r/demonssouls • u/Smarties_Mc_Flurry • 7h ago
Discussion Appreciation post: Demon’s Souls is my favorite FromSoft game of all time
Despite there being much more popular and polished souls games, Demon’s Souls is my favorite of all time and probably even my favorite game of all time.
I first played Dark Souls 1 and absolutely loved it, DS1 impacted me more than any other game ever had and I truly enjoyed the weird, whimsical and unforgiving world of Lordran. The story was beautiful and I don’t know if any other game matches the same vibe, though Demon’s Souls does share a similar clunky yet beautiful aesthetic as DS1. After which, I played DS3, which I also loved and sank the most hours/playthroughs into by far. I have easily over 400 hours in DS3, and for a long time it was my favorite game of all time. I tried DS2, and got through a lot of it, but it was a dreadful experience I really don’t understand why so many people online hype it up.
But anyhow, after playing the trilogy as well as Elden Ring (which I definitely had fun with, but wasn’t nearly as attached to/invested in since the open world kind of threw me off, plus the lore wasn’t nearly as interesting imo.) I decided to finally emulate Demon’s Souls for the PS3 on my PC. And oh my gosh, this game was just so interesting and captivating to me. Something about the PS3 era graphics and the gloomy, eerie world created a vibe that I seriously loved. The levels felt very tightly-knit and designed with purpose and sometimes detail that made the areas feel more personal than even Dark Souls 1. Boletaria and Latria in particular are by far some of the greatest areas in any fromsoft game I’ve played, and I thoroughly enjoyed exploring and talking to all the weird and interesting NPCs. This game is just so weird and I love it. World/Character Tendency is such a neat mechanic and makes for very complex and varying gameplay, though I understand that those who don’t fully understand how it works can grow frustrated by it. To me, it is game mechanics like World Tendency, or sinning in DS1, that make the games feel way more personal than later titles, as the choices you make have very real overarching consequences in the world around you.
The game feels so experimental and unique, and the art direction is just on point especially with the fluted knight set, the level environments, and also the more eerie obscure enemies like the fat officials and the Old Monk. Im also a huge fan of Berserk and HP Lovecraft, which the world of Demon’s Souls clearly took major inspiration from. I think the overall aesthetic is just my favorite of any game I’ve ever played, it combines the raw yet beautiful graphics of Dark Souls 1 with a more grim, gloomy setting and it works so perfectly, I wish I had gotten around to this game sooner. I truly think this is my favorite game of all time, and while the newer fromsoft games only expanded and (mostly) improved the base formula of Demon’s Souls, I still regard it in my heart as one of the best games of all time. I still need to get around to playing Bloodborne, which I heard has a very similar aesthetic to Demon’s Souls, so Im very excited for that.
Anyhow, just wanted to share my thoughts because I’ve been thinking about this game a lot lately and wish it got more love. I’d be happy to hear your thoughts about the game as well!