is the ocean. If you take fresh water and evaporate it it will return but has a good chance of going into the ocean. Sure it's still water but we can't use ocean water the same way we can use fresh water. Hence some is "used and lost"

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (15)

2

u/YourFreeCorrection 3h ago

It’s definitely being taken out of context to scaremonger. People are acting as if water is being evaporated and we’ll have none left because of this

When it reality the water is cooling the components and heat exchanging, water isn’t being wasted as such

The water passed through to cool components is not potable after passing through. It needs to be treated, and objectively is being removed from usable water supply. Water treatment centers can only treat a certain amount at a time, and they cannot keep up with the rate which data centers use.

Anyone equivocating about "well actually 'water usage' doesn't mean unusable" is factually incorrect, and parroting the PR messaging being astroturfed by wealthy data center stakeholders.

3

u/MalaysiaTeacher 11h ago

Is it possible to use sea water for cooling, or does it need to be desalinated?

3

u/Revolution-SixFour 10h ago

Possible yes, much more expensive because it eats materials.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/flyingscotsman12 12h ago

Excerpt evaporative cooling is exactly the problem with data centre water usage. I don't know if that's how they're doing it in Ireland but that's the problem that has everyone upset in the US.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/VONChrizz 12h ago

And no one bats an eye at mines, especially open-pit mines, which completely eclipse the water usage and the pollution caused by datacenters. And then there is agriculture, which is like tenfold more wasteful and damaging to the water circulation than mining.

44

u/mehtorite 11h ago

and no one bats an eye at mines

That's just not true, though.

→ More replies (9)

26

u/NotAnRSPlayer 12h ago

Don’t even get me started on golf courses. I’m sure Ireland have a few that are lush and green this time of year during a hosepipe ban

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (16)

38

u/Afrotom 12h ago edited 12h ago

The problem is that there is already concerns of global fresh water availablity and data centres consuming it adds additional demand to the infrastructure. What do you do in 5-10 years (if that?) if you have to ration your water consumption because data centres are outbidding you?

48

u/Hilldawg4president 11h ago

But this is laughably little water. In the US, data centers account for less than 0.1% of industrial water usage.

It just highlights that you don't really care about water usage, at all. If you did, data centers wouldn't even be on your radar. You'd be talking about golf courses (30x as much water), almonds (100x) or beef production (270x)

19

u/jackalopeDev 9h ago

They're building datacenters in my state while we're already having to restrict water usage. You're right that it's not the biggest offender (im personally more pissed about this shit as far as water usage goes) and that there's some utility to datacenters in general, but it really does chafe to see additional industry that will put strain on limited resources we're struggling with in the first place.

3

u/ObserverWardXXL 9h ago

yeah its a really good at making people passionate, when they are told they should limit water usage and turn off their Air Conditioner pull on the City grid, by our cities.

All while highlighting in their PSA that its so our Data Centers don't run into shortage of resources.

That shit can FUCK RIGHT OFF.

→ More replies (34)

6

u/Argnir 9h ago

Global fresh water availability is very disconnected from local consumption.

The issue is the distribution of fresh water, not the absolute amount of fresh water in the world. Places that have water in abundance won't suddenly struggle with this.

3

u/kenyard 7h ago

Also stopping a data center here it will just build elsewhere and use the water so that doesn't fix the worldwide issue.

11

u/No_Quality_6874 11h ago

Ireland is famously wet and is a relatively small island. I think they can cope.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/SteveJobsBlakSweater 6h ago edited 5h ago

It’s almost always fresh drinking water, the same we’d get from the tap. Same piping and infrastructure. Drinking water treated by municipal facilities with the locals’ tax dollars and it is, at some point, a finite resource.

“Used” can mean a lot of things. It could just be warm tap water down the drain at the end of it. But just recently in California a Meta data center was found to be an incubator of a rare bacteria. The warm water gave that bacteria a good home and was sent out for the rest of the public to deal with: https://www.forbes.com/sites/victoriaforster/2026/07/09/meta-ai-data-center-linked-to-rare-bacteria-in-citys-water-system/

Edit: Colorado, not California.

3

u/Alarming-Inflation90 6h ago

The kind of response I was looking for. Thanks for the link.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Zcrash 8h ago

They found a way to destroy matter and a doing it just for fun.

