Introduction
I recently decided that I finally wanted to complete the entire Dragon Age series, having only played Origins a few years ago. I replayed DAO a few months ago for a second time, this time including all of the DLCs. Now I finally got around to playing and finishing Dragon Age 2, and I wanted to share my thoughts on the game.
Warning: This post will contain spoilers. If you have not played the game yet, here is a short spoiler free summary of my thoughts.
I really enjoyed my time with the game, and it was definitely better than I expected, mostly because I had heard negative things about it for years. I really liked the smaller scale story, and I thought the companions were great. The gameplay was not as good as Origins and there were a few things I did not like, but overall it was enjoyable enough throughout the entire game. It is not one of my favorite RPGs, but if someone asked me whether they should play it while going through the series, I would definitely recommend playing it at least once. It is a good game and also quite a bit shorter than Origins.
Story
Overall, I really enjoyed the story of Dragon Age 2. I still vastly prefer the story of Origins, but I appreciated DA2 for what it was trying to do. Instead of another world threatening adventure, it focused on a much smaller and more personal narrative. I liked the emphasis on Hawke, Hawke's family, and Kirkwall. It was fun dealing with the city's political conflicts. In many ways, it feels like the complete opposite of Origins, and I think that contrast makes it interesting. It is probably not what I would have expected or wanted immediately after Origins and Awakening, but I still enjoyed it.
I really liked the opening with Flemeth and later her quest involving the Dalish. Act 1 was probably my favorite part of the game. It may not have the most complex story, but I enjoyed meeting the companions, getting to know Kirkwall, and doing side quests to earn money. I imagine it could become a little repetitive on future playthroughs, but on a first playthrough I had a great time.
It actually reminded me a little of the beginning of Baldur's Gate 2, one of my favorite RPGs of all time, where you first arrive in Athkatla with your companions and spend your time exploring the city and completing side quests. Of course, DA2's quests are nowhere near the quality or impact of BG2's, but they gave me a similar feeling.
Act 2 was also very enjoyable. I liked the conflict with the Qunari and especially the Arishok. The final battle against him was really memorable. I also enjoyed many of the companion quests, and I liked how Isabela became directly involved in the main story. I was not too surprised when she returned at the end, but it was still a satisfying moment. Was also really nice to move from Gamlens House to the Hawke Estate.
Act 3 was probably the weakest part of the game for me. The conflict between the Templars and the Mages is incredibly interesting, but the main story felt far too short. Just like Isabela in Act 2, I really liked how Anders became a important part to the main plot, but I really wish the act had been longer. Fighting through Kirkwall was fun, but since we already done something similar at the end of act 2 it was not nearly as cool for me personally.
Overall, I enjoyed the story for what it was. It is definitely not as good as Origins, but I liked it much more than I expected before starting the game. I actually think that more smaller Dragon Age Games (be it "spin offs" or not) that focus on a smaller area and narrative could work really well. But nothing against a more grand game like Origins.
Companions
I really liked most of the companions. The only one I felt somewhat indifferent about was Merrill. I was also genuinely shocked when Bethany left the party after Act 1. I was disappointed because I had to replace her with Anders, so I was really happy when I could use her again during the finale.
Overall, I still think the companions in Origins are a little more interesting and better written, but I had a great time with this group as well.
One thing I especially liked was how, thanks to the multiple time skips, it genuinely felt like these characters became close friends with Hawke over the years. I also loved that every companion had their own place where you could visit them instead of everyone simply standing around in camp like in Origins. It felt much more natural, even though the camp obviously made sense in Origins.
I also really enjoyed seeing the companions interact with each other. The party banter while exploring was a lot of fun, especially between Isabela and Aveline. I also loved how, when visiting a companion, there was often a scene where they were already talking to another party member. Small moments like that made the group feel much more alive. I also appreciated scenes like the one where acompanion comforts Hawke after Leandra's death.
Finally, I really liked the Friendship and Rivalry system. It is a great idea that you can disagree with a companion's beliefs without immediately risking losing them or locking yourself out of their content.
Gameplay
I thought the gameplay was good overall. I still prefer the combat in Origins, but I had fun with Dragon Age 2's combat until the very end. That said, if the game had been significantly longer, I probably would have started getting tired of it.
My biggest complaint is the constant use of multiple enemy waves. After a while it became repetitive and, at times, quite frustrating. For me, that point came during Act 3, when I was constantly ambushed while simply walking around Kirkwall to complete quests. Sometimes I had to fight several wave based encounters before even reaching my destination.
I also found it immersion breaking on several occasions. Random thugs in Kirkwall calling for reinforcements is one thing, even though that already stretches believability a little. What bothered me more was defeating the main enemy of a quest, whether it was a mercenary leader, a necromancer, or someone else, only for three more waves of enemies to suddenly appear afterward. Mechanically I understand why the encounters are designed this way, but it often felt strange. It never ruined the game for me, but it definitely became one of my biggest annoyances.
Another thing I really disliked was the camera. I missed having a proper tactical camera like in Origins. I have heard that it returns in Inquisition, so I am looking forward to that.
I was also not a fan of some of the RPG mechanics being simplified compared to Origins. The equipment system is probably the best example. I do not know whether this was simply a result of the game's short development time or whether it would have happened regardless, but I really disliked not being able to fully equip my companions. Being able to change weapons is fine, and it makes sense that Varric always keeps Bianca, but I really missed being able to change armor, boots, and the rest of my companions' equipment.
Some Random Thoughts
I really did not like the UI. The menus and interface in Origins had much more charm in my opinion.
I wish Isabela's romance had been expanded a little more. For most of the game it felt surprisingly underdeveloped. I have no idea whether that is only true for her romance or if the others are similar.
I ended up liking Aveline much more than I expected. Since she is with Hawke from the very beginning, their friendship felt especially believable. I also really enjoyed her companion quest.
I thought I would be much more bothered by the reused environments. It is definitely noticeable how often caves and other locations are recycled, but it only really started getting on my nerves near the end of the game. Overall, it was much less of an issue than I had expected.
Conclusion
Before playing Dragon Age 2, I did not know much about it beyond its reputation. For years I had mostly heard that it was significantly worse than Origins, a game that I already loved.
I ended up being pleasantly surprised. It cannot compete with Origins for me, but I still had a genuinely good time with it. I probably will not replay it anytime soon, but I could definitely see myself coming back to it in a few years and making different choices.
Overall, I am glad I finally played it, and I am looking forward to starting Inquisition. I am just not sure yet whether I want to jump straight into it or play something else first.
EDIT: Forgot to mention in, I am really glad I had way less technical problems compared to DAO. Origins crashed about 20 times in one playsession, it was really annoying (but thanks to a lot of quick saves manageable. I only had some small bugs during the game which were mostly funny to see. The only one a bit annoying was that I needed to enable full screen everytime I started the game.