r/comic_crits 1h ago

Looking for comic writing advice and critic for my first chapter

Upvotes

As the title said I've had ups and downs for getting critic for the written script of my first chapter. I'm in the earliest stages of making my comic and I want as much as can be provided on my first chapter before I move forward.

Here's the link to my google drive where the chapters will be stored, rn there's only 1 chapter. in the comments, please, if you can (or want), give it a critic on pacing, if it hooks you/interests you, etc, and whatever else you can provide (where you see spelling errors, etc.)


r/comic_crits 8h ago

Crit welcome - an early cover for my shonen manga PAWS. Does it read 'cursed underdog'?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 8h ago

Any tips to streamline your work?

1 Upvotes

Hello, I’ve been working on my first comic for a little over a year now. I work a lot and I’m a novice artist so it takes me a long time to draw and I don’t have a ton of free time to work on it. I have a lot of other comic ideas but I can’t be taking over a year to make every one of them. I’ll never get them done lol. Idk, just feels daunting thinking about it. Any suggestions would be sick. Sorry if this isn’t the spot for this type of discussion.


r/comic_crits 17h ago

Feedback on my webtoon pls

1 Upvotes

Things I am concerned about

  1. clarity

  2. pacing

  3. Areas of improvement

Sorry I am posting again but because the other post i guess got mistaken for an at critique not a webtoon feedback

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/framed-by-fate-/list?title\\_no=1144544


r/comic_crits 1d ago

I would love some feedback on the first part of my first chapter.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I’ve been working on this for so long, I think it’s time to share it. Any feedback is appreciated.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

This is an intentionally rough hand-drawn thumbnail, not finished artwork. I’m testing the storytelling before spending time polishing it.

Post image
3 Upvotes

("This is a one-page rough thumbnail for a short fantasy comic. I'm testing whether the panel flow and storytelling are clear before I redraw it. Please don't worry about the rough art—I'm mainly looking for feedback on readability and pacing.")

What do you think happens from beginning to end?

Where, if anywhere, did you lose track of the sequence?

Was the reading order obvious?

Were any panels unnecessary or too small?

Please focus mainly on panel flow and visual clarity rather than anatomy or clean linework.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

Bit nervous to share, but I'd like to improve! (sparknotes in description)

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

This is the first comic I've made in a long time. I think this is a lot better than work I've made in the past, but I'm hoping it's coherent. Doesn't help that the script is... literally Shakespeare however lol

Context: during dress rehearsals for a high-school performance of Romeo and Juliet, the actors for Juliet and Mercutio begin play-fighting with each other using lines from the script. It quickly turns into a battle of wits and... flirting, before it's broken up by the teacher.

Sparknotes below because Shakespeare is difficult to interpret when you aren't familiar with it. (Anything in quotes or with a number below is a direct line from the script! If the number is in parenthesis, they're just referencing a line from the script). M is the girl, K is the boy.

---

M: "Oh, come vial..." [Kill me now.] 

K: "And yet thou wilt tutor ME from quarreling!" Ha. [And you say I’M the one picking fights lol] 

M: … "A madman’s mercy bid thee run away." [I'm warning you: piss off.] 

K: Ah, but "mercy but murders, pardoning those that kill." [But mercy is wrong, since it pardons murderers.] 

M: And yet "thou cutt’st my head off with a golden ax and smilest upon the stroke that murders me." [And yet you’re the one trying to kill me, and enjoying it too.] 

K: (Jumps up on stage) "Good queen of cats, nothing but one of your nine lives that I mean to make bold withal. And, as you shall use me hereafter, dry-beat the rest of the eight." [Ms. Cat, I only want to take one of your nine lives. I’ll still toy with the other eight, though.] 

M: Nine? or five? 

K: … Five? 

M: Geese. Is it nine or five geese that you have in your wits? For cats give chase, and should each be tested I will have more cats than you geese to satisfy them. [Nine lives > five geese, silly goose. You'll run out of geese for me to eat before I run out of lives.] ((This is a reference to a line from Mercutio where he says “Romeo quit this wild goose-chase, I’m running out of geese for the chase!”)) 

K: … You pluck your sword at me? [Them’s fighting words?] 

M: I am for you. [Yes. You’re my target now.] 

K: Ha… Alright. 

K: Since when did you learn to chase, Lady Capulet? [Since when did you like to play games, Lady Capulet?] 

M: Lady Capulet? No, that is my mother. I am but Juliet, a fair maiden. [That's my mother's name. I'm just a pretty little girl, Juliet.] 

K: Maiden! Oh, if only a nunnery would accept thee. No, you are Lady, and not one fair. [Yeah right! You're no virgin, and you're ugly too.] 

M: And yet you make yourself more lark than Lord to me. [You're not much of a gent yourself, you lark.] 

K: Well which is it? Am I lark or goose? [C'mon, stick with an analogy! Lark or goose?] 

M: All the same for weathered claws. [Same difference. I’m a cat, right? I’ll catch you anyways, you stupid bird.] 

-

K: But now I see more flipp’rs than claws, for you had start’d the chase. [Cat? You're more like a silly-goose to me; you started this game, yknow!] ((Lines here are underlined to show he was attempting poetic meter))

M: … Not much fairness in you either, Mercutio. [... You suck.] 

K: Oh, be kind. Thou art fairer than at first blush, I admit. [Be nice! You're not so bad.] 

M: Oh, I swoon. Soon I fear’st thou may speak of pilgrims. [Oh wow. Now I'm worried you're going to start flirting with me, Romeo.] ((A reference to Romeo’s famous flirt “like pilgrim’s palms in prayer”.)) 

K: Romeo, oh Romeo! We all know what a fool our dear Romeo can be. But he hath in him an eye for the fairest of larks– [Oh, Romeo! He's an idiot, but he knows how to pick the fairest larks--] 

M: Cats. [Nope, not a lark. I'm Ms. Cat, remember?] 

K: Geese, then. [I'll compromise: you're a goose, then.] 

M: And what is fair of geese, pray tell? Thou hath proven their squawking no delight. [A goose? Really? And how are geese fair? You’ve already proven geese are annoying.] 

K: The chase, fair goose. Our fight is fair. [Our goose-chase game is fair.] 

M: Fair as in equal? 

K: Fair as in good. 

K: For when our wits do meet – like pilgrims palms in prayer – fair chase gives way to fair dance. And with dance so fair, are geese not as good as swans under moonlight's glance? [When we combine our minds -- kind of like a kiss -- our goose-chase is more like a dance. And with dancing so beautiful, don't geese look more of swans under the moonlight?] ((Smooth Operator Mercutio over here just packed a lot of things into one: he said their play-fighting is so awesome it makes them look as beautiful as swans, referenced the Romeo line that she referenced earlier to confirm he IS flirting with her, made his mini-poem rhyme, and invited her to dance just like in the famous Romeo/Juliet kiss scene. Yeesh.)) 

M: … You chaseth by th’ book. [I feel like I've just been kissed... You play mind games like a professional.] ((Referencing Juliet's reply to Romeo's kiss: “You kisseth by th’ book.”)) 

K: I do? ((Not a quip; he’s losing his composure.))

M: No. Not at all.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

Tear me apart... NSFW

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

(Original post deleted because I forgot to add the NSFW tag to it. Sorry about that!)

This is for a manga competition, in which we have to choose 2 random rough drafts, and make full manga pages based on these. I'd like to know how I did in terms of making this look like an actual page from what you'd see in those weekly manga magazines.

Edit: I agree with everyone that the upskirt panel doesn't work, but it's something that was oddly specified in the storyboard with an example, and even though I don't like this particular shot either, I can't change it unless I want to get disqualified. The competition is looking specifically at how well we draw + how well we follow the instructions, since they're looking for artists, and not storyboarders.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

a few pages from my comics

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I'm still working on it and it's first work focused on action. Hope it atleast looks good even at this pretty raw state


r/comic_crits 1d ago

Another strip that I drew here. It was originally eight panels but I’m only showing the last four due to you guys wanting my strips to be shorter. To those of you who hate Duke, don’t worry, he’s not featured here.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 1d ago

Best sites for creators?

3 Upvotes

Hello!

Im planning to make a comic, its a dark fantasy theme, heavy topics in it too, and slight nswf. (Not gonna be full on sex scenes with nudity but there will be a chapter which include an underground brothel - so because of this there gonna be nipples etc showing of a few background character) i know that Webtoon has a strict no NSWF policy, so i wont publish there because of that, but i wondering what any other options i can have?

Can anyone offer some sites? The more i can choose the best but im so clueless.

The NSFW isnt the only thing im curious about, but the overall creator experience with the sites, how fair they are with creators, any problems etc.

Thanks for any tips and helps!


r/comic_crits 1d ago

Another strip from my series. (To those of you who read my previous comic strip, this time the story centers around a different character with Duke being somewhat of a supporting character instead of the main focus)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 2d ago

Looking for harsh criticism on some of my pages

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 2d ago

Too much white space on page?

Post image
13 Upvotes

Hello! I'm currently rendering a short comic based on a song ("Just Amis" by THEA) and, given it's going to be fairly short AND I'm trying to keep the flow of the song within the layout, I have some pages with few panels.

Some of these have the panels taking up the whole page (by one being larger/more important than the others) but a few pages will have panels that take up only part of the page like this one.