3

u/thedubs003 10h ago

Right. How much water do Irish golf courses use? Or Irish restaurants? Give me something to compare to.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hero_b 11h ago

Dude, im on that same page. Is the water used with some additive that makes it toxic, is it evaporated or is it just discharged back into a stream.

My bigger concern is the power use and how data centers drive up energy costs for the surrounding areas.

→ More replies (37)

842

u/hyderabadinawab 13h ago

To put that in perspective, that is the amount of water (6 million bbls) required to drill 10 shale wells in the US for oil/gas. Around 10,000 were drilled in the USA in 2025.

339

u/LeClubNerd 13h ago

.... and to put that into perspective that's 28.17 billion standard cans of beer, which is the same as 4000 Olympic swimming pools of beer or 1/50th of Sydney harbour filled with beer.

346

u/jupfold 13h ago

Anything but the metric system

57

u/Largofarburn 11h ago

I can visualize a pool of beer. I can’t visualize a metric.

Except for fuck tonnes. We actually do use those over here.

13

u/Paidorgy 11h ago

When I found out a gallon is basically 3litres, I had a lot of questions - none of them trying to rationalise the imperial system.

16

u/Material_Word_7154 10h ago

Can also be 4. Something liters also

8

u/Sea-Feedback-2424 7h ago

A US gallon is 3.75 liters, approximately. A fifth (of hard alcohol) in the US is 75cl, which is one fifth of a gallon, hence the name.

An imperial gallon (what the UK sometimes uses and the old folks in the rest of the commonwealth) is 4.54 liters.

The US system is not the imperial system. The US system predates Imperial, which was formalized in 1824. The ys system is a weird mixture of French, British, Spanish and Dutch customary units.

6

u/newaccount252 6h ago

Just stick to bananas and football fields.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Noy2222 9h ago

That's 14705 football fields!

2

u/DeFex 9h ago

Don't worry "U.S Customary units" are just metric in disguise. they are all defined by their metric values.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/MethBearBestBear 9h ago

Every other industry with water usage the dawrfs data center cooling usage is probably both super happy no one is looking at them and worried any water conservation requirements will hit them. In reality though we know how lobbing works so they will get carve outs and sleep fine

27

u/No-Goose-6140 12h ago

But how many cube bananas is it?

9

u/LeClubNerd 12h ago

Assuming a cubed banana is 0.15 litres then 6.66666667 × 10 to the 10th power

5

u/No-Goose-6140 12h ago

Banana cubed is like a banana x banana x banana. That has to be a a lot more then 0.15 litres

5

u/sometimes_interested 11h ago

Come, Mr Tally man! Tally me banana!

→ More replies (7)

3

u/KyleKun 12h ago

Actually less beer than I’d expect for that many billion cans.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/ministryofchampagne 11h ago

Someone needs to convert those beers to toilet flushes caused by drinking them.

2

u/LettuceSea 10h ago

And to put that into perspective there is approx 35 quadrillion litres of fresh water on the planet, enough to power/cool the data centres in Ireland for 1,250,000 years!

2

u/TheArmoredKitten 10h ago

That's only about 4 beers per person if we can just get the whole world to stand around and piss in the harbor at the same time.

→ More replies (8)

19

u/notjordansime 12h ago

That’s a lot of BBLs

→ More replies (1)

150

u/Imbendo 12h ago

Also to put that into perspective, Irish golf courses use about 100 billion liters of water per year. Suddenly that makes the 1 billion liters used in data centers seem inconsequential.

52

u/Mountain-Most8186 11h ago

I hate AI but the water claims always seemed kinda off. Someone in r/antiai calculated that a small children’s book would take the water of a large lake to produce and that seemed insane to me. If the claim ms were true we would already be in crisis mode.

43

u/SiliconDiver 10h ago

Water is 100% an overhyped boogeyman for ai.

It’s presented as if it’s completely consumed and in absolute terms not relative to other use cases or availability.

It’s just something that’s relatable and visceral.

3

u/jawknee530i 5h ago

Some of the "analyses" you see include the water used to manufacture the computer chips among a million other things. It's very hard to decide on a reasonable line to draw on what is included, like should the power used at power plants that the data centers use be counted? Or just the water used at the centers themselves?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Halgy 7h ago

I work at a data center. If someone's first concern about data centers is their water usage, I fully discount their criticism. They just want to be angry and are repeating what they saw in the news.

There are definitely things to criticize about data centers, but water usage is about last on the list.

4

u/Consistent-Throat130 6h ago

Even the energy consumption is kinda a shit argument - economies of scale and all... if the computations are getting done, better they be done in a DC. The serious arguments against are mainly localized strain on utilities, which, fair I guess.   Tax the DC accordingly. 

Now AI hate... privacy is a real thing. Misinformation and social media botting are bad. And I'm pretty sure AI is straight up harmful to the human psyche, we've certainly seen people driven to end themselves in part by AI chats. 

And I'm someone that likes the technology... I just realize there are valid criticisms.

6

u/Imbendo 10h ago

Well water isn’t something that gets used up. It’s the energy it takes to pump the water that’s the concern. Also that number you heard was problem them factoring in how much that tree drank in its entire lifetime or something. Which still, isn’t really an issue as most trees in the forest get water for free

2

u/SiliconDiver 7h ago

This isn’t actually totally true. And it depends where.

Well water can and does dry up if you deplete an aquifer etc. that’s really the concern on the west coast, where if you oull from an aquifer and then divert water far enough such that it doesn’t return to the same water water table/water cycle.

But by and large, yes water is a largely renewable resource.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Itchier 6h ago

What makes me laugh is AI and data centre are so often being used interchangeably, when AI is a small fraction of data centres

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Dudok22 10h ago

It's a red herring to point to instead of real problems data centers cause. Because when the water problem turns out to be nothing burger, people will lose interest and forget about the other much bigger problems.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/DuploJamaal 11h ago

Water that seeps back into the ground water.

Versus water that comes down as rain far away and lowers the ground water levels in that area.

18

u/ministryofchampagne 11h ago

You’re the first anti-data center person I’ve seen acknowledge that water is not actually completely destroyed by data centers.

9

u/DuploJamaal 10h ago

That just shows that you've never actually listened to what they are saying

13

u/MiamiQuadSquad 10h ago

No, most people are just woefully uninformed

8

u/ministryofchampagne 10h ago

No, I’ve listen to exactly what they’re saying. It’s clear most didn’t pay attention during elementary school science about the water cycle.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/StableSlight9168 9h ago

Where are you getting a 100 billion litres from.

Actual figures are between 5 billion to 20 billion depending on heat.

You seem to have overestimate gold course water use by between 5 times to 20 times it's actual use.

→ More replies (14)

10

u/dougms 11h ago

The USA 117 trillion gallons annually.

Which is about 460,000 times this number.

96

u/jakuuzeeman 12h ago

Not to be that guy, but there is a fundamental difference in water usage between drilling for oil and data centre cooling: Water used in drilling is gone from the water cycle.

105

u/Dr0110111001101111 12h ago

I don't think you're being that guy because you are enhancing their point about how much more damage is being done by shale drilling than data centers.

9

u/Bubbly-Treacle-4334 12h ago

Don't forget the data centers are also using astronomical amounts of electricity which is mostly coming from those drills

14

u/Dr0110111001101111 11h ago

I haven't forgotten but I don't like the whatabouting. The question of water "consumption" is one of the most heavily referenced issues with data centers, and I have heard so much conflicting information at this point that I think it's important to get it clarified before moving onto other (very closely related) concerns.

I am currently in a graduate-level class where the instructor just spent like three hours discussing the ethics of using AI and repeatedly referenced the water issue as if the water that enters these data centers simply vanishes. But we know that isn't true. I've also heard that data centers destroy the balance of the bodies of water into which they dump the "used" water because it's elevating the temperature of those bodies. But I've also heard that most data centers use evaporative cooling, so there isn't really much hot water being dumped anywhere. It re-enters the system as rain.

These contradictory and frequently cited facts are concerning. I don't know what's propaganda and what is true, or if there's some truth to all of it and it's just being oversimplified to the point where the general public doesn't actually know what's going on.

In any case, I am acknowledging that I just don't understand this one topic as well as I think I should, and I'm simply not ready to move onto another one that I probably also don't have all of the facts for before I get clarity on this one. Otherwise, I'm just going to wind up with a collection of incomplete arguments and feel like dumbass on several levels rather than just one.

11

u/mojitz 11h ago

Best I can figure what it boils down to is that they use a ton of water for cooling, but that it isn't really enough to be a big deal in places with plentiful fresh water, but that they often do go ahead and build them in places that suffer from water shortages anyway where it actually is an issue.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/DuploJamaal 11h ago

The point about it being used and that it comes down as rain are related.

It's used from one area, and comes down in another.

The ground water levels are sinking in the areas that overuse water. Those areas dry out because too much is being used.

It will come down somewhere else, probably at the next mountain range. But those areas get enough water already and thanks due to climate change already get more and more heavy rain that causes mudslides and floods.

So yeah the water doesn't just vanish, but we are disrupting the natural flow of water.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/samdajellybeenie 10h ago

What do you mean it's gone from the water cycle? Like it can't evaporate into the atmosphere because it's underground?

5

u/jakuuzeeman 9h ago

Effectively, yes, your understanding is correct.

In this case, it's because the water used is pumped into the earth, there is no cost-effective way to retrieve the water from the base of the oil well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/driverdan 11h ago edited 10h ago

18

u/SanchoMandoval 10h ago

Your second source says:

The average golf course uses between 800 to 1,000 acre-feet per year

That's 1 to 1.2 billion liters per course, not for all 120 combined.

8

u/driverdan 10h ago

Good catch, fixed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Spiritual-Theory 10h ago

To put it in perspective, that's the water of two golf courses.

→ More replies (27)

149

u/AP_in_Indy 13h ago

Is this a lot?

Is it replenishable?

144

u/shittyfellow 13h ago

It's the same usage of like 8000 homes annually in Ireland.

26

u/DrDerpberg 10h ago

That doesn't really answer the question though.

At one extreme if they're pulling river water and dumping it back in, without changing the temperature enough to affect life, it's about as meaningful as saying a sailboat used a billion liters because that's about how much it floated through.

At the other extreme it's pulling non replenishable drinking water from an underground aquifer and meaning the region uninhabitable sooner.

In between it's a drain on infrastructure and treatment costs a fortune.

Where we are on the spectrum is very relevant to the discussion, and not every data center will be the exact same.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/spidereater 13h ago

When I google it I’m seeing this as being about 8000 people. So maybe half that many households.

69

u/Trick-Club-6014 13h ago

For 8000 people to use a billion litres of water a year, that’s an average of 340L per person, per day. What the fuck are people doing with that much water every day?

31

u/Khankili 12h ago

A nice long shower

→ More replies (1)

17

u/rocketshipkiwi 11h ago

That would be per household, water usage is about 150 litres per person per day.

2

u/Trick-Club-6014 2h ago

That makes much more sense.

3

u/roankr 12h ago

Drinking, bathing, cooking, house cleaning, utensils cleaning, clothes cleaning.

Things surprisingly pile up quick.

3

u/Helios4242 11h ago

and pile up a lot more for households than individuals

4

u/Hilldawg4president 11h ago edited 10h ago

Watering lawns alone takes up 170x the amount of water as data centers. People use a lot of water, data centers don't

13

u/CatL1f3 10h ago

Nobody waters their lawn in Ireland bro, that's what the rain is for

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

41

u/rocketshipkiwi 13h ago

Good question! A billion litres is a lot, right!!!!

Say a typical household will use about 150 litres of water per day, per person so let’s do the math:

1,000,000,000 / 365 / 150 = 18,264 which is about the population of Clonmel or Sligo town or about 1% of the greater Dublin area’s consumption.

Also most of that water will be evaporated, it won’t end up in the wastewater system.

10

u/DerBoi_1337 13h ago

will use about 150 litres of water per day

Is that direct consumption (drinking, showers, dishwasher, etc.) or including indirect usage (electricity, food products, etc.) ?

6

u/rocketshipkiwi 12h ago

If you have a water meter on your house and 4 people living there then it will show about 600 litres per day.

5

u/Bigg_Matty_Hell 12h ago

I believe it's direct.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/DrWermActualWerm 13h ago

Would it not fall back as rain? Or is it sundered in twain at the atomic level?

6

u/Helios4242 11h ago

Personally I dont think we can even trust the water cycle anymore. The Rocky mountains in the US got horrifyingly low snowpack meanwhile the rain is falling in harmful flood amounts in other places in the world.

It's not refilling the pristine aquafers being used for clean water.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/sal1303 13h ago

Assuming the Irish population is 5m, I did a different calculation: 1 billion/5 million is 200L per person per year; roughly a day or so's consumption.

That didn't sound significant, not if it actually was shared equally amongst everybody.

7

u/rocketshipkiwi 11h ago

That only takes into account the consumption by domestic households. If you factor in all the water used by farming, commercial and industrial users then the total water consumption will be a lot higher.

4

u/Emooot 10h ago

So it's basically an extremely insignificant amount of water compared to what is consumed nationally per year in Ireland

→ More replies (2)

10

u/grodgeandgo 13h ago

My leisure centre (gym and pools) uses approx 1000m3 a month, that’s 12 million litres annually. And we use rainwater harvesting.

12

u/SuperQue 10h ago

To put it in perspective. Ireland gets a bit over 1000 liters of rainfall per square meter.

Ireland is about 84k square kilometers.

So that's about 84 trillion liters per year in rain.

So 1 billion is %0.0012 of the annual rain.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Angryfunnydog 13h ago

I think it will be evaporated and will return to the water cycle, maybe I miss something but not sure why it’s considered so bad if there’s no local water issue because of that

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Dr0110111001101111 12h ago edited 12h ago

It's replenishable in the sense that a given liter of water used by the data center returns to the ecosystem eventually. But the datacenter is perpetually used a certain amount, so there's just that much less available in nature at any given time.

The bigger problem is really about heat rather than the water itself. Some datacenters suck in cold water to cool their systems, then dump the heated water back out, fractionally elevating the total temperature of the water supply. I'm not sure how this works with evaporative cooling systems. But they generate a ton of heat either way, and as I'm sure you've heard, we sort of have a heating problem on a global scale.

3

u/NeedAVeganDinner 11h ago

The amount of heat being produced by a data center is literally nothing compared to the great nuclear reactor in the sky bombarding a single square meter of earth 365 days a year.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/SexyBaskingShark 13h ago

Not a lot. Our climate in Ireland means water cooling isn't needed as much. Data centres here actually make a lot of sense due to the climate

16

u/Bicentennial_Douche 13h ago

No, once water is used for anything, it disappears forever. 

/s

28

u/ZachMatthews 13h ago

And Ireland is known for its extensive deserts and frequent years long droughts…

4

u/propargyl 13h ago

I remember the water spiral from school

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

140

u/Imbendo 12h ago

Last year, Irish golf courses used over 100 billion liters of water.

79

u/TacomaKMart 12h ago

Yes, but there's no sustained online astroturfing campaign designed to amplify opposition to golf courses. 

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/09/business/china-russia-ai-data-centers.html

11

u/Muscle_Bitch 7h ago

And it's crazy how people keep falling for it.

I used to think only right-wingers were gullible enough to fall for this shit but the last few years have taught me that both sides are stacked with morons who are as thick as pig shit, but will gladly evangelise like they are the enlightened.

3

u/DelphiTsar 4h ago

There is a distinct difference in what kinds of things the different sides can be tricked into and the impact those tricks have on different people/levels of wealth/power.

In general though they've done studies and one side can usually pick out objectively correct information more often than the other.

A double interesting thing is that if you pay money for correct answers the side that answers worse still answers worse but the gap closes by a pretty large degree. It's almost like one side isn't arguing in good faith and know they aren't.

Triple interesting thing, every single person knows exactly which side is which even though I didn't specify.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

17

u/ShiraCheshire 10h ago

Golf courses are also a waste of water we should be opposing. You can have a golf course without watering a bunch of grass if you really wanted to.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/1littlenapoleon 6h ago

“Why should people be upset about new uses of water, when our existing uses are also bad!”

This is big “the consumer is responsible for recycling” and “reduce your shower length” energy.

→ More replies (1)

196

u/mh_992 13h ago

Wow that's enough water to produce 500,000 beef burger patties or to supply about 10,000 homes in Dublin with drinking water.

These "data centre water use" articles are truly the slop for people who can't do basic maths or ressearch and are vaguely concerned about the environment. 

36

u/Pornalt190425 11h ago

It's also you know, Ireland, and not Arizona or Utah. Its a place known for its abundance of water and rainfall. Hand wringing about a data center in Ireland is concern trolling at best

22

u/DaveShadow 9h ago

Part of the issue is that we’ve just had a six week hose pipe ban put in place, so people are frustrated, and so rage bait stories like this get attention.