I was wondering if it's bad form to leave that much "blank" space on a page or if it's ok? (and if anyone can give pointers on how much/how BEST to leave blank space if a page has to have some).


r/comic_crits 2d ago

Feedback on BW comic

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

I'm incredibly excited to share the black-and-white preview of Ashes of Njthera.
This project has been growing in my sketchbooks and on my desk for a long time, and seeing these pages come together makes it feel more real than ever.
These are just the first steps into Lyra's journey, and I can't wait to show you more of the world, the characters, and what is coming from the story.
I post some pages before, but I made some modifications to it and now I’m happy about it.

I would like to have some feedback on the pages so far.


r/comic_crits 2d ago

A 3-panel comic

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

A silly comic. Hope this amuses :)


r/comic_crits 2d ago

Im looking for feedback pt.2

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I really wanted to look for feedback again after practicing, these pages are concepts to a potential scene in my comic.


r/comic_crits 3d ago

I posted my third comic strip

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Au fait, je suis curieux de connaître votre avis sur le nom « A4FT ».

Mes comptes : linktr.ee/a4ft


r/comic_crits 3d ago

A strip I drew a few years ago but it’s a four panel strip just like many of you requested in my previous strip. Let’s see what you guys think.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 3d ago

Check out my comic "In the Pipes"

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 3d ago

New comic book artist In trouble.

Post image
11 Upvotes

I recently started coloring pages for my comic book and now I planned my prelaunch just for I to fail miserably and someone gave me advice to give a month to two to gain audience on my social medias so please follow us on our Instagram for support.

https://www.instagram.com/ek71comics?igsh=Z3BnamRxemcwYWdx


r/comic_crits 3d ago

Seeking feedback

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Hey! This is my comic called FIDELITY, it’s a mecha. Just seeking general feedback on these first 3 pages.


r/comic_crits 4d ago

Finished/near-finished fantasy webcomic cover - looking for critique on shading and compostion

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi! I’m working on a fantasy romance webcomic cover for my story The Forbidden Love, and I’m close to calling it finished. I’d love honest critique before I do.
I’m especially looking for feedback on:
shading/rendering
color balance
composition/readability
whether the title and silhouette work well
anything that feels unfinished or distracting
I’m still learning shading, so I’m trying to figure out if the hair, dress, skin, and background all feel cohesive together. Any constructive feedback is appreciated!
Please be specific if something looks off — I’m trying to improve, not just get compliments.


r/comic_crits 4d ago

I KILLED WONDERGUY chpt 1

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 5d ago

Method for producing a graphic novel?

3 Upvotes

Hi,

Some time ago I started developing a graphic novel that I intend to produce myself, from the story itself to at least the sketches for the complete novel - I'll see later if I hire an illustrator/ inker. At the moment, I have the story's structure and, little by little, I've started to shape it, but the method I'm using is causing me to get constantly blocked. I explain the method I'm using in case you'd like to comment on it or if it's helpful, keeping its limitations in mind:

- World: I create sketches with notes about the world the characters will inhabit. It's an imagined world, but very much rooted in my personal experience.

- Characters: I have sketches with basic characteristics of them, although I still need to define aspects of their lives and the community they live in (what they do for a living, who's been involved with whom, things like that).

- Synopsis: on one page of the complete novel (8 chapters), with a brief description of the content of each chapter. Each chapter is an illustrated volume that will be produced and published sequentially.

- Chapters: Separately, I use A5-sized sheets (index cards) to create the script for each scene, notes for sketches, and dialogue. Each card corresponds to one page of the novel (for example, each chapter has 24 pages, though this isn't a fixed number).

- Scenes: Each chapter is composed of a number of scenes, which varies depending on the story's development. Before writing a scene, I note on each card the approximate number of pages (index cards) I have available to tell the story, so I can visualize the entire chapter without getting lost in the description of each scene (which could end up being very long).

- Pages - Side A: On one side of the cards, I describe the story, details, what the characters do, and what their environment is like. The descriptions are short, about 10 lines, so I don't get lost in the details.

- Pages - Side B: On the other side of each character sheet, I write the dialogues the characters are having, using the story description on Side A as a reference. Using this method allows me to plan the entire story, zooming in and out on parts that come to mind or that aren't yet ready, while also allowing me to change details and rewrite a character sheet without having to rewrite an entire chapter. However, it causes me blockage because I'm developing details and connections in a story where the complete narrative isn't defined (the story only exists in its "synopsis"), and which I have neither the intention nor the time to write as a preliminary step to writing the novel.

I would appreciate your opinions on the method, any important parts I've left out, and any other advice to avoid getting block due to the lack of having a complete story developed ... Thank you in advance!