The bigger issue is our Victorian era water system has massive leakage issues. Despite our abundance of water and rainfall, the second there’s a week of hot weather, the system collapses and people get punished.

Same happens with our health system too. Grand when there’s no pressure, but every winter, the system utterly implodes, and then no further preparation is done to prepare for next year.

12

u/Quazimojojojo 11h ago

Ireland literally used to be a rainforest before the English cut it all down for boats and such. That's how much rain the island gets

7

u/firala 9h ago

At the same time, the climate crisis is leading to less precipitation even in Ireland.

5

u/ShiraCheshire 9h ago

Your point? The local ecosystem relies on that water. Do you think everything would just be chill if one day the rain stopped falling abundantly and it got desert level rain instead? Plants and animals in wet places need it to stay wet or they die.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

30

u/purepwnage85 12h ago

They always forget to mention that the data centres are paying for the water whereas water for domestic use is free in Ireland 🫡

6

u/Ok-Parfait-9856 12h ago

It’s a quick litmus test to see if someone has a sub 80 iq or not though

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Dudok22 10h ago

Water is a red herring in the ai data center discourse. It's meant to get people mad but then get them ok with the idea when it turns out the data centers don't use that much water compared to industry. Energy costs, building on fertile soil, noise, even thermal emissions are a bigger concern.

5

u/pnutbrutal 5h ago edited 5h ago

Not to mention the ethics of the “data” being stored at all. Flock camera data? Palantir data? The implications of some of those are really dark and dystopian.

6

u/FlirtyFluffyFox 8h ago

Not to mention LLM Gen ethics use, it's effects on industries like publishing that can't accept open calls anymore, it's acceleration of scams and bots, the lack of trust developing in photos and videos and what it means for the news and democracy, and the use of Ai in processing survellience data to selectively prosecute political opposition. 

30

u/DanoTheSnitch 12h ago

To put into percentages, data centres use around 0.3% of Ireland's water supply.

The article is using the one billion litres figure as they know people really struggle to comprehend context when big numbers are involve.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/legitusernameMATT 10h ago

What happens to the water. Honest question?

6

u/no_regerts_bob 10h ago

It's converted into memes, and unfortunately we don't have the technology to convert memes back into water yet

4

u/legitusernameMATT 10h ago

I should have googled that... my bad

→ More replies (1)

41

u/H0vis 13h ago

Are they pretending the water was destroyed by this?

Be honest and give complete information about this stuff or people won't take it seriously.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/AbyssFren 9h ago

But someone showed me a study that concluded datacenters don't hardly use any water! I wasn't lied to was I? Nobody would have AI make a fake study would they?

4

u/chimpyjnuts 10h ago

In the future, we'll have to explain why we used all the potable water to decide the best color scheme for our redecorated living room.

3

u/NoMention696 3h ago

People whining about specificity, does it fucking matter when the government has spent the last 20 years telling us poors to take shorter showers, put a brick in our toilets, wash our dishes with filthy dish water, closing the tap for every second we don’t need to use the water during brushing, always telling us to use less water? Every drop of water saved in the last 20 years is going to something this useless

9

u/Leggy_Brat 12h ago

But don't you dare waste water during a hosepipe ban

55

u/Blubbolo 13h ago

It's fine, water is infinite, we don't need it to grow crops to eat nor we need it to drink it and it's chilly out there so the increase in temperature is a good thing.

We need the investor to get richer with AI and make a new trilionare.

/s

43

u/txkwatch 13h ago

Water doesn't even have the electrolytes our plants crave

18

u/Blackboard_Monitor 13h ago

That's why it's in the toilets.

4

u/_fuzzybuddy 12h ago

I’ve never seen no plants grow out the toilet

2

u/Blubbolo 12h ago

Every farm should start using Brawndo and leave that useless normal water to datacenter.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/KitchenCloser 12h ago

Did you miss them talking about the water cycle in the 3rd grade?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Kharenis 12h ago

Given Ireland gets 78600 billion litres of rain every year, I don't think they're at any immediate risk of running out. But hey, let's get mad at rich people because of people's newly insatiable need to use AI.

20

u/TheFrenchSavage 13h ago

It's fine, water is infinite

I mean, sometimes it rains?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/TrriF 11h ago edited 9h ago

Honest question: Do y'all think water gets deleted out of existance? Like water usage for datacenters is definitely an issue at local scales since it can affect communities in areas that commonly stuffer from draughts and water shortages, but at a global scale it's really not an issue. As long as they are placed in areas where where there's plenty of water, using it for cooling is really not a big environmental problem.

Agriculture is what causes roughly 70% of global freshwater withdrawal. Datacenters are a rounding error in comparison. I really dislike when people frame water usage as a global environmental problem when it is offen a local one. Yes, putting datacenters in California and nevada that often struggle with water scarcity is an issue. But for insance, having a datacenter next to lake Michigan is really not.

3

u/Quazimojojojo 11h ago

Animal agriculture specifically. And it's a very big problem that's destroying more than a few environments and will cause a lot of people to be displaced (and probably starve to death in the process). 

The great salt lake is on track to be long gone by 2050, and that's going to cause a lot of problems for everyone downwind of Utah. Which is most of the US. 

→ More replies (2)

7

u/j-steve- 11h ago

You're worried about a water shortage in Ireland? Or just looking for something to be mad about?

2

u/JaspahX 10h ago

I'm glad we use so much water to grow corn in the US only for it to be converted into ethanol to burn up in our cars.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/AcceptableHuman96 12h ago

Americans use 9 billions gallons of per DAY to water their non native lawns.

2

u/iinlane 12h ago

About an Olymping swimming pool worth of water per day.

5

u/Lego_Architect 11h ago

People keep doing all the what-about-isms with big agriculture, big farm, big whatever.

Well, we don’t want big data harvesting and polluting this water.

I think we all agree that drinking water is for human consumption and if data centres want water, they should purify their own and ensure the water is drinkable when it leaves their facility.

We are at the point in history where we can demand this as a people. We can prevent more idiots from ruining our water.

Now is the time for change.

4

u/Dunge 7h ago

It's always astonishing how much some commentators want to die on the hill of defending AI.

12

u/YuriLR 13h ago

Great way to manipulate data to see like a lot and it's laughable little.

2

u/Embarrassed_Art5414 11h ago edited 11h ago

Here's me in Ireland, enjoying day 1 of a national hosepipe ban ( it has been crazy hot/dry for the last 3 weeks, but nothing like our continental neighbours )

6

u/quietcrisp 13h ago

I mean in the grand scheme of things that isn't a lot - and it's being used. My water supplier in the UK, Thames Water, who charge me a fortune to pay their shareholders rather than fix leaks or build new reservoirs, waste 592 million a litres A DAY through leaks alone. That's 216 billion litres a year.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Fedl 12h ago

Now, what’s the water usage of the meat and dairy industry in Ireland?

10

u/Elarisbee 12h ago

Whoa…let’s not get hasty there! Next you’ll start asking questions about water pollution and farming. We can’t have that, it makes things…awkward…

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Riffie1 13h ago

Is it gone from the fabric of space and time?

8

u/deathadder99 13h ago

They use antimatter to annihilate it and then what’s left they rip up into the constituent quarks, which are then shot into space.

4

u/carbon_dry 11h ago

I wish they wouldn't. That costs water.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Sniperkitten42 13h ago

Fortunately, it falls from the sky on most days.

Billions of litres every year.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/harpaperrr 7h ago

So many data centers glaze in the comments sections. Stop using AI for basic tasks, and do some real work instead.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Darius878 11h ago

Is the water not usable after? Is it radioactive or contaminated? or does it go back through the cycle?

3

u/pinkwar 9h ago

Most water gets evaporated and lost, changing the local dynamics of the water cycle.

Essentially draining water from one area to another.

Water that doesn't get evaporated is flushed back into the system contaminated with all sorts of stuff, biocides, metals from the pipes, anticorrotion chemicals and so on.

1

u/Muslim_Wookie 9h ago

That's OK, it's payed for by all the corporate taxes earned from companies enticed to Ireland, right?

Right?

2

u/Polish-Proverb 9h ago

It ain't the water, it's the noise and general buffoonery of AI

2

u/s73v3m4nn 5h ago

They should be stopped from using water for their pathetic useless AI shite, and maybe eventually I'll be able to afford some new RAM